Looking for some opinions on QT video

[salmonstk]

hey all, I am working on a "music video" project with iMovie and have recently posted to my web site.

I am looking for some opinions on it. Its 20 MB so modem users beware.


Its under the movie section of course.

Criticize away... (http://homepage.mac.com/salmonstk)

[AppleMaster]

I thought it was excellent.

If you want some really picky criticism, I'd say:
1. The text at the beginning might be displayed a little too quickly.
2. The audio of both Kennedy and King takes away a little from the song and sort of interrupts loudly, but it still is good. I'm not sure what I would do with it...

But, I really do like it. Very professional looking...It goes to show what amazing things can come out of iMovie with an idea and a little talent. Good work!

[salmonstk]

Thanks for the suggestions.

BTW I used to live in Cleveland.

[salmonstk]

I hate to bager but could some other people comment if you have the time. I would really like some feedback- good or bad.

[DaveLee]

I thought it was very good as well. Very evocative.

I agree that the inital text maybe fades in and out a little quickly, but it kind of adds to the theme like that.

I think the fades could be a little too similarly timed, it makes it a bit regular (but I am not sure if that was your intention). And the pans could also vary a little more in speed (some coming in or out a little slower for example). Otherwise, fantastic. I would be proud if this were my production.