Watch: Apple's Siri on iPhone X vs. Samsung's Bixby Voice on Galaxy S9+

AppleInsiderAppleInsider
Posted:
in iPhone
Concluding AppleInsider's in-depth comparison of flagship smartphones from dueling tech titans Apple and Samsung, we take a closer look at the pair's respective virtual assistant technologies, Siri and Bixby Voice.





While not as exciting as top spec sheet items like new processors and displays, smart assistants are an important feature that makes a big impact on day to day usage.

For our test, we set the devices side by side and asked a series of questions to test the speed, capability and effectiveness of each brand's technology. Queries ranged from system-level commands like photo viewing to internet- and app-based questions.

For example, we asked both assistants to pull up recent photos and video, calendar entries and messages with varying success. Internet searches including weather forecasts and general queries fared a bit better, though the performance of app-based commands that rely on user privileges was spotty at best.

Overall, Siri works faster and more accurately understands our voice, but Bixby is more capable especially when it comes to requests to do specific things on the device like sending photos, changing settings, opening, using, and closing apps, and creating contacts. Apple's strict privacy and security protocols are to blame for many of Siri's shortcomings, as iOS limits voice commands to a very narrow set of actions.

That said, Bixby is a very capable assistant despite being fairly new to market. It's wide purview over Galaxy system controls is especially useful, though some users might find such access disconcerting.

Siri vs Bixby

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 6
    acejax805acejax805 Posts: 109member
    I prefer Bixby over Google Assistant .Bixby can do actual tasks while Google Assistant can only do things based on search, very simple phone tasks, and what data they mine .
  • Reply 2 of 6
    franklinjackconfranklinjackcon Posts: 612member
    I love the boom shot!
  • Reply 3 of 6
    crossladcrosslad Posts: 527member
    And yet I still don’t know anyone who uses any assistant on their phone. 
  • Reply 4 of 6
    franklinjackconfranklinjackcon Posts: 612member
    crosslad said:
    And yet I still don’t know anyone who uses any assistant on their phone. 
    Really? I use mine a lot, it's much easier than digging into apps/settings. Although now that I have smart speakers at home, I use it less on the phone but that makes the assistant even more useful than before.
  • Reply 5 of 6
    jbdragonjbdragon Posts: 2,311member
    franklinjackcon said:
    crosslad said:
    And yet I still don’t know anyone who uses any assistant on their phone. 
    Really? I use mine a lot, it's much easier than digging into apps/settings. Although now that I have smart speakers at home, I use it less on the phone but that makes the assistant even more useful than before.
    I use Siri all the time on my Apple Watch. It's really useful. I can control my growing Homekit house with it for example. It comes in handy to answer a question.
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 6 of 6
    jcs2305jcs2305 Posts: 1,337member
    franklinjackcon said:
    crosslad said:
    And yet I still don’t know anyone who uses any assistant on their phone. 
    Really? I use mine a lot, it's much easier than digging into apps/settings. Although now that I have smart speakers at home, I use it less on the phone but that makes the assistant even more useful than before.
    I use Siri to send a text or call someone while in the car, or set a timer while cooking. I still find it strange seeing people ask questions to their phone in public. It's just weird and awkward to me for some reason.. I don't know why, but it is.
Sign In or Register to comment.