Apple's Siri integrates sound clips including animals, musical instruments and vehicles

Posted:
in General Discussion edited December 2020
Released in tandem with iOS 14.3, Apple on Monday introduced a new feature to Siri that enables the virtual assistant to play back short audio clips when queried about specific sounds.

Siri


Spotted by CNBC, the new capability is somewhat limited, though that could change if Apple continues to build out Siri's sound library. Apple says there are hundreds of options, but finding what audio is supported boils down to trial and error.

As of this writing, Siri can reproduce animal noises, sounds from musical instruments, and audio recordings of vehicles. The publication found these questions trigger the new audio clip feature:
  • "Hey Siri, what does a humpback whale sound like?"
  • "Hey Siri, what does a toy poodle sound like?"
  • "Hey Siri, what does a harp sound like?"
  • "Hey Siri, what do firetrucks sound like?"
Independent testing shows other animals like lions, tigers, spotted hyena and more. Vehicles include regional ambulance and police car samples, while instrument audio is limited to a range of common woodwinds, brass, percussion and strings.

The feature appears to be an extension of Siri's Knowledge base and is presented as "Knowledge" on iOS 14.3. Queries result in a pop up pane that provides a brief
Wikipedia summary of the requested item and an audio clip that automatically plays when invoked. Users can listen to the audio again by tapping the play icon.
gregoriusm

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 8
    Humpback whale sounds like “insert Siri web search list here.” Must not be available yet in Winnipeg. 
    elijahgequality72521
  • Reply 2 of 8
    elijahgelijahg Posts: 2,759member
    How lovely, now if only they could put as much work into the basics.

    Siri has terrible understanding, just processing each word at a very basic level rather than the sentence as a whole. Asking it to for example "Add chicken and mushroom pies to my shopping list" usually (but not always) results in "Ok, I've added those two things". But then when I want it to add more than one separate item, for example "add chicken, mushrooms and milk to my shopping list" it adds them as one item. Its understanding really has been in alpha since day one. Considering Apple's smarts in AI elsewhere, its weird that Siri is the worst performer of the class. Another example, today I tried to get my HP to facetime audio with my dad, and it was insistent it should play some obscure song instead. 4 attempts and it finally called him. Why?!
    gregoriusmtokyojimuBeatsbyronl
  • Reply 3 of 8
    This is headed somewhere; perhaps a future accessibility/AR play, e.g., being able to recognize and playback sounds from the environment. Siri could gain the onboard capacity to identify sounds in one's surroundings for the hearing impaired. At least that's where I'd like to see it go.
    edited December 2020
  • Reply 4 of 8
    Rayz2016Rayz2016 Posts: 6,957member
    elijahg said:
    How lovely, now if only they could put as much work into the basics.

    Siri has terrible understanding, just processing each word at a very basic level rather than the sentence as a whole. Asking it to for example "Add chicken and mushroom pies to my shopping list" usually (but not always) results in "Ok, I've added those two things". But then when I want it to add more than one separate item, for example "add chicken, mushrooms and milk to my shopping list" it adds them as one item. Its understanding really has been in alpha since day one. Considering Apple's smarts in AI elsewhere, its weird that Siri is the worst performer of the class. Another example, today I tried to get my HP to facetime audio with my dad, and it was insistent it should play some obscure song instead. 4 attempts and it finally called him. Why?!

    I've had a fun morning with this. I didn't have a shopping list so I created one and started playing.

    I tried:

    Add chicken and mushroom pies to shopping list

    and it worked.

    So then I tried:

    add chicken, mushrooms and milk to my shopping list

    and it added it as a single item. 

    Mmm. Then it occurred to me that the problem might be that I didn't have a list called "my shopping list" so I deleted the entry and tried again with this:

    add chicken, mushrooms and milk to shopping list
    Note that I missed the my from the phrase because that's not the name the shopping list.

    And it worked, correctly adding 3 separate items to the list.

    So I wiped the items and tried again with 

    Add chicken and mushroom pies to my shopping list
    And it didn't work. I had a single item on the list.

    So I tried again with:

    add chicken, mushrooms and milk to shopping list

    And it worked! Three items on the list.

    So, I wiped and tried again with:

    Add chicken and mushroom pies to my shopping list

    I expected it to fail, but it worked. And I haven't managed to get it to fail since. Not only that, but it worked first time when I tried it on my other devices.

    My best guess is that after a couple of tries, it eventually worked out what I was getting at, and then learned to accept both variations of the phrase.

    Pity I don't need a shopping list after all that!

    My results with Siri have been getting better the more I use it. I suspect the problem might be that Siri learns better from some people than it does from others. Not sure why. It could be that working in software for many years, I might have a better intuitive understanding of what's going on behind the scenes. Interesting that I didn't try using my shopping list when I knew that wasn't the name of the list, though adding the (needless) extra word is probably standard human behaviour.

    Still, Siri learned what was going on after a couple of tries. 

    Fascinating.

    edited December 2020 fastasleepelijahgbyronl
  • Reply 5 of 8
    Rayz2016Rayz2016 Posts: 6,957member

    carthusia said:
    This is headed somewhere; perhaps a future accessibility/AR play, e.g., being able to recognize and playback sounds from the environment. Siri could gain the onboard capacity to identify sounds in one's surroundings for the hearing impaired. At least that's where I'd like to see it go.
    Good thinking.

    Mrs Rayz2016 reckons this will be a godsend for homework assignments. 

    As you say, this is leading to something much bigger.

    Let's look at the real reason that Apple coughed up some serious coin for Shazam. As well as being able to identify songs by listening to them, Shazam was also working on a similar visual search technology when Apple bought them out.

    Furthermore, a couple of sites have noted an increasing in activity from Apple's web crawlers, which they believe is being used to build up their own search index.

    So my own guess is that Apple is looking to bring something else in-house: a Siri-based search engine that works can work with the camera and the microphone as well as through text and multimedia elements on screen, and without sending your personal details to folk you don't know.


    fastasleep
  • Reply 6 of 8
    But, Rayz 2016, I’d be curious to know how Siri responded to those queries after a hard reboot. Whenever I do a hard reboot my iPad Siri suddenly starts spelling my sister Steffanie as the more common spelled Stephanie . Even though it has been spelling her name correctly for months. Also she suddenly starts misspelling my granddaughter Ellie as Eli. I hate when I’m forced to do a hard reboot due to some thing or the other not working. because suddenly Siri forgets all that she has learned about me personally.
  • Reply 7 of 8
    BeatsBeats Posts: 3,073member
    carthusia said:
    This is headed somewhere; perhaps a future accessibility/AR play, e.g., being able to recognize and playback sounds from the environment. Siri could gain the onboard capacity to identify sounds in one's surroundings for the hearing impaired. At least that's where I'd like to see it go.

    Maybe that's where Shazam tech is going? Hopefully.
  • Reply 8 of 8
    elijahgelijahg Posts: 2,759member
    Rayz2016 said:
    elijahg said:
    How lovely, now if only they could put as much work into the basics.

    Siri has terrible understanding, just processing each word at a very basic level rather than the sentence as a whole. Asking it to for example "Add chicken and mushroom pies to my shopping list" usually (but not always) results in "Ok, I've added those two things". But then when I want it to add more than one separate item, for example "add chicken, mushrooms and milk to my shopping list" it adds them as one item. Its understanding really has been in alpha since day one. Considering Apple's smarts in AI elsewhere, its weird that Siri is the worst performer of the class. Another example, today I tried to get my HP to facetime audio with my dad, and it was insistent it should play some obscure song instead. 4 attempts and it finally called him. Why?!

    I've had a fun morning with this. I didn't have a shopping list so I created one and started playing.

    I tried:

    Add chicken and mushroom pies to shopping list

    and it worked.

    So then I tried:

    add chicken, mushrooms and milk to my shopping list

    and it added it as a single item. 

    Mmm. Then it occurred to me that the problem might be that I didn't have a list called "my shopping list" so I deleted the entry and tried again with this:

    add chicken, mushrooms and milk to shopping list
    Note that I missed the my from the phrase because that's not the name the shopping list.

    And it worked, correctly adding 3 separate items to the list.

    So I wiped the items and tried again with 

    Add chicken and mushroom pies to my shopping list
    And it didn't work. I had a single item on the list.

    So I tried again with:

    add chicken, mushrooms and milk to shopping list

    And it worked! Three items on the list.

    So, I wiped and tried again with:

    Add chicken and mushroom pies to my shopping list

    I expected it to fail, but it worked. And I haven't managed to get it to fail since. Not only that, but it worked first time when I tried it on my other devices.

    My best guess is that after a couple of tries, it eventually worked out what I was getting at, and then learned to accept both variations of the phrase.

    Pity I don't need a shopping list after all that!

    My results with Siri have been getting better the more I use it. I suspect the problem might be that Siri learns better from some people than it does from others. Not sure why. It could be that working in software for many years, I might have a better intuitive understanding of what's going on behind the scenes. Interesting that I didn't try using my shopping list when I knew that wasn't the name of the list, though adding the (needless) extra word is probably standard human behaviour.

    Still, Siri learned what was going on after a couple of tries. 

    Fascinating.

    That's very interesting, I come from a software and hardware background so I do the same, I try to construct queries the way Siri will understand best but I hadn't thought about dropping the "my". There must be some understanding that the "my" is superfluous, else it would always fail as "my shopping list" doesn't exist. It is really weird that "my" has an effect only on multiple list items though - and that it's fine to have single items with "my shopping list" not without. 

    Of course we shouldn't have to say things in a contrived robotic way, otherwise it's no better than Classic Mac's speakable items.
    gatorguy
Sign In or Register to comment.