Posts by Tulkas

Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy  No sir. I tried as best I could to explain why and can't think of anything more to help you understand something you're obviously struggling with. I'll let you and the handful of...

Quote: Originally Posted by whatever71    The german court tried to find that samsung infringed but they had no jurisdiction to do so.  So to put a statement on the apple site but not explain that...

Quote: Originally Posted by arrowspark  The judge is right.  Apple's Statement is so convoluted and long.  They turned what could have been stated VERY CLEARLY in two sentences into a whole...

Quote: Originally Posted by whatever71    Give up Gatorguy, we just have to accept that some apple fans simply won't see other side of arguments & think that one of the fairest & most respected...

Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy  Then if there's a valid EU-wide judgement from the German courts Apple should enforce it. . .  Oh, wait.... I never claimed the could enforce it. The UK courts saw to...

Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy  Not to the best of my knowledge it was not. It only concerned a preliminary sales ban within the German borders with any actual ruling of infringement coming at a later trial on...

Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy  Yes, quite sure. You'e making the mistake of mixing a preliminary finding that even if valid would apply to only a single country (Germany) with a final ruling from the UK action...

Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy  Argue all you want. There is no valid finding of infringement of Apple's Community Design by any German Court. Period. Did a german court find that Samsung infringed?

Quote: Originally Posted by whatever71    I think you'll find that the telegraph link is irrelevant as the english court decision hadn't overruled that when the article was published on 24th July....

Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy  Tulkas, the problem arose when Apple continued to press for a preliminary injunction on the Tab 7.7 in Germany during and even after the UK judgement that applied to the...