Define “examined”. Did you ask her if she bought an iPod since? If she has purchased any iPod or other portable device for the purpose of music playback since the initial allegation, her argument is void. No, the train has been plummeting off a cliff for quite a while now. Can this be dismissed on the grounds of criminal stupidity? YOU WASTED NINE YEARS. WHY DO YOU THINK WE’LL BELIEVE YOU?!