Posts by muppetry

Quote: Originally Posted by sammi jo  Quote: Originally Posted by muppetry    Disclosure of intelligence sources or intelligence gathering technology is one cause for...

Quote: Originally Posted by tonton  Quote: Originally Posted by muppetry  Quote: Yes, I was arguing a strict interpretation, because that's what MJ is arguing in his claim that...

Quote: Originally Posted by tonton  Yes, I was arguing a strict interpretation, because that's what MJ is arguing in his claim that government is fundamentally immoral. In the context of government vs....

Quote: Originally Posted by tonton  Quote: Originally Posted by muppetry  Quote: Originally Posted by MJ1970  Quote: Originally Posted...

Quote: Originally Posted by BR  Quote: Originally Posted by muppetry    So that's where some of their ideas seem a bit off track. Many interpretations of NAP accept the need...

Quote: Originally Posted by BR  Quote: Originally Posted by muppetry    The law - the legal system. NAP does not preclude an institutional judicial process. And...

Quote: Originally Posted by BR  Who is the arbiter of these decisions?  To whom can I redress a grievance if someone else's interpretation of an act of defense differs from my own?  What level of force is...

Quote: Originally Posted by BR  Quote: Originally Posted by muppetry    And there you go - in one short paragraph you make the case - argument over. Why didn't you just do...

Quote: Originally Posted by MJ1970  Quote: Originally Posted by muppetry  I disagree.   OK.     Quote: Originally Posted by...

Quote: Originally Posted by MJ1970  Quote: Originally Posted by muppetry    No - tonton presented a credible (though refutable) counterexample argument, and you...