Quote:
Originally Posted by
tonton 
No time to respond to your whole post... I may get to it... but I had to point out:
Intelligent people don't polarize.
I'll try to remember that. Especially when those who are claimed to be intelligent do exactly that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tonton 
To say that "raising the minimum wage or mandating a variety of employer-provided benefits are good things for the poor as a whole" is just as wrong...
Some people who are generally considered intelligent say that raising the minimum wage* will help the poor. This notion is, quite often, offered in a categorical way just as I have stated it here such as: "raising the minimum wage will help the poor." The implication here is that it will help the poor
as a whole.
Furthermore, these same intelligent people often reject
any notion that that raising the minimum wage might hurt
some of the poor (or have no net positive effect). This suggestion is often dismissed as merely right-wing, free-market talking points or kookiness or some such similar dismissal. Perhaps a dash of implication about how the person pointing this out probably doesn't care about the poor and probably even hates them.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tonton 
...is just as wrong as it would be to say that "raising the minimum wage or mandating a variety of employer-provided benefits are bad things for the poor as a whole."
I'm pretty certain I've ever said that. I
have pointed out how it affects people at the lower end of the wage scale and how this likely will negatively effect some (possibly many) poor people who are employed at that end of the wage scale.
I've also pointed out that there are a
number of policies that have been implemented in the spirit of
helping the poor (again this is never qualified so the implication is always helping the poor
as a whole** or
all** of the poor) that appear to have the net effect of hurting some (or many) of the poor.
I've also pointed out how various policies whether intended to help the poor or not actually hurt them.
*Mandating employer-provided benefits has the same basic effect as raising the minimum wage...raising the cost of the employee to the employer. Minimum wage is used in this example merely for the sake of simplicity.