Quote:
Originally Posted by insike 
You are kidding, right? You are comparing a mini-browser with the engine on a server to full browsers with the engine locally? If this isn't a joke, this site really needs to start laying off staff... Of course Opera Mini isn't going to pass Acid3. The way it works prevents it from doing that. Rendering on a server, remember? ...

You are kidding, right? You are comparing a mini-browser with the engine on a server to full browsers with the engine locally? If this isn't a joke, this site really needs to start laying off staff... Of course Opera Mini isn't going to pass Acid3. The way it works prevents it from doing that. Rendering on a server, remember? ...
Quote:
I guess you are the one man Opera mini defence team today but you really go a bit overboard here.
The reason Acid 3 is important and the reason this article is justified for it's (minimal) taking of Opera to task for failing it, is that Opera itself uses Acid 3 to tout it's superiority in it's own promotional materials and has or a long time. Opera has a history of throwing their Acid scores in everyone's face and making claims about how fantastically compatible they are with web standards.
It seems to me then that it's completely relevant, and quite proper for someone to take them to task for putting out a browser that not only *doesn't* pass Acid 3, but is forever incapable of passing Acid 3. This browser will literally *never* be standards compliant (by design!) as you yourself mention.
Secondly, you try to equate Safari with Opera by saying that Safari doesn't render pages properly either, but it's strictly Apples and Oranges and you know it. There are huge, noticeable, visual differences between pages rendered with Opera mini and the same page rendered on a standards compliant browser that the end user can see and have commented on. People have been posting all over the web about it as well as in the comments for the app in the store. That's completely a different order of "error" than Safari getting a 100/100 score and rendering a couple of minor page elements slightly differently.
Finally, you several times use the defence that Opera "isn't supposed to replace full browsers," but there is nothing about that on the app store page they sell it from. I've never heard anyone from Opera make this claim before either.
You are just twisting things around and making stuff up to suit your argument and are clearly biased.








\
