segovius, you've said a lot of sensible things in this thread, but this is not one of them. Setting aside the specific issue (i.e., "someone is gay") how can you categorically claim "it is impossible that A God who created the Universe could care" about X and dismiss such an idea as "nonsense?" In fact, isn't the opposite argument more likely (i.e., that a god that created the universe would care about what goes on in it, even to what might seem like inconsequential (to you or I) details)?
Because things like homophobia, racism, general stupidity etc are human weaknesses - I do not consider it possible that a being capable of creating a universe that contains gay people would be a homophobe.
Put another way: all powerful racist homophobic God would not create ethnic minorities or gays.
But this raises other issues.... the state of 'being gay' does not exist apart from life or creation, therefore God would not know he was homophobic until he created humanity and discovered it there. It's not very rational is it? And God if He exists would not be irrational....because the universe is not irrational.
Another issue; if God could feel being gay was a sin say (as the Fundies believe) then this calls up issues of Good and Evil....essentially it would mean that things were reversed.
The 'good' people would be Robertson, Falwell etc...
The 'bad' people would be people like the compassionate guy round the corner who has not a drop of hate in him but who just happens to be gay.
I don't believe it is possible but if it turns out to be the way it is then in the hereafter I shall not have the slightest hesitation when standing before this God in
a) Pledging allegiance to Satan
b) Begging forgiveness for all the bad things I ever said against Hitchens, Dawkins, Harris and all the rest of the dancing bears