Quote:
Originally Posted by
asdasd 
Can some mod take all the bullshit matte screen posts and dump them into a matte screen thread where they can wither and die, and the rest of us can get on discussing the actual announcement today.
I have a better idea. How about: Can some mod take all the bullshit
anti-matte screen posts and dump them into a jerk thread where they can whither and die?
Guess what? This
IS about today's announcement. Some of us held out hopes (albeit very small) that we might actually be able to buy a desktop machine from Apple at some point, but looks like that's not the case again for 2011. And it's apparently an important issue to a lot of people, regardless of your opinion. Unarguable, because enough people raised a stink that Apple caved and made it an option for the MacBook Pros, even though I'm sure they'd much rather keep it simple without extra hardware options.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
SSquirrel 
You can buy an antiglare filter or a monitor hood if needed. You could setup your workspace properly to remove glare. There are any number of things you can do that makes the glossy display a non-issue.
This is just not true, and it's really tiresome to hear people spout off nonsense like this. Anti-glare filters are bullshit. Problematic at best, to install, and they offer noticeable degradation in quality. Monitor hoods? Are you joking? Are we back in the 80s? An iMac is a consumer device that resides in the living room, bedroom, home office, etc. It's probably going to be in a relatively small space compared with a desk at work, and a big ol' hood is ridiculous.
And NO, it's not reasonable to ask people to rearrange their furniture, turn off the lights and close the drapes every time you want to spend some time at the computer.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
iMoan 
Yes, the world is dominated by teenagers ... And the only multitasking required is trying to see your content behind the reflection of your face.
Best quote of the entire thread.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
plokoonpma 
Why you think a glossy screen makes so much difference?
Maybe because it acts a fricking mirror?!
Not aimed at you in particular, but this is the saddest part of the whole debate. The fact that that many people don't seem to notice the reflections. What the hell is up with that? The reflections are there. Absolutely, unequivocally, there are serious reflections on glass screens. So what kind of tricks are people doing to fool their brains into ignoring them? I'm serious, I would love to know!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TBell 
I like Matte Screens better for some things such as working in photo shop and in areas where direct light is shining on the monitor. However, the iMac is billed as a consumer oriented machine. Gloss screens tend to look better for other things consumer like to do such as playing video.
Are you saying people prefer reflections when they watch video? Dimming the lights can help a lot when watching videos on a big-screen, but it's several feet away from you, so the % of the room that's in your reflected area is greatly reduced.
This is why it's not
as objectionable using a glossy screen on an iPhone/iPodTouch. It's much smaller, so a lot easier to diddle your position/angle as there's less reflected area behind you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TBell 
Matte screen users have options. You can buy a Mac Pro or a Mac Mini and bring your own monitor.
Kind of silly; Mac Pros are out of the question for most people. Mac Mini
is an option, but Apple continues to make them very under-powered, therefore unattractive performance-wise compared with iMac.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
myapplelove 
But the imac screen glare still remains an abberation.
I think you meant to type "abomination".
Quote:
Originally Posted by
SSquirrel 
I don't wear sunglasses to use my computer, I just manage the contrast and brightness properly.
Tweaking the contrast and brightness makes the reflections go away? Bwahahahaha!
You can help tone down the worst of it, but that's it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Goldenclaw 
You won't eliminate all glare, well maybe unless you live in a cave.
Even if you
are in a cave (or realistically, in a very dark room), that doesn't remove the reflections of your face from the light of the screen. Reflective screens suck.
--------
There may only be 1300 sigs on that petition, but there are way more than a few small percent of frustrated customers. The surveys put out a couple years ago showed that pretty solidly. A few more comments just to reiterate that there are a lot of people who care about this issue.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
elroth 
With a dark photo or a darkish movie scene, all I see is myself reflected in the glossy monitor (like Bin Laden, I moved out of my cave years ago).
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hamiltonrrwatch 
As for the matte screen, I'd like to see Apple offer it as an option. But these comments about "rearranging furniture" and "closing drapes" are just plain idiotic

It's a little more complicated for those of us who have vision problems and taking my iMac for a ride around the house isn't going to help.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
WelshDog 
That being said I prefer matte screen. If they don't make an iMac with matte screen I wouldn't buy one. Easy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Mode 
Add my voice to 'not buying until they make it useable'.
I bought my wife a 27" iMac and she had to move her office, block part of a window to be able to use it. Yah, it was stupid to buy it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
zunx 
No matte displays. No purchase. Sign the petition for Apple matte displays at:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Goldenclaw 
To put it simply, I get horrible headaches from glossy displays. It's very bad with the new iMacs, which I don't work with very long if I can avoid it.
Ok, so Apple and no one else cares. I get it. Workarounds include peeling off the front glass with sticky tape or suction, using an anti-glare adhesive (which has issues), and carefully controlling your environment. Or maybe flip the thing around and use another display externally. But you shouldn't have to do all this for a new computer. Or build a hackintosh.
The irony to me is that the original CRT displays were very glossy, and people had to get antiglare filters and hoods all the time. Then we get LCD and the glare goes away, but the native resolution is never where you like it and the scaling technology was terrible. Now you can get LCD's with high PPI, but they are glossy. Vicious.
I would have bought a Mac Mini in a heartbeat but the specs seem gimpish. Integrated GPU, 5400rpm laptop drive, still only 2GB RAM in default config. If they beefed up the Mini a bit or lowered the price I'd probably be all over it. But right now the specs aren't any better than my years old PC. Which is a real shame.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
MacRulez 
In short, Apple lowered to quality of the baseline configs to extract more money from their customers, knowing that most of them are like the posts I expect in reply to this one....
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Goldenclaw 
I have 20/10 vision and good eye movement and coordination. I am fortunate that the world is often presented quite clearly for me to see. I am grateful for it. What I don't need is for people telling me to accept a screen that I know isn't acceptable. I can barely tolerate the iPad in my bedroom with the lights out and curtains and shades down. I can't even take the thing outside.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
aaarrrgggh 
For me, it is purely the reflections. I sit in an office with the lights off and prefer the brightness to be in the mid-to-low range, as the higher brightness is hard on my eyes. Even at full brightness though, the black band is fully reflective. I have tried every permutation, including switching offices and any possible position of the unit, different lighting setups, etc, all to no avail.