Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
In a free society, such as the USA,
Well, I'm not so sure how "free" a society the US is any longer.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
the government has a responsibility to give it's citizens accurate information and teach critical thinking so as to equip them to be fully functional individuals.
I disagree that the state has this responsibility at all. But this is a difference in the philosophy go government we must have.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
In addition, our government has a directive within our constitution to not favor or include any religious education within what it mandates as necessary basic knowledge. Religious training is the province of the various religious leaders the student is being brought up to believe in. In this way the student has the freedom to accept either the secular world view or the religious view of various topics.
OK
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
I cannot understand how crippling a young thinker's mind so they lack the ability to do critical thinking gives them any ability to have the freedom of thought.
Who is proposing to do that? Who is it that wants to cripple a young person's mind so they lack the ability to do critical thinking? Based on outcomes, I would guess it is those who are running the public education systems today.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
I'm 69 years old and have seen the evolution of my government in its increasing awareness of its previous missteps with regard to religion, cultural sensitivity, and historical bias. We, as a body of citizens, are more aware and more inclusive then we were in the 1950s.
In some ways, yes. In some ways things aren't all that different.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
There is now, in the USA, a strong push to make the predominate religion, Christianity, a pseudo-State religion. This is being promoted by many conservative political leaders who are willing to forgo the constitutional separation of church and state.
Really? By whom? Where? Who is making this "strong push?"
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
There is, along with this idea a desire to "dumb down" science, eliminate many of the arts...
Really? By whom? Where? Who wants to "dumb down" science and eliminate the arts?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
...and move toward a more state-controlled press.
Yes, it would be bad if the state controlled the media. If, for example the President of the United States was suggesting or telling them what they should say about him and his campaign (or his opponent and his opponent's campaign).
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
...less like the liberty you profess to hold to.
I profess to hold a liberty in in which everyone is free. Everyone's basic rights of life, liberty and property are protected by their government. Not one in which some people's rights are trampled or infringed or ignored because some other people simply think they should be in order to apply this own set of values upon everyone. I profess to hold a liberty where the vast majority of interactions among people are voluntary rather than coerced.
This is the liberty I profess.
Do you have a problem with the kind of liberty where a) the government's job is to protect the basic rights of life, liberty and property of its citizens, b) the government does not infringe upon or ignore or restrict the basic rights of life, liberty and property of some of its citizens for the benefit of other citizens, and c) voluntary interactions, exchanges and arrangements are the order of the day rather than coerced interactions, exchanges and arrangements?
Do you have a problem with this kind of liberty?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
Those within the military or FBI that want to indoctrinate other people within the military or the FBI have a hopeless desire due to the critical reasoning their target audience has been allowed to develop during their growing process.
Their target audience is immune to this stuff because if the critical reasoning skills they've developed?! Now that's just laughable. That statement right there appears to demonstrate a disconnection of the reality in modern America.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
In a pluralistic society we cannot have liberty for some people and not others... especially when some people's idea of liberty is the right to control what and how young minds may do critical reasoning.
I agree. Who is it that you think wants to have "right to control what and how young minds may do critical reasoning"? Is is the people who wish to force every kid to be subject to the government schooling system or is the people who believe parents ought to have more choice in how, where and what their children are educated?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Macky the Macky 
We are all free when we have the ability to think freely and question freely and make judgments based on all the evidence available.
I agree. I don't believe the government schools are actually teaching, supporting or promoting that kind of thing at all.