Video editing is not the only situation 17" laptop was/is used (on location is a big one). The 17" laptop was the standard of the recording industry. Logic (or other DAW's) is simply to difficult to work on a 15" retina screen (live mobile situations). Many people in the recording industry would have bought a new laptop (even though the market is small). It is sad that people want to belittle those of us who wanted and were willing to pay for the extra's that came on a 17".
Recent Reviews
-
I was given the Ipod nano 6th generation for Christmas 2011. I was starting to take up running and needed something to track my run. since I just started I was only using my Ipod roughly 3 times...
-
I have had the iPad Verizon 4G LTE for a month now, and over all I couldn't be happier with the machine. The only issue I have found so far is when on wifi it has a slower speed in processing...
-
I have owned at least a dozen different Mac laptops over the years, starting with a Powerbook 1400 back in the day. The 13-inch Air is my absolute favorite of the bunch. It's the first laptop...
-
I spent quite a bit of time reading the setup manuals and various Apple articles about manually setting up this device since I have an unusual setup, and the setup manuals indicated I would have...
-
all i have to say is i love it its so much faster and i could just slip it into my purse p.s it has a ton of space for the 64gb
US MacBook sales drop 6% over 2012 holidays, NPD says - Page 3
- « Previous
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Next »
- SolipsismX
- Mogul Gaberator
- Joined: Nov 2011
- Location: The Ansible
- Posts: 12,569
- online
- Select All Posts By This User

Video editing is not the only situation 17" laptop was/is used (on location is a big one). The 17" laptop was the standard of the recording industry. Logic (or other DAW's) is simply to difficult to work on a 15" retina screen (live mobile situations). Many people in the recording industry would have bought a new laptop (even though the market is small). It is sad that people want to belittle those of us who wanted and were willing to pay for the extra's that came on a 17".
I know several coders that like the large display on the 17" paired with being portable. Means they can do "real" work from virtually any location. It's clear it was the lowest selling Mac notebook but I would have thought that it would have been popular enough to continue making.
Perhaps the move to the new design forced engineering issues on them they couldn't easily resolve without making it more expensive to a point they didn't feel was worth producing. Or perhaps it's just being delayed until the Mac Pro update this year. A professional event, so to speak.
Did you set up your two drives as a Fusion drive? I have had a similar setup with OptiBay in my MBP since 2010 but only until the announcement of Fusion did I do the logical pairing of the drives. I like it much better now over having my SSD as my boot/app drive and my entire 1TB HDD as my ~/user folder.
"Blank! BLANK! You're not looking at the big picture!"
"Blank! BLANK! You're not looking at the big picture!"

Video editing is not the only situation 17" laptop was/is used (on location is a big one). The 17" laptop was the standard of the recording industry. Logic (or other DAW's) is simply to difficult to work on a 15" retina screen (live mobile situations). Many people in the recording industry would have bought a new laptop (even though the market is small). It is sad that people want to belittle those of us who wanted and were willing to pay for the extra's that came on a 17".
I personally also preferred the 17", but the published figures from last year were that the 17" accounted for only 3% of MBP sales. Obviously, the number was small. And of those, some fraction will undoubtedly have accepted the 15" rMBP instead.
It raises the question of how large a niche must be to be viable. Apple obviously decided that the number of people who wanted a 17" was too small to justify.
I'm disappointed, but complaining isn't going to change anything.
- Tallest Skil
- Cartography!
- Joined: Aug 2010
- Location: 1 Geostationary Tower Plaza
- Posts: 24,515
- online
- Select All Posts By This User
I might not get what you were saying because I don't see how's that different than "anything today" like iOS. For example, I can already hold down on a day to create an event on my iPad.
The Android way: Our problems become your problems.
The Android way: Our problems become your problems.
Apple laptop sales are down? So are PC sales. By nearly twice as much?
*Shrugs.
We're in a rough world economy that has been struggling since 2008. People have it all on finding jobs...rising food and fuel bills which are far outstripping wage rises.
Apple jacked up the price of the iMac by a £100 here in the U.K (while dropping the DVD player which they'll happily charge you £60+ for.) To get a Fusion, i7 and top end GPU well over £2000+ Historically, very pricey.
Apple's laptop line look pricey on the retinas if you take away the fancy screens. The gpus aren't that hot on them. No optical. You have to really want that retina...
I have no doubt that the iPad has been laying waste to netbooks and crap wintel cheap laptops on the battlefield. While the economy has slowed purchase of Apple's premium computers. Apple's pc growth seems to have hit the ceiling. But that's been coming for a while...as the growth numbers declined over time.
Many people are exposed to Apple Stores. Apple are getting new customers. But many of the computers these days are all the machine most people need. They'll last longer than an average pc.
I guess computer sales will hover between 4-5 million. The iMac sales will get a bounce...but it was a year and a half out of date...and it could barely deliver them last quarter.
I think there's a case for making Apple computers a pricey cut. They're creeping upwards in price, correlating nicely with the hubris that saw Apple release 'maps' as the best mapping solution out there.
Lemon Bon Bon.

I know several coders that like the large display on the 17" paired with being portable. Means they can do "real" work from virtually any location. It's clear it was the lowest selling Mac notebook but I would have thought that it would have been popular enough to continue making.
While it's hard to have too much screen real estate when coding/debugging, the number of people doing this and in the market for a MBP is tiny relative to the general population. Same with other potential uses such as graphic design or (I believe someone mentioned) filmmaking or recording. All together they are a tiny percentage of potential customers.
On the other hand, maybe they should have treated the MBP 17" like the Mac Pro. Let the design languish (I mean, there isn't really much to improve with either, for the purpose they serve) but keep producing them with infrequent updates. The only problem is that they would have needed to make a Retina version of the MBP 17", with optical drive, or it would have quickly been irrelevant anyway.

There is a downside to Office when it comes to a "touch" interface, and that is it's so full of bells and whistles that it becomes nearly impossible to implement. Even Microsoft seems to cede that point on the Surface RT. Word, for example, has grown in complexity to the point where it can nearly perform as a word-processing program. That's a good thing for a sub-set of users that are highly skilled at designing with Word.
The broader set of users want to open whatever they want, read it, edit it, and create much simpler documents. A pdf document serves most of these functions except the last, and iWorks satisfies the bulk of latter.
Apple, on the other hand, seems to be of the mind to keep the iWork apps lean and clean and in balance with the overall iPad experience.
Most people don't use 95% of Office's functionality. So long as business feels the need to pay for overpriced software with features that the vast majority of users never touch, Office will thrive. But the times they are a changin'...
- Tallest Skil
- Cartography!
- Joined: Aug 2010
- Location: 1 Geostationary Tower Plaza
- Posts: 24,515
- online
- Select All Posts By This User
What was confusing? Computers are already far more powerful than is needed by a majority of the people that use them. When e-mail, and browsing (as of late, "browsing" has started to be called "Facebook", for which I want to punch people in the face really, REALLY hard) are all they do, they don't need Haswell. They don't need RAM. They don't need this or that or what have you.
All they need is an iPad. Or something even weaker.
That's Google alright. For a stupid company they sure do dumb things.
That's Google alright. For a stupid company they sure do dumb things.
- « Previous
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Next »
- US MacBook sales drop 6% over 2012 holidays, NPD says
Recent Discussions
- › Evernote gains reminders, Telltale's poker comes to iOS & Angry... 7 minutes ago
- › Mailbox for iOS gains native iPad compatibility 8 minutes ago
- › Apple announces WWDC 2013 keynote for Monday, June 10 11 minutes ago
- › New Microsoft Windows 8 ad turns Apple's Siri against her maker 13 minutes ago
- › Apple on pace to double lobbying spending on taxes, other issues 23 minutes ago
- › Half of Apple's MacBook Air lineup now sold out at Amazon ahead of... 25 minutes ago
- › Google's new 3D Maps destroy Manhattan in the wake of Apple's Flyover 30 minutes ago
- › Apple granted patents on push-to-talk, double-sided touch panel 38 minutes ago
- › With spotlight on it & Apple, Ireland calls for worldwide tax... 42 minutes ago
- › Apple investigating advanced AirPlay system with device-specific UIs 47 minutes ago
Recent Reviews
- › Apple iPod nano - 16GB, Silver MC526LL/A (6th Generation) by cc420
- › Apple iPad with Retina Display Wi-Fi + Verizon/Sprint 4G - 64GB,... by Aaron Krahn
- › 13.3-inch Apple MacBook Air MD231LL/A (Mid-2012) by ahilal
- › Apple Time Capsule - 2TB (MD032LL/A) by biyahero
- › Apple iPad Wi-Fi - 64GB, White (MD330LL/A) by raeganapril
- › Apple Magic Trackpad (MC380LL/A) by WisdomSeed
- › Aperture 3 by bcbcbroderick
- › 17-inch Apple MacBook Pro MD311LL/A (Late 2011) by bcbcbroderick
- › Apple iPod touch - 32GB, Black MC544LL/A (4th Generation) by bcbcbroderick
- › Apple iPod touch - 8 GB, White MD057LL/A (4th Generation) by bcbcbroderick
New Apple Wikis
- › 2013 'Modified' iPod touch by Mikeycampbell81
- › 2013 MacBook Pros by Mikeycampbell81
- › iPad mini 2 with Retina display by Mikeycampbell81
- › 2013 iPhone 5S by Mikeycampbell81
- › Trade in your old devices for holiday cash by Mikeycampbell81
- › How to sell your old iPad for cash by Mikeycampbell81
- › How to offset the cost of a new iPhone by... by Mikeycampbell81
- › How to save money on AppleCare extended... by Kasper
- › How to offset the cost of a new iPad mini by... by Mikeycampbell81
- › Apple Prototypes by Mikeycampbell81
About AppleInsider | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 AppleInsider is powered by Huddler Tech | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map





