I find that unless you're actually printing photographs on photo paper all the time, HP gives better quality for the money. The photosmart printers are really good. You can pick up a 1115 for under 200 easy. I find HP a little more reliable, but their inks are more expensive because they haven't moved to single-color ink cartridges.
Favorite Bumper Sticker: Nuke the Gay Whales for Jesus!