Quote:
Originally Posted by
melgross 
That's why I had said, in our earlier discussion, that most cellphones had them.
You did not say "most". You said "
all".
Quote:
Originally Posted by
melgross 
Just how difficult is it for you to type AGPS in Google?
Not difficult. It's just a shame that you and others don't seem able to apply basic logic:
1.) AGPS requires a GPS receiver on the phone, the data received is passed over the network for servers to process the data (GPS requires quite a bit of data processing to determine the actual position).
2.) Saying a phone has AGPS therefore implies that it has a GPS receiver.
3.) Just because the E911 regs were the main driving force behind the development of AGPS, it does not imply that "all phones have AGPS". Other methods are perfectly valid for
E911.
4.) No evidence has been provided that all new phones in America have AGPS.
I'm pretty sure that there are plenty of new phones in America that don't have GPS receivers in them. Like all the "basic" (non smartphone) phones e.g. Sony Ericsson W810i, Motorola SLVR etc. etc.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
melgross 
Every real time reporting site stated that Jobs said it had GPS.
Lets just make it clear that I'm not trying to prove to anyone that the iPhone doesn't have GPS. It's just that no one has proved that Steve actually said it.
Are you not familiar with the game "Chinese whispers"? Just because most of the live reports said he said it, doesn't mean he said it. Someone could have mis-heard or mis-interpreted what he said.
Someone provided an article that states the iPhone has GPS. Again, I've seen plenty of articles about new Apple products that get features wrong.
I'd say the balance of probability is that he did say it. But we have the benefit that there is a recording of what he said! It would be nice if someone could provide a time stamp, because until then we can't be sure.