Quote:
Originally Posted by
nikon133 
Well... Apple fans will find everything anti-Apple funny, but there are a few good points there.
- I don't game on phone. As I am already gaming on PC, PS2 and PSP, another gaming platform would really be overkill. I could replace PSP with iPhone/iPod for portable gaming... if they ever come out with games like God of War. Which I don't think you can make without dedicated controls. Additionally, I know number of people that don't game at all, and people that will play games only in home environment and are not interested in mobile gaming. Poor souls, but that is the way things are.
http://www.icontrolpad.com/Quote:
- Hip holster? I don't like keeping phone in the pocket as I do carry a lot of keys (kar keys, office keys, home keys). Even glass can be scratched with good ole keys. Anandtech claims Pre is not built like iPhone, but compared to other phones it is OK. It is not like every phone with inferior built to iPhone will break the next day.
I've worn all of my phones my belt with a holster. It's just easier. In fact, when I got my 3G, I ended up using my old holster from my Treo 700p, because I bought an incase skin, and even though I was assured that it would fit into the Incase leather holster (which is very nice) with the skin, it's way too tight. The Treo holster is just perfect. Strange, but true!
Quote:
- Phone cameras... I made, all together, 14 photos with phone camera (most with BB, a few with wife's Treo). Photography is my hobby and I always have at least compact with me, or DSLR if I'm really going for a kill. Even compact with 8MP, stabilized lens etc. etc. is not something iPhone, Pre can even dream to compare to.
The only phone camera that made decent pictures was a Samsung from a couple of years ago. The front was a phone, and the rear a camera with a big lens. but it's far too clumsy either as a phone OR a camera. They still make updated models, but they don't sell too well. The 5 MP camera on the N97, for example, is said, in reviews, to take nice pictures outside, in strong light, but very noisy and low rez (from the ineffective noise reduction) indoors. The LED flashes on phone cameras are almost useless. Less than $100 these days gets a far superior compact camera.
Quote:
- Plastic can be made very durable. I never ever had a problem with scratching screens of my BB, Nokias and everything else I was using since '90. I like idea of even more durable screens, but it is not a deal breaker. Choosing between glass screen and - for me - more confortable phone to hold in hand, I'd go for second (if functionality is comparable).
All of my Palmphones, from the Samsung i300 to the Treo 700p scratched badly from the stylus. Very badly. Everyone I know had the same problem if they used the phone screen a lot. That's why screen protectors were invented. There is a real need with plastic screens.
Fortunately, the iPhone works so much better that you get the best of both.
Quote:
Now... I might end up eating some of my words in next few months.

My wife is looking at Pre as long-time Treo user, while I'm at present more interested in iPhone. I'm modest phone user and already have to carry BB during the work hours, so I'm sure both Pre and iPhone would suit my needs perfectly; but since we'll have one Pre in the house, it'll be interesting to try something else as well.
If the Pre were available before the iPhone came out, I would have been delighted, esp because you can use the old programs in some form or another until they get more "real" Pre programs out there, and I really did like those palmphones. But I'm happy the iPhone came out first, because it's simply a much better proposition overall.
The physical design of the Pre is disturbing. It's everywhere described as flimsy, cheaply made and scratches too easily. With the possibility that the screen cracking is endemic, and the mostly poor response from Palm and Sprint, I'd wait at least a month before buying one.
Quote:
At the end, price and available plans in NZ will decide, but it everything works as I am planning, as I said - I might take some of my comments back. Or not.
Good luck!