Black History Month plagues people?s minds; attempts to give moral standing

in General Discussion edited January 2014
Editorial from a local newspaper... I find it to be very accurate... we will never end racism if we still recognize people BY thier race. People are people and it's as simple as that... no more of this "First black woman basketball coach from Nigeria to be launched into space, crap.

[quote] The plague of racism has once again arrived in a most overt way. This plague tags along with the month of February, infesting American culture and corrupting young people into becoming life-long racists.

I am speaking, of course, of Black History Month. This celebration, however, is only a small representation of modern racism. The plague afflicts countless aspects of society under the guise of such repugnant principles as taking pride in racial heritage. Racism is the belief that a person?s identity comes from his or her race. It is a manifestation of collectivism. It is not, as popularly held, merely the idea that one race is superior to another (although that belief is racist). Defining racism so superficially has allowed for such things as Black History Month to silently perpetuate in American culture.

What makes Black History Month racist? Racism attempts to give moral worth to a person, not by his or her actions, but by race. Black History Month attempts to instill a sense a pride among blacks. The source of this pride is to be derived from the fact that men and women in history, who happened to be black, have done great things (often in spite of oppression dealt by men and women who are white). It is not enough for those who celebrate Black History Month to regard these historical figures as simply great individuals. In a racist quest for the unearned, a black person who celebrates Black History Month attempts to take pride in what others have done, merely because they share the same race. It is no different, in principle, than the 1930s German who took pride in what other Germans had done, merely because they were both German.

Hispanic Heritage Month is another example of the embarrassment of modern racism. The online education resource Education World hosts an article entitled "Celebrate Hispanic Heritage Month!" In it, teachers are encouraged to instill racial pride in Hispanic students. According to the article, "teaching about the contributions of Latinos can only help to build the self-esteem and the pride of those who identify themselves as Mexican-American or Cuban-American or Puerto Rican-American or ... "

Note that, according to this article, students are not to discover their self-worth in their own works and ideas, but as a part of a racial collective. The self is nothing more than an interchangeable part of a certain race and may be praised or condemned based on racial membership.

Our much-loved former President Clinton, most definitely a proponent of Black and Hispanic history months, showed the world on Nov. 7, 2001, what it means to be a modern racist.

In a speech he gave at Georgetown, Hurricane Willy claimed that, in respect to the massacres committed during the Crusades "those of us from various European lineages are not blameless."

According to Clinton, we are not to be individually judged based on our own actions. Our moral condition is derived directly from our race.

Unfortunately, facts will remain facts, regardless of the whims and wishes of a racist. As the philosopher Ayn Rand pointed out, "A genius is a genius, regardless of the number of morons who belong to the same race - and a moron is a moron, regardless of the number of geniuses who share his racial origin."

There is no legitimate pride or moral credit to be gained by virtue of sharing the same race with a great and admirable individual.

The first step in ending racism, it seems, has not even been accomplished. That is, it hasn?t even been properly identified by a bulk of Americans. Racism is being "fought" by the promotion of more racism. The only cure for this disease, however, is the endorsement of pure, unfettered individualism. As Rand said, "racism invalidates the specific attributes which distinguishes man from all other living species: his rational faculty. Racism negates two aspects of man?s life: reason and choice, or mind and morality, replacing them with chemical predestination."

The young people of America need be taught that the only pride they may properly hold is in the content of their character, and the achievements they make. Let us all take a first step by abolishing the observance of racism and the repudiation of individualism - by eliminating Black History Month.


Mac Guru


  • Reply 1 of 16
    I'm not sure if I agree with everything in the above. One interesting aspect that I've thought of before it touched on.

    If we "teach" kids to strongly identify with the accomplishments of people of their race then don't we also teach them to identify strongly with the misdeeds of people of their race.

    If the message is "see this former slave did this great proud" then is the message also in effect "this former slave did this horrible thing...(fill in blank)"

    or am I wrong?

    [ 02-08-2002: Message edited by: Scott H. ]</p>
  • Reply 2 of 16
    You may be right in some aspects Scott but the point is, we should be able to say, Job Schmoe did this a long time ago isn't that great? NOT, Joe Schmoe the African American did this.... blah blah blah.

    It is my beleif that if you tag a race onto anything it further impedes the progress of ending racism in this world. People need to identify with the world around them as people, not as people of a certain race. Although you may be black, white, chinese, japanese, whatever... it should not and does not matter in my mind. If I did something profound like fly to Mars and stick a flag in it for the first time in mans brief history... they'd clap and cheer and I'd get a medal or something... now if someone of a different race than caucassian did the same it'd be GLOBAL news of 100 times the magnitude simply because of the society we live in. How many white dudes have flown a space shuttle... a Lot... when a person of a different race does the same they make a HUGE deal out of it. I simply DO NOT understand this. Anyone that flies the space shuttle IS a human being... simple as that, race simply is not the point... race has NOTHING to do with your ability to complete a task... your upbringing, education, and physical strength do... among other things.

    ok I think I'll sit back and read what others have to say... I can't think straight... too much noise here at work.

    Mac Guru

    [ 02-08-2002: Message edited by: Mac Guru ]</p>
  • Reply 3 of 16
    [quote] There is no legitimate pride or moral credit to be gained by virtue of sharing the same race with a great and admirable individual. <hr></blockquote>

    Perfectly put.

    [quote] The young people of America need be taught that the only pride they may properly hold is in the content of their character, and the achievements they make. <hr></blockquote>

    My personal hero would be Theodore Roosevelt, I think he is one of the greatest men that ever came to this earth. Not because I feel white pride or some bullshit like that, its because he was a great person and only wanted the good in things and people.

    "speak softly and carry a big stick" - TR
  • Reply 4 of 16
    That quote that KrazyFool pulled out above almost sounds "anti-hero". But if you take it for what it says and not read anything else into it it makes a lot of sense.

    For example (this may sound corny) but my father is one of my heros. I do take pride in some of his accomplishments. Which I guess I shouldn't. I didn't do those things. To my benefit is to use him as a roll model.

    I guess in the zeal for group self esteem the actions of a single person is applied to all. All take pride in the actions of a single person. I don't think anyone can deny that this is going on wrt race.
  • Reply 5 of 16
    powerdocpowerdoc Posts: 8,123member
    What put Krazyfool is entirely correct. But he miss something. Every humans have roots and need roots, and it's legitimate to be proud of your roots.

    But having great roots , is not everything , it's a charge (a burden in a way) : you have to honor them.

    so having great roots is fine, but you have to stay humble and to think about your own actions.

    Scott H, is proud of his father : he is lucky, but unfortunately not all the kids have this chance. I wish sincerely that all kids can be proud of their parents.

    I am proud of my parents , but i do not consider them as heroes. Perhaps my grand father was a heroe (he is dead now), he had an important place in the resistance in WW2 and he has risqued his life many times. Last year i find an article about him on the net : that was strange to learn, what he did in this time, because i never learn this from him when he was alive. Perhaps this time was too dirty to be told to his family ?

    During his agony when he was confused he remember this terribles times. I think this secret period of his life was a wound. I think he will have prefered to not being an heroe, and to have a normal life, what the did , he did by obligation, because he think it was is duty.

    I do not know , what will be my attitude in the same context, but i prefer to never have to know that, and stay for ever a simple man.
  • Reply 6 of 16
    hmurchisonhmurchison Posts: 12,271member
    It's simple. Ask whoever you want if they are "Proud to be xxxxxx" Most will say yes. I've always known that it's foolish to be proud of something you had no control over. It's better to be proud of something that you willfully accomplished yourself. Racism is fueled by insecurity and despair...those will prove harder to beat as insecurity is almost an American Trait.
  • Reply 7 of 16
    Here's another aspect of it which seems MUCH more prevalent and dangerous.

    The notion that if "someone of color" is not represented then it can't represent people of color. That's what happened with that WTC Firemen memorial. Because they were all white it didn't represent blacks and hispanics.
  • Reply 8 of 16
    That's exactly one of my MANY points... this world of people that want to get rid of racism purpetuate it by doing crap like that. That statue was a perfect example of people bringing in race where it wasn't even an issue. In this world if 3 white guys do something honorable, it's immortalized as three "guys" untill someone that is overly sensitive comes along and says there need to be three wize men and a camel in there for the christians, and a black guy, a chinese guy, someone with a German and Polish mixed blood background and a hairless siamese cat.

    Quit throwing in things that either weren't an issue or have no place in the issue... it just purpetuates the issue in a negative light.

    Mac Guru
  • Reply 9 of 16
    hmurchisonhmurchison Posts: 12,271member
    Ummmmmm it's not quite that easy. Eradicating Racism is a noble concept but it's a little bit more difficult in practice. America has never had a Woman, Asian, Latino, yadda yadda yadda elected President. It was only 30 years ago that the mere enrollment of some minorities in some schools caused Riots. I beleive Racism can be beaten but it will take open minds and hearts. Let there be Latino Heritage month let there be Black History Month let there be White Student Unions...the REAL key is getting this groups to engage in civilized debate and come up with solutions to problems.
  • Reply 10 of 16
    falconfalcon Posts: 458member
    I dont really beleive that there are actual human races. Its mearly a different skin pigment for the most part. The 'race' part comes from us mentally tagging these people.

    Continue with discusion .
  • Reply 11 of 16
    Race is as much a matter of culture as it is physiology. I wonder if racism isn't tied closely with nationalism, and that racial discrimination exists in the US because minorities are still seen as minorities, which is, other than the majority, and therefore, not quite American like white people are American.

    If ya ask me, I think there are people in white America that do a pretty good job of keeping racism alive by themselves:

    ME: Walking on the sidewalk. Car approaches with two white males in front seat.

    FROM CAR: "Gook! Go home!" Car passes.

    ME: Flicking off car speeding away. "I'm f**king Filipino, ***holes!!!!"

    Minorities are encouraged to be proud of their heritage so they cannot be made to feel ashamed of it by some pathetic ***hole. Once mainstream America starts accepting minorites as "ordinary people," then things like Black History Month, etc., etc., will be moot.

    [ 02-08-2002: Message edited by: jesperas ]</p>
  • Reply 12 of 16
    It's very easy to say something like Black History Month shouldn't matter. But suppose you're black and you go to a mediocre high school. You do OK and you are going to go to community college, the first person in your family to make it past high school. You aren't really confident as a student and you don't know a whole lot of people who made it out of your crummy neighborhood but you know a lot of people on drugs, with children they can't afford, etc. It's nice to have reminders that black people really do have hope and that it's not simply a white person's world.

    It's easy for a person who has always expected to have a stable and comfortable life to say that these things are fluff. But when you're in the minority (like us Mac users are) its a comfort to celebrate each little victory.
  • Reply 13 of 16
    outsideroutsider Posts: 6,008member
    So you say way should have a Mac history month? Pulll-eaze.
  • Reply 14 of 16
    [quote]Originally posted by jesperas:

    <strong>If ya ask me, I think there are people in white America that do a pretty good job of keeping racism alive by themselves:

    ME: Walking on the sidewalk. Car approaches with two white males in front seat.

    FROM CAR: "Gook! Go home!" Car passes.

    ME: Flicking off car speeding away. "I'm f**king Filipino, ***holes!!!!"</strong><hr></blockquote>

    And people in black america too. My wife had black (err african american) kid yell "Chop Suey" and fake asian at her.

    [ 02-08-2002: Message edited by: Scott H. ]</p>
  • Reply 15 of 16
    [quote]Originally posted by Scott H.:


    And people in black america too. My wife had black (err african american) kid yell "Chop Suey" and fake asian at her.

    [ 02-08-2002: Message edited by: Scott H. ]</strong><hr></blockquote>

    Yeah, same thing happened to my finace. From a white kid, though. Where the f**k are these kids getting this crap? Their parents????

    <img src="confused.gif" border="0">

    [ 02-09-2002: Message edited by: jesperas ]</p>
  • Reply 16 of 16
    Something I must say is that as far as we all know there is no race, creed, or color in this thread by its posters. We are all just names that we somehow picked to represent us. With that said we are all colorless and have only what we say to show for what kind of person we are. So far I would love to hang out with all you in this tread and have like a fat mac lan party or something. Seriously, I could not care if half of your head was gone and had no legs and you drooled all over the place but you played a mean game of othello/reversi and god I love that game (but I suck at it ) I just would not care, I am one that believes that you should not judge a book by its cover.
Sign In or Register to comment.