Review: Apple Pencil is iPad Pro's must have accessory

Posted:
in General Discussion edited December 2015
Apple Pencil is the most talked about accessory to come out of Cupertino in recent memory, and rightfully so. Its classic design, packed with cutting edge technology, makes it an enticing product for digital artists and, more importantly, speaks to the future of Apple's tablet lineup.




The last Apple product to boast a stylus -- or non-finger touch input implement -- was 1993's Newton, a PDA lineup built around intuitive handwriting recognition technology. The series saw middling success before being axed by Steve Jobs upon his return to the company in 1998.

After leaving the stylus in the rearview mirror, Apple pushed forward with multitouch on iOS and hasn't once looked back. That is until Apple Pencil.

Apple CDO Jony Ive said Pencil is made for marking, not for executing banal user interface interactions. Apple largely rendered traditional styli obsolete with multitouch gestures in iOS, but there are certain scenarios -- drawing being an example cited by Ive -- where a writing implement bests even the most refined finger-based interface. Pencil is here to fill those gaps.

Design



Pencil is an unassuming device, much more so than the iPad Pro to which it pairs. Crafted out of tough, white polycarbonate reminiscent of Apple's early iPod designs, Pencil has substantial heft and feels rock solid. There is no flex, no extraneous buttons and, save for the nib and removable end cap, no moving parts. It feels purposeful.

The tip, or nib if carrying forward Ive's writing implement design metaphor, is made from a slightly flexible rubberized plastic. While not exactly malleable, the material is nowhere near as rigid as a common stylus point. When a nib gets worn down or damaged, it can be twisted off and replaced with a fresh tip. Apple includes one backup in the package.




The gray plasticized compound gives under reasonable pressure, providing a bit of drag against iPad Pro's smooth glass screen. Overall feel is akin to a slightly dulled graphite pencil with a high hardness rating.

Pencil is shaped to be immediately familiar to the user, but committing to a completely cylindrical format meant making concessions in ergonomics. Styli from Wacom and other professional imaging hardware companies boast thick bodies, sometimes shaped like hourglasses and wrapped in rubber sheathing. By comparison, Apple Pencil is a slender wand with a hard, slick body, not ideal for extended periods of use.

Apple's engineers were able to cram a good deal of electronics inside Pencil's slender shell. Most of the operational bits are found on a folded logic board situated toward the nib, itself outfitted with highly sensitive pressure sensors and specialized emitters used to determine degree of tilt.

More than half of all available space inside the plastic shell is claimed by a tube-shaped 0.329-watt-hour lithium ion battery Apple claims is good for 12 hours of uptime. We found that estimate to be slightly conservative. The battery's mass helps achieve a weight distribution nearly 50/50 point-to-point, making Pencil feel more like a common writing instrument and less like a tablet accessory.




For recharging, Apple built in a Lightning plug on the end opposite Pencil's nib. To keep the overall sleek aesthetic, a domed plastic cap is secured to Pencil's chassis via magnets. In our limited time with Pencil, we've almost lost this piece on two separate occasions, and Apple's retail kit doesn't include a replacement.




Unfortunately, Apple found it unnecessary to build in an iPad attachment mechanism, meaning users have to carry Pencil separately in a bag or case. We understand that not all iPad Pro buyers intend to pick up an Apple Pencil, but all Pencil owners -- for now -- need an iPad Pro. It would have been nice to see an internal magnetic attachment point in iPad Pro's chassis similar to the coded magnets used to retain Smart Covers and cases, or even a magnet or loop in device-specific accessories.

Charging is a simple, if not completely sophisticated, task of sticking Pencil's male Lightning plug into iPad Pro's receptacle, which incidentally trigger device pairing on first use. A quick charge takes only 15 seconds and yields 30 minutes of up time. Ive said the feature is built in to make usage more intuitive and to let users focus on drawing instead of fretting over battery life. A full recharge takes about an hour and saps a little over one percent of iPad Pro's capacious battery cells. Alternatively, Apple provides a female-to-female Lightning adapter for connecting to a standard iPhone or iPad wall charger.




Usage



As AppleInsider noted in our first look, Pencil can be used as a simple stylus for pecking at apps, highlighting text and swiping through Web pages. There are a few notable limitations, however, including control over multitasking windows in Split View.




As a capacitive input device, Pencil should be able to invoke Slide Over in iOS 9, but Apple is apparently using Pencil's unique digital signature, which aids in palm rejection, to prohibit such use. An interesting choice that likely has more to do with user experience than limitations in iOS.

The real magic lies in Pencil's intuitive drawing capabilities. Onboard sensors communicate with matching components disposed under iPad Pro's display to log the slightest changes in pressure and tilt, which are translated to thicker lines, shading modes and more. When iPad Pro detects Pencil's aforementioned digital signature, a sampling subsystem boosts scan rates to 240Hz, thus reducing perceived lag.

The tight hardware development process yielded a type of futuristic symbiotic relationship. Apple Pencil cannot stand alone without iPad Pro, and iPad Pro is not whole without Pencil.

Along with ultra-fast response times, the Pencil-iPad Pro pairing incorporates the best palm rejection technology we've seen in a consumer device. Period. Along with the usual assortment of palm detection algorithms, apps like Apple's Notes proactively monitor for and fix erroneous marks. For example, resting a pinky finger on iPad's screen invokes a short stroke in Notes, but if Pencil is recognized by the display's hardware during the same action, that mark is retroactively erased.




As of this writing, Apple's own Notes app is, perhaps unsurprisingly, the most fine tuned of current Pencil-supporting software. Notes exhibits imperceptible Pencil-to-screen latency. Other products sometimes take a split second to register the takeoff point when a stylus tip comes into contact with the tablet surface. With Pencil the moment of contact is immediate, emboldening the user with pixel-perfect accuracy. Even pulling long, roaming circles across the display at pace returns zero lag.

It is with Notes' pencil tool that Apple Pencil's capabilities are made most apparent. Laying down material on virtual paper is an uncanny experience. The amount of virtual lead, and its opacity, is controlled by pressure, tilt and draw speed in a way that clearly mimics real life. Apple totally nailed it.

Drawing in Notes is an additive process in that Pencil deposits a certain amount of material on each pass. For clean lines, the app applies dynamic stroke smoothing, while tilt-based shading and pressure sensitivity are predictable to the point of being utterly intuitive. We were also impressed with Apple's seamless animations between sharp points to shading and back again.

For all its benefits Notes is not a dedicated drawing app, meaning artists will have to look to third party programs like Adobe Sketch, Adobe Draw and Procreate for their creative needs. While these apps have granular tool control and a litany of brush styles, their implementation of Pencil is spotty.

Procreate is in our view the most well integrated out of today's standalone offerings. The app features highly granular brush customization, an easy-to-use drawing interface and well thought out multitouch gestures. Using a few custom brushes, I was able to produce the rough sketch below in about ten minutes, and I'm most certainly not an artist.


Procreate. Note: Disregard horrifying eyelashes.


Adobe Photoshop Sketch is another great app, though quality results are harder to achieve due to a lack of tools. Users are able to select from a variety of pencils, pens, brushes, smudge tools and more, while each has its own set of customization options.

Adobe Illustrator Draw is similar to Sketch, but is designed to create vector graphics, a useful feature for illustrators looking to start a project on iPad and finish up on a professional desktop rig. Unfortunately, the first version of Draw suffers from noticeable lag. The exact cause is unclear, but it could have something to do with processing pressure, tilt and azimuth information into dynamically smoothed vector art.


Adobe Photoshop Sketch.


We had to dig deep to find Pencil's negative attributes, of which there are sparingly few. For example, the shell's slick exterior forces a tighter grip, which can be fatiguing after hours of use. Pencil's nib is also tiring. While vastly superior to hard plastic found on competing styli, Apple's version still slides freely across iPad's screen, meaning users can't rely on friction to bring Pencil to a halt. The sensation will be familiar to anyone who's used a stylus, but a lack of surface grip means hand muscles have to work harder for complete control.

Conclusion



At $99, Pencil is hardly an impulse buy. Indeed, Pencil is the main reason many customers are even considering the gigantic iPad Pro. As an art tool, Pencil is unmatched in the iOS ecosystem, and that lead should only increase as more developers build in Apple's APIs.




Pencil was made for artists. The tablet workflow is not yet powerful enough to completely replace desktop software, but the iPad Pro/Pencil combo performs flawlessly for mockup work and on-the-go creation. Apps like Astropad, which connects iPad to a Mac for use with pro apps like Photoshop, further blur the line between tablets and dedicated digital canvases.

Education and business users will benefit to a lesser extent, especially in apps where note taking and markup features play central roles.

The case for Pencil is less clear for casual users. There's no denying that Pencil is a hugely fun accessory to play with, but its overall utility for everyday use is questionable. Factoring in the price of an iPad Pro, however, the package is hardly worth a few doodles in Notes.

In short, Apple Pencil is the best stylus -- gasp! -- on the market, but remember you need a $799 iPad Pro to join in the fun.

Score: 4.5 out of 5



Pros:
  • Intuitive pressure- and tilt-sensitive input
  • Amazing hardware integration with iPad Pro
  • Minimalist design

Cons:
  • Restricted to iPad Pro

Where to buy



Apple Pencil is available for $99 through Apple's website, though estimated ship-by dates have languished at 4 to 5 weeks since mid-November. Some customers have found random shipments pop up at brick-and-mortar Apple Stores, as well as Best Buy, but supply is severely constrained.
«13

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 58
    I'm interested in it as a music writing tool. Has anyone had any experience with this & the few music writing apps that are available? I know that StaffPad on a Surface is getting rave reviews & I'm wondering if the same exists now in iOS land
  • Reply 2 of 58
    mrzee said:
    I'm interested in it as a music writing tool. Has anyone had any experience with this & the few music writing apps that are available? I know that StaffPad on a Surface is getting rave reviews & I'm wondering if the same exists now in iOS land
    I've purchased forScore and used the Pencil to annotate scores. The Apple Store in NY City upper west side actually had this config on display. ForScore is probably more for display and annotation than for composition... But worth mentioning.
    mrzee
  • Reply 3 of 58
    I'd love to be able to use it as a markup tool in Keynote and Numbers presentations, or in an open Pages or iBooks document. Any idea if that is possible?
  • Reply 4 of 58
    jdwjdw Posts: 742member
    Too bad the flip side isn't an eraser.  I don't mean to defend MS by saying this, but their pen input device is much more "natural" in that regard.  For 100 bucks, I should be able to flip it and erase.  It really is that simple.
    RobJenk
  • Reply 5 of 58
    jdw said:
    Too bad the flip side isn't an eraser.  I don't mean to defend MS by saying this, but their pen input device is much more "natural" in that regard.  For 100 bucks, I should be able to flip it and erase.  It really is that simple.
    I've been  Wacom tablet user for years. Their pens have an eraser end. I've never had much use for the eraser end. I'd much rather hit the keyboard shortcut to turn the writing end into an eraser or another tool.

    So, while I applaud Wacom's products, for my workflow Apple has made the right call designing a perfectly simple pencil input device.
    justadcomicsdiegog
  • Reply 6 of 58
    Tangentially related to the Pencil review…I am still waiting for my Pencil to ship from Apple, though I've had my iPad Pro for over a week.

    I realized there is an Adobe Ink stylus in my desk drawer and figured I could get started with that until the Apple Pencil arrived.

    NOPE!

    For whatever reason, Adobe has specifically disabled support for the Ink stylus in their apps.

    Goes to show that products based on clever hacks of Apple's touchscreen tech (and by extension, other Apple hardware features that haven't yet been specifically made available to developers) are probably best avoided.
  • Reply 7 of 58
    jdwjdw Posts: 742member
    polymnia said:
    I've been  Wacom tablet user for years. Their pens have an eraser end. I've never had much use for the eraser end. I'd much rather hit the keyboard shortcut to turn the writing end into an eraser or another tool.
    3 points in rebuttal:

    1) Apple calls it a pencil.  Some pencils come without erasers but MOST DO.  It's only natural to give it an eraser.  It's expected.  And for $100, it's a MUST.

    2) People reviewing MS's input device have praised the flip-side eraser as natural, while expressing minor disapproval of Apple's design choice.  Not that we really care what MS fans care about, but we would be fools to treat their thinking as flippant.  They are paying customers too.

    3) I myself don't care so much about what other people think when it comes to my "needs."  I just want products to be the best they can be, and I am willing to voice that accordingly.  I want the flip-side to be an eraser.  Put an eraser there and don't use it?  Who cares!  But remove the eraser and want to use it?  Ah, but you can't.  So by adding the eraser I am happy and so are you since you don't care!
    edited December 2015 RobJenk
  • Reply 8 of 58
    mrzee said:
    I'm interested in it as a music writing tool. Has anyone had any experience with this & the few music writing apps that are available? I know that StaffPad on a Surface is getting rave reviews & I'm wondering if the same exists now in iOS land
    Notion has an IAP for handwriting support and has even been updated for Apple Pencil support. I'm still waiting on my Pencil so I haven't tried yet. It is a very robust app, though not without bugs. 
    mrzee
  • Reply 9 of 58
    palegolaspalegolas Posts: 1,277member
    davepbass said:
    mrzee said:
    I'm interested in it as a music writing tool. Has anyone had any experience with this & the few music writing apps that are available? I know that StaffPad on a Surface is getting rave reviews & I'm wondering if the same exists now in iOS land
    Notion has an IAP for handwriting support and has even been updated for Apple Pencil support. I'm still waiting on my Pencil so I haven't tried yet. It is a very robust app, though not without bugs. 
    I've also been eyeing Notion. Haven't pulled the trigger yet though. It's a bit costy, and notation isn't my major. It looks like a beautiful software.

    One more con about the Pencil, that nobody seems to talk about, is the tilt sensor. Although the precision of the tip is just brilliant, miles ahead of Wacom, the tilt sensor, I find not that precise. When tilting at extreme levels, for shading, you can clearly see the steps between the tilt sensor levels. Not all that cool. And also there seems to be a problem detecting the initial pressure when shading in extreme tilt levels. Sometimes, I'd say 1 out of 10, the initial pressure comes off as unusually strong, leaving hard marks, rather than the intended soft marks, when drawing sideways. I haven't come to understand the behaviour of this yet, leading me to believe it might actually be a shortcoming of the hardware. I'm hoping an update can stabilise this, but for now, it's impossible for an end user like me to see if this can be done something about.
  • Reply 10 of 58
    mrrmrr Posts: 63member
    Please please PLEASE Apple bring Apple Pencil support to the entire next gen line of iPads and to the iPhone 7.
    tallest skil
  • Reply 11 of 58
    I had friends over for dinner on Saturday and one of them asked to see my iPad Pro. So I brought it out and then was asked if I had the Pencil, which I do. Interesting that two friends were immersed for a couple of hours drawing with the Pencil. They quickly adapted to using the "erase" and "erase all" commands. I also had to make sure that I still had my new iPad and Pencil when they left my home.

    I, myself, haven't used a pencil with an eraser for over a decade. When I was an engineer at the "rocket factory" 40 years ago, we were only allowed to use mechanical pencils and separate erasures. My own experience with a "lead" pencil with erasure was that I often smudged the paper and so have been conditioned to using a separate erasure.
    tallest skiljustadcomicsdiegog
  • Reply 12 of 58
    ursine1 said:
    When I was an engineer at the “rocket factory” 40 years ago…

    Ah, is that what the Rocketdyne guys called the strip club down the street… their “rocket factory”…
  • Reply 13 of 58
    dacloodacloo Posts: 890member
    A 'drawback' (no pun intended) of this pen is the lack of pen-tip support. It would be great to be able to turn around the pen and use it as an eraser.
  • Reply 14 of 58
    Apple Pencil is one of the best products Apple has released since the iPhone and multi-touch. I've been using it mostly for note taking and it's exactly like writing with a pen on a piece of paper.
  • Reply 15 of 58
    dreyfus2dreyfus2 Posts: 1,070member
    jdw said:

    1) Apple calls it a pencil.  Some pencils come without erasers but MOST DO.  It's only natural to give it an eraser.  It's expected.  And for $100, it's a MUST.

    2) People reviewing MS's input device have praised the flip-side eraser as natural, while expressing minor disapproval of Apple's design choice.  Not that we really care what MS fans care about, but we would be fools to treat their thinking as flippant.  They are paying customers too.

    3) I myself don't care so much about what other people think when it comes to my "needs."  I just want products to be the best they can be, and I am willing to voice that accordingly.  I want the flip-side to be an eraser.  Put an eraser there and don't use it?  Who cares!  But remove the eraser and want to use it?  Ah, but you can't.  So by adding the eraser I am happy and so are you since you don't care!
    1. No, all professional pencils (those normally used by artists) do not have erasers. No artist expects an eraser there, and it certainly is no must.

    2. True, I do not care what MS fans care about.

    3. That is a perfectly fine opinion, but that is not how good products are designed. You don't cater for every possible wish of every single individual, you make the best choices possible. And an eraser at the end is a terrible idea for various reasons... There is the stroke width discrepancy (eraser is thicker, might even be thicker than the eraser thickness set in the software – it is not an actual eraser after all, it is just another software setting), no need to confuse the issue by having two hardware pieces performing the same thing, only worse. Then there are apps that do not even have eraser functionality, like technical drawing apps that only draw shapes and bezier curves – there is only undo there, no erase. How confusing would the eraser end be there? Once it is part of the hardware, you can't make it disappear.

    I use Wacom tablets since 2002 and have never used the eraser end on those pens that had it (swapping modes by hitting a button is always faster than flipping the pen around), and in my two weeks with the Apple Pencil I have not missed it even once. 
    justadcomicsdiegog
  • Reply 16 of 58
    mr omr o Posts: 1,046member
    jdw said:
    Too bad the flip side isn't an eraser.  I don't mean to defend MS by saying this, but their pen input device is much more "natural" in that regard.  For 100 bucks, I should be able to flip it and erase.  It really is that simple.
    I am not a big fan of having a one size bulky eraser on the flip side. I prefer the fine grain control you get when the tip of the pen transforms into an eraser.

    Although having the eraser on the flip side of the pen might feel more natural/familiar, it is a significant step back in usability.
    justadcomicsdiegogdeserteagle911
  • Reply 17 of 58
    jdw said:
    Too bad the flip side isn't an eraser.  I don't mean to defend MS by saying this, but their pen input device is much more "natural" in that regard.  For 100 bucks, I should be able to flip it and erase.  It really is that simple.
    I haven't missed that once. Apps have undo buttons or quick gestures to undo/redo. For me that's just as easy as flipping the Pencil over to erase. It seems to me Apple designed this in the likeness of a real artists pencil and they don't have erasers on the end.
  • Reply 18 of 58
    How does Pencil compare to Wacom's technology which requires no battery?

    Since the tip is replaceable, could we see a market for alternative tips with expanded capabilities?
    edited December 2015
  • Reply 19 of 58
    mr omr o Posts: 1,046member

    mrr said:
    Please please PLEASE Apple bring Apple Pencil support to the entire next gen line of iPads and to the iPhone 7.
    The pencil should definitely be compatible with the iPad mini and iPad air. Especially the iPad air, it has the perfect size for a sketchbook.

    I am not sure whether Apple should make the pencil compatible with the iPhone/iPhone plus. The pencil could be a great differentiator between the iPad and iPhone.
  • Reply 20 of 58
    jdw said:

    3) I myself don't care so much about what other people think when it comes to my "needs."  I just want products to be the best they can be, and I am willing to voice that accordingly.  I want the flip-side to be an eraser.  Put an eraser there and don't use it?  Who cares!  But remove the eraser and want to use it?  Ah, but you can't.  So by adding the eraser I am happy and so are you since you don't care!
    I seriously doubt that the people currently defending the lack of an eraser would complain about Pencil if it did have an eraser.  So this is just a case of defending whatever Apple brings out, even if self contradicting.
    edited December 2015
Sign In or Register to comment.