Compared: 2018 iPad with Apple Pencil support vs 2017 iPad and iPad Air 2

Posted:
in iPad edited March 2018
The launch of a new iPad is usually followed by users deciding whether they should update to the latest model, or to continue using their existing iPad and save money. AppleInsider compares the new 2018 iPad against last year's release and the iPad Air models to decide if it's worth making the upgrade.

Apple March 27 education event


Apple's unveiling of the 2018 iPad focused heavily on the usage of the Apple Pencil and how it is an ideal computing device for education. This feature alone may be compelling enough for existing iPad owners to buy the new device, but putting that addition aside for the moment, the iPad on its own is probably enough of an improvement to warrant a purchase.

At first glance

Looking at the basic specifications of the 2018 iPad in comparison to the 2017 iPad, the iPad Air 2, and iPad Air, there's oddly very little between them all. This is not just in general appearance, but many of the core functions and features that users expect when they look at an iPad.




A quick glance at the above chart seemingly suggests there aren't that many changes between the models, despite the group's release dates spanning five and a half years. With the exception of the iPad Air 2, Apple continues to make the iPad 7.5 millimeters thick, meaning the new model should fit in older cases fairly comfortably.

The 9.7-inch display in the 2018 iPad remains unchanged in terms of size, with the same 1536 by 2048-resolution screen and the 264ppi pixel density. Even the overall 9.45 by 6.67-inch size is the same as earlier versions.

The battery in the newest model is a bit smaller than the iPad Air and 2017 version's 32.9 watt-hour capacities, weighing in at 32.4 watt hours. Unlike the 27.3 watt-hour version in the slimmer iPad Air 2, this reduction is fairly negligible, and Apple continues to claim it has the same 10-hour active battery life as the previous model.

The Wi-Fi upgrade to 802.11ac in the iPad Air 2 remain static in the 2018 iPad, with it also continuing to use Touch ID for biometric security. The rear camera still uses an 8-megapixel sensor, introduced to the device range in the iPad Air 2, so even that isn't a major reason for moving to the newest model.

It's what inside that counts

The biggest difference that users of older models will likely experience if they try out the newest version will be in its performance running apps. Each progression of the iPad since the Air has used the next generation of the A-series chip, with each successive upgrade bringing with it an improvement to the tablet's processing power.




In last year's comparison of the 2017 iPad against the two Air models, it was shown to have a considerably higher pair of Geekbench 4 scores. While the A9 chip's muli-core score wasn't a big jump compared to the A8X in the iPad Air 2, the single-core result was viewed as a massive leap forwards.

As it is always unclear how the day-to-day use of an iPad uses symmetrical multiprocessing, the multi-core result's minor improvement probably called the A9 upgrade into question by some parties. By comparison, the move to the A10 Fusion probably won't raise similar issues.

Initial Geekbench 4 tests for the 2018 iPad reported by iMore say it achieved a score of 3254 for single-core and 5857 for multi-core. This puts it similar to the iPhone 7's results of 3387 and 5694 for single and multi-core tests respectively, which makes sense as the iPhone uses the same processor and has the same 2GB of RAM as the 2018 iPad.

In theory, this is an improvement of about 28 percent for single and 33 percent for multi-core performance when comparing the 2018 iPad to the 2017 model.

Put against the iPad Air 2, the single-core score for the 2018 iPad is about 80 percent better, as well as an admirable 40 percent increase for multi-core. Against the iPad Air's dual-core A7 and 1GB of RAM compared to the 2GB in the other models, the single and multi-core score increases rise even higher, to 245 and 260 percent respectively.

If processing power is an important factor to users, the potential performance increases alone make the upgrade from the iPad Air and Air 2 extremely attractive.

Familiar design should equal similar repairability level

Ahead of an expected teardown of the new hardware, it is probable that the new iPad will be quite similar to earlier models in terms of repairability, with relatively few changes.

The 2017 iPad was constructed in a similar way to the iPad Air, using the same unfused display as the older model, rather than the thinner laminated touch panel found in the iPad Air 2. The similarity between the 2017 iPad and iPad Air's components even went as far as the two using identical connectors in some areas.

Disassembly of 2017 iPad by iFixit
Disassembly of 2017 iPad by iFixit


It is currently unclear what kind of display assembly is being used in the 2018 iPad, but the addition of Pencil support means there may be some design cues carried over from the iPad Pro range. The similarly-sized 9.7-inch iPad Pro had the LCD and front panel glass fused together, which made it simpler to open but upped the cost of screen repair.

As for the rest of the components, it's probably safe to consider them on a par with the 2017 iPad to repair.

Even so, for most users, this isn't really an issue, as the majority of iPad owners will be handing over their damaged or faulty devices to Apple or a third-party repair shop instead of tackling the fix for themselves. Cost of repair will remain a factor, and will largely depend on which display production technique Apple uses.

Apple Pencil helps enhance the 2018 iPad's already viable prospects as an upgrade

Looking at it as a standalone tablet without the Apple Pencil, the 2018 iPad is certainly a good candidate for owners of the iPad Air and iPad Air 2, at least when looking at the numbers. From a performance perspective, the two tablets are handily thrashed by the processing power of the new model, even more so than the improvements seen in the 2017 update.

The low $329 cost of the 2018 iPad also makes it a relatively cheap upgrade, putting it at the same price as the 2017 version for consumers.

Existing 2017 iPad owners will not be as enthusiastic to upgrade to the 2018 version just based on the performance bump. The similarities between the two models for the cameras, display, battery life, and other elements will probably make 2017 iPad owners strongly consider sticking to what they've got for at least another year, maybe two.




Of course, this all doesn't take into account the addition of Apple Pencil support. For those who have coveted the iPad Pro range's stylus input but avoided upgrading over cost, the added functionality makes the move to the 2018 iPad highly beneficial for iPad Air and Air 2 owners, even with the additional $99 cost for the Apple Pencil.

It is also arguable that the draw of a cheap Apple Pencil-enabled device could encourage 2017 users to upgrade as well, but only if it is highly desired by those thinking about buying one.

Apple's continued efforts to make iPad a central part of education are certainly helped with the addition of Apple Pencil support, with both the 2018 iPad and Apple Pencil discounted under institutional pricing to $299 and $89 respectively. The existence of the Logitech Crayon as a $49 alternative to the Apple Pencil makes the acquisition more tempting for schools already keen on the idea of adding iPads to their classrooms. Home users looking for the best deal on the 2018 iPad can also save by purchasing from an Apple authorized reseller with no sales tax in many states.
«13

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 55
    seanismorrisseanismorris Posts: 1,105member
    The MacBook Air is now $650 over at BestBuy for Students.  Interesting timing...
  • Reply 2 of 55
    supadav03supadav03 Posts: 461member
    Nice jump in performance. Apple is really offering some great tablets at near rock bottom pricing. My kids begging for the upgrade so they can have access to ARkit. I’m still waiting for the 12.9 refresh.
    ronnalbegarctmaynunzywatto_cobra
  • Reply 3 of 55
    Super dull upgrade but exciting for who they are targeting.
    albegarc
  • Reply 4 of 55
    seanismorrisseanismorris Posts: 1,105member
    Super dull upgrade but exciting for who they are targeting.
    The memory is a bit hobbled.  Apple might have issues pushing out iOS updates for the next 4 years, without killing the performance.

    It is a good market share move...
    muthuk_vanalingam
  • Reply 5 of 55
    canukstormcanukstorm Posts: 1,981member
    Super dull upgrade but exciting for who they are targeting.
    The memory is a bit hobbled.  Apple might have issues pushing out iOS updates for the next 4 years, without killing the performance.

    It is a good market share move...
    At $329, It'll make it more viable for people to upgrade after 2 years By that time there will be a better iPad.
    ronnnunzywatto_cobra
  • Reply 6 of 55
    Looks like a great uprade from my Air 2 but I think that this new iPad won´t fit in my logitech case with keyboard for the Air 2 and that could be a deal breaker for me because it could be an additional  $100 expense in a new case and another $99 plus tax for the Apple pencil.
  • Reply 7 of 55
    seanismorrisseanismorris Posts: 1,105member
    Super dull upgrade but exciting for who they are targeting.
    The memory is a bit hobbled.  Apple might have issues pushing out iOS updates for the next 4 years, without killing the performance.

    It is a good market share move...
    At $329, It'll make it more viable for people to upgrade after 2 years By that time there will be a better iPad.
    Yes.  But we are also talking about schools buying these.  They’re going to use them for the full 4 years.
  • Reply 8 of 55
    Anyone know if the 2018 model has the improved antiglare screen that the iPad Air 2 has? The 5th Gen (2017) did not have this.
  • Reply 9 of 55
    seanismorrisseanismorris Posts: 1,105member
    Anyone know if the 2018 model has the improved antiglare screen that the iPad Air 2 has? The 5th Gen (2017) did not have this.
    In the video from AI it didn’t look like it.
  • Reply 10 of 55
    Mike WuertheleMike Wuerthele Posts: 4,968administrator
    Anyone know if the 2018 model has the improved antiglare screen that the iPad Air 2 has? The 5th Gen (2017) did not have this.
    In the video from AI it didn’t look like it.
    It has essentially the same screen as the fifth generation one from last year did.
    GeorgeBMac
  • Reply 11 of 55
    fallenjtfallenjt Posts: 3,980member
    Super dull upgrade but exciting for who they are targeting.
    The memory is a bit hobbled.  Apple might have issues pushing out iOS updates for the next 4 years, without killing the performance.

    It is a good market share move...
    At $329, It'll make it more viable for people to upgrade after 2 years By that time there will be a better iPad.
    Yes.  But we are also talking about schools buying these.  They’re going to use them for the full 4 years.
    Agreed. My iPad Air is still running like charm. I got to replace it with 12.9" iPad Pro today because my 4-year-old stood on the screen and broke the glass last week...fixing the damn screen costs over $150, so I retire it.
    mike54beowulfschmidtwatto_cobra
  • Reply 12 of 55
    SoliSoli Posts: 9,337member
    Amazing update for the price. I guess this means the digitizer will be standard on future iPads. I hope that means the digitizer will come to iPhones and Mac trackpads, at least.
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 13 of 55
    Apple is going sell a ton of these, event it is exactly the same iPad as 2017 with the pencil functionality added to it.  
    MisterKitwatto_cobra
  • Reply 14 of 55
    MisterKitMisterKit Posts: 291member
    I got a 2017 for $249 on Black Friday. I don’t have a use for the pencil. Staying put this cycle. Maybe they will be $249 this year on Black Friday.
  • Reply 15 of 55
    fallenjtfallenjt Posts: 3,980member
    Apple is going sell a ton of these, event it is exactly the same iPad as 2017 with the pencil functionality added to it.  
    Not exactly the same as 2017 iPad, but better and more. This new iPad has A10 Fusion chip which is 25%-30% faster than A9 in the last year model. Beside, it's a lot cheaper, even vs iPad Mini 4.
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 16 of 55
    rogifan_newrogifan_new Posts: 4,213member
    Super dull upgrade but exciting for who they are targeting.
    The memory is a bit hobbled.  Apple might have issues pushing out iOS updates for the next 4 years, without killing the performance.

    It is a good market share move...
    At $329, It'll make it more viable for people to upgrade after 2 years By that time there will be a better iPad.
    People shouldn’t have to buy a new iPad every 2 years because the RAM isn’t sufficient. I would never buy another iPad that didn’t have at least 4GB RAM.
    edited March 2018 muthuk_vanalingam
  • Reply 17 of 55
    bb-15bb-15 Posts: 272member
    I could see upgrading an iPad Air 1 which has only 1 GB of RAM which limits multitasking. (Earlier models have even more multitasking limits.) 

    But the iPad Air 2 and 2017 iPad have 2 GB of RAM, (the same as the 2018 iPad) and I wouldn't upgrade from those devices (unless the Apple Pencil is crucial).
    In real world tests, I don't imagine the Air 2, 2017 & 2018 to be significantly different in using apps.   
    - Benchmark scores alone don't tell the full performance story imo. 
    muthuk_vanalingam
  • Reply 18 of 55
    foggyhillfoggyhill Posts: 4,767member
    Super dull upgrade but exciting for who they are targeting.
    The memory is a bit hobbled.  Apple might have issues pushing out iOS updates for the next 4 years, without killing the performance.

    It is a good market share move...
    At $329, It'll make it more viable for people to upgrade after 2 years By that time there will be a better iPad.
    People shouldn’t have to buy a new iPad every 2 years because the RAM isn’t sufficient. I would never buy another iPad that didn’t have at least 4GB RAM.
    Nobody's doing, I'm still using an Ipad 2 (we got 6 Ipads of 4 different generations in the house). Stop building straw men. They still sell 4GB laptops and windows is less efficient than IOS on these.

    StrangeDaysfastasleepGeorgeBMacwatto_cobra
  • Reply 19 of 55
    canukstormcanukstorm Posts: 1,981member
    Super dull upgrade but exciting for who they are targeting.
    The memory is a bit hobbled.  Apple might have issues pushing out iOS updates for the next 4 years, without killing the performance.

    It is a good market share move...
    At $329, It'll make it more viable for people to upgrade after 2 years By that time there will be a better iPad.
    People shouldn’t have to buy a new iPad every 2 years because the RAM isn’t sufficient. I would never buy another iPad that didn’t have at least 4GB RAM.
    Right now the 9.7" iPad has 2GB RAM.  I'm willing to bet in a couple of years time it'll be double that.  That's the point I was getting at.
    StrangeDayswatto_cobra
  • Reply 20 of 55
    StrangeDaysStrangeDays Posts: 8,778member
    Super dull upgrade but exciting for who they are targeting.
    The memory is a bit hobbled.  Apple might have issues pushing out iOS updates for the next 4 years, without killing the performance.

    It is a good market share move...
    At $329, It'll make it more viable for people to upgrade after 2 years By that time there will be a better iPad.
    People shouldn’t have to buy a new iPad every 2 years because the RAM isn’t sufficient. I would never buy another iPad that didn’t have at least 4GB RAM.
    Right now the 9.7" iPad has 2GB RAM.  I'm willing to bet in a couple of years time it'll be double that.  That's the point I was getting at.
    Exactly, his hand-wringing and teeth gnashing doesn't make sense. It’s not like all people will need to upgrade all devices every two years, because Apple doesn’t up them every two years like clockwork. And whenever they do bump it, some may wish to upgrade and some won’t. It all depends on use case and value proposition, which is personal. 

    But boy, he sure likes to tilt at windmills everywhere...”Upsell conspiracy!”
    edited March 2018 fastasleepwatto_cobra
Sign In or Register to comment.