Photo smackdown: iPhone XS Max versus Samsung's Galaxy Note 9
Among everything new with the iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max, the camera saw the most love from Apple, with changes like a new larger sensor on the wide end, a brand new depth control feature which works incredibly well now that portrait blur is more accurate and a new Smart HDR feature.
The Samsung Galaxy Note 9's camera has similar 12MP sensors behind the telephoto and wide lenses. It also has a live focus feature that simulates background blur, which also allows you to adjust the blur after you snap a photo.
We went out to Coeur d'Alene, Idaho, and snapped a bunch of photos so we could see how Apple's new iPhone XS Max performs against the Note 9.
Here, the sky on the Note 9 is overexposed, and there's a huge loss in color. If you take a close look at the buildings in the background, they're blown out as well. However, the Note 9 was able to keep the subject looking brighter and better exposed. We noticed much more saturation on the Note 9's image as well, which is a personal preference, but we prefer the more natural look.
Here's where the story changes. When shooting against the sun, the Note 9 does a much better job at dynamic range. The highlights look the same, but the Note 9 is able to keep the darkest areas of the scene looking brighter. There's less lens flare on the Note 9 as well.
Now here's a photo of the same scene except using portrait mode. The sunspot on the Note 9 is larger, but it does much better keeping the subject exposed properly. There's a massive flare on the iPhone XS Max's image again.
In this shot, the Note 9 has noticeably better dynamic range inside the parking garage.
The iPhone XS & XS Max have a new depth control feature, and there's a much wider range of blur adjustment compared to the Note 9. The iPhones can go from a depth setting of F16, all the way to F1.4. The Note 9 can only go from 0-7.
The background on the Note 9's Live Focus photos can't get nearly as blurry as they can on the iPhone XS Max, and we think a lot of people would like to have that kind of freedom.
When shooting plants, the Note 9 does a much better job. In this photo, the white balance is more accurate and the image looks more pleasing. The XS Max struggles with blur edging, whereas the Note 9 does just fine.
In this photo of a flower, the XS Max actually blurs out the whole stem. The Note 9 is able to detect the stem and keep it in the foreground. This is a huge advantage for the Note.
Comparing front-facing portrait modes, the Note 9 is looking a bit soft. There's much more detail in the face with the XS Max. The background also looks brighter and more balanced on the iPhone.
Another perk on the XS Max is that you can adjust the blur on the front-facing portrait shots as well. The Note 9 isn't able to do this. Because of this, the XS Max is able to get portrait photos with incredibly high levels of blur, and it actually turns out quite nice.
Comparing Portrait mode photos of objects, the iPhone XS Max is getting much better dynamic range. Both phones struggle with blur edging, but the Note 9 is a little bit better.
In this photo with a small crease on the inside of two poles, the iPhone XS Max completely fails to detect that it needs to blur the inside of the object. The Note 9 does an almost perfect job at it. However, the dynamic range on the Note 9 is quite bad.
In this shot of a flower, both photos look very detailed, but it seems that the Note 9 either has more contrast or it's more detailed compared to the XS Max. You'll have to decide for yourself which photo you think is better at color reproduction.
In this telephoto image of a tree, the Note 9 has more contrast and it has more detail as well.
Here's another comparison of detail. The XS Max has noticeably better dynamic range, and they seem similar in detail. The Note 9 has more contrast and it adds more saturation to the image.
Now comparing regular selfie photos, the difference in dynamic range is shocking. The sky on the Note 9's image is completely blown out. On the XS Max, you can see every single cloud, and the sky is actually blue. At the same time, the face is properly exposed and there's more detail as well.
Here's a wide image shot from the inside of a building. There's noticeably better dynamic range on the XS Max, and it's able to accurately reproduce the colors in the sky and background.
In this portrait & live focus mode comparison. The Note 9 fails to accurately detect the face and ends up blurring it, even after multiple attempts. Not only that, but the dynamic range is worlds better on the XS Max.
We shot these images with extremely low light. The Note 9 has very impressive noise reduction, making the image look a lot more detailed. You can easily see more noise with the XS Max. However, the white balance is way off on the Note 9. The XS Max was about as accurate as you can get.
Now on the front-facing camera, the dynamic range differences were huge. The painting on the Note 9's image was completely blown out. With the iPhone XS Max, you can see every detail. The XS Max was better at white balance as well.
Now outside, towards the end of the night, both phones didn't that great of a job with dynamic range, but the iPhone XS Max did a little bit better. The white balance is much better on the iPhone as well, and the Note 9 added way too much saturation.
Finally, we have a low light scene with bokeh in the background to compare the portrait & live focus modes. The Note 9 had issues accurately detecting the face and it ended up putting a slight blur over it. The XS Max did a great job with blur edging. The Note 9 was already at the maximum amount of blur, while the XS Max was at the default F4.5 setting.
Now here's where it gets amazing on the iPhone XS Max. We set the depth to the maximum setting of F1.4, and the bokeh really starts to stand out. This shows just how much extra blur you can get on the iPhone XS Max, which we think has the potential to convince a lot of customers to go with the XS or XS Max over the Note 9.
If you compare the blur on the left and right sides of the iPhone's image, you'll see that they're directionally warped, based on where they're at in the frame. This is something that professional cameras do, and it's nice that Apple added this realistic touch. On the Note 9, the bokeh simply gets larger when you increase the blur, and that's about it.
Let us know what you thought about this comparison in the comments, and stay tuned for our iPhone XS Max versus Note 9 video quality comparison, where we'll be testing if Apple's claims of improved video quality are true.
Carrier deals:
The Samsung Galaxy Note 9's camera has similar 12MP sensors behind the telephoto and wide lenses. It also has a live focus feature that simulates background blur, which also allows you to adjust the blur after you snap a photo.
We went out to Coeur d'Alene, Idaho, and snapped a bunch of photos so we could see how Apple's new iPhone XS Max performs against the Note 9.
Comparing High Dynamic Range (HDR)
In this first portrait mode shot, you can see how much better the dynamic range is on the iPhone XS Max. The t-shirt in the Note 9's image is blown out, whereas the XS Max's image is completely balanced. Not only that, but the darkest areas in the shot are brighter on the iPhone.
Here, the sky on the Note 9 is overexposed, and there's a huge loss in color. If you take a close look at the buildings in the background, they're blown out as well. However, the Note 9 was able to keep the subject looking brighter and better exposed. We noticed much more saturation on the Note 9's image as well, which is a personal preference, but we prefer the more natural look.
Here's where the story changes. When shooting against the sun, the Note 9 does a much better job at dynamic range. The highlights look the same, but the Note 9 is able to keep the darkest areas of the scene looking brighter. There's less lens flare on the Note 9 as well.
Now here's a photo of the same scene except using portrait mode. The sunspot on the Note 9 is larger, but it does much better keeping the subject exposed properly. There's a massive flare on the iPhone XS Max's image again.
In this shot, the Note 9 has noticeably better dynamic range inside the parking garage.
Comparing Portrait & Live Focus Mode Photos
In this portrait mode shot, you'll notice that the XS Max has more blur in the background. You'll also notice that the shirt in the Note 9's image is a bit blown out. One thing we like about the XS Max's image is that it's more balanced, with a background that is exposed brighter.The iPhone XS & XS Max have a new depth control feature, and there's a much wider range of blur adjustment compared to the Note 9. The iPhones can go from a depth setting of F16, all the way to F1.4. The Note 9 can only go from 0-7.
The background on the Note 9's Live Focus photos can't get nearly as blurry as they can on the iPhone XS Max, and we think a lot of people would like to have that kind of freedom.
When shooting plants, the Note 9 does a much better job. In this photo, the white balance is more accurate and the image looks more pleasing. The XS Max struggles with blur edging, whereas the Note 9 does just fine.
In this photo of a flower, the XS Max actually blurs out the whole stem. The Note 9 is able to detect the stem and keep it in the foreground. This is a huge advantage for the Note.
Comparing front-facing portrait modes, the Note 9 is looking a bit soft. There's much more detail in the face with the XS Max. The background also looks brighter and more balanced on the iPhone.
Another perk on the XS Max is that you can adjust the blur on the front-facing portrait shots as well. The Note 9 isn't able to do this. Because of this, the XS Max is able to get portrait photos with incredibly high levels of blur, and it actually turns out quite nice.
Comparing Portrait mode photos of objects, the iPhone XS Max is getting much better dynamic range. Both phones struggle with blur edging, but the Note 9 is a little bit better.
In this photo with a small crease on the inside of two poles, the iPhone XS Max completely fails to detect that it needs to blur the inside of the object. The Note 9 does an almost perfect job at it. However, the dynamic range on the Note 9 is quite bad.
Photo Detail Comparison
Now let's compare detail without using Portrait or Live focus modes.In this shot of a flower, both photos look very detailed, but it seems that the Note 9 either has more contrast or it's more detailed compared to the XS Max. You'll have to decide for yourself which photo you think is better at color reproduction.
In this telephoto image of a tree, the Note 9 has more contrast and it has more detail as well.
Here's another comparison of detail. The XS Max has noticeably better dynamic range, and they seem similar in detail. The Note 9 has more contrast and it adds more saturation to the image.
Now comparing regular selfie photos, the difference in dynamic range is shocking. The sky on the Note 9's image is completely blown out. On the XS Max, you can see every single cloud, and the sky is actually blue. At the same time, the face is properly exposed and there's more detail as well.
Here's a wide image shot from the inside of a building. There's noticeably better dynamic range on the XS Max, and it's able to accurately reproduce the colors in the sky and background.
Low Light Photo Comparison
Moving onto some low light photos, there's a couple of things you'll notice here. First of all, the dynamic range is slightly better on the iPhone, and the white balance is much more accurate. The biggest difference is that the Note 9 adds way too much softening to get rid of the noise. Just look at all of the detail in the pants that is lost on the Note 9.In this portrait & live focus mode comparison. The Note 9 fails to accurately detect the face and ends up blurring it, even after multiple attempts. Not only that, but the dynamic range is worlds better on the XS Max.
We shot these images with extremely low light. The Note 9 has very impressive noise reduction, making the image look a lot more detailed. You can easily see more noise with the XS Max. However, the white balance is way off on the Note 9. The XS Max was about as accurate as you can get.
Now on the front-facing camera, the dynamic range differences were huge. The painting on the Note 9's image was completely blown out. With the iPhone XS Max, you can see every detail. The XS Max was better at white balance as well.
Now outside, towards the end of the night, both phones didn't that great of a job with dynamic range, but the iPhone XS Max did a little bit better. The white balance is much better on the iPhone as well, and the Note 9 added way too much saturation.
Finally, we have a low light scene with bokeh in the background to compare the portrait & live focus modes. The Note 9 had issues accurately detecting the face and it ended up putting a slight blur over it. The XS Max did a great job with blur edging. The Note 9 was already at the maximum amount of blur, while the XS Max was at the default F4.5 setting.
Now here's where it gets amazing on the iPhone XS Max. We set the depth to the maximum setting of F1.4, and the bokeh really starts to stand out. This shows just how much extra blur you can get on the iPhone XS Max, which we think has the potential to convince a lot of customers to go with the XS or XS Max over the Note 9.
If you compare the blur on the left and right sides of the iPhone's image, you'll see that they're directionally warped, based on where they're at in the frame. This is something that professional cameras do, and it's nice that Apple added this realistic touch. On the Note 9, the bokeh simply gets larger when you increase the blur, and that's about it.
Let us know what you thought about this comparison in the comments, and stay tuned for our iPhone XS Max versus Note 9 video quality comparison, where we'll be testing if Apple's claims of improved video quality are true.
Deals on the iPhone XS Max and Galaxy Note 9
If you haven't already ordered Apple's iPhone XS Max, wireless carriers are incentivizing the purchase. Want to get your hands on a new device asap? eBay sellers are also shipping units now.Carrier deals:
- AT&T Wireless: Buy one iPhone XS or iPhone XS Max, get a second $700 off when you add a line.
- Verizon Wireless: Buy one iPhone XS or iPhone XS Max, get a second $700 off when you add a line. Or save $100 with an eligible trade.
- Sprint: Get the 64GB iPhone XS for $0 per month with eligible trade-in and Sprint Flex lease.
- T-Mobile: Save up to $300 on the iPhone XS with an eligible iPhone trade.
Comments
I'd be curious to see how the camera on the XS compares to the Pixel 2, or the upcoming Pixel 3, as it's often regarded to be one of the best cameras on a smartphone.
Skin tone Note 9, Dynamic range Xs Max, Detail Note 9, Blur range Xs Max, Blur accuracy Note 9, low light tie.
* Overall; edge to Note 9 (& I’m not a Samsung/Android user) for what we are given.
- The Xs Max skin tones seem off but the video narrator doesn’t comment on that. In another camera comparison AI video, there was often a reference video shot from the pro camera which showed what the proper color should be. This allowed for clearer color comparisons which we don’t have here.
in addition, one needs to be very careful when comparing the out of focus modes to get both as equal in the image as possible when evaluating the disappearance of hair, and other difficult to distinguish features. That can include edges. I can tell you that even today, with two decades of software development, professional software has a problem with hair, when cutting a face out for a comp. we still need to do some manual work to get it all correct. So while it’s great that the Xs can do a lot more in out of focus, the fact that it doesn’t seem to do as well in keeping some edges and hair in focus, is, from the images we see, often the result of a much stronger out of focus effect than the Note can manage. Keeping the amount of effect the same will equalize the two more in that problem area.
A tip that makes it work better. Launch the camera and trigger selfie mode. Hit the settings gear and toggle on Tracking AF.
You should see much better results after it's on .
If they did a blind test where they list a a couple dozen photos and then have the reader determine which phone took it I feel like the Note 9 would come out ahead.
I think somebody who takes pictures for a living would do better in reviewing these pictures. I'm 68 years old and I've been in the advertising industry for over 46 years and photography is just something that as a tool for me.
Now in those photos, if you'd introduced a secondary bright source to the scene, you'd get better exposure of the body and the face:
What you have photographied in those photos is actually the sun, not the person. Since your guy, despite all of his handsomeness cannot shine more than the Sun, the best sun photo is all you can expect of those shots.
And that, only the Xs Max delivers...
Edit:
Ahem..., you may cause people to damage their camera sensors by exposing samples like that. Although reportedly that damage depends on the exposure time, since you have no control on how long people will point their cameras to the sun, a cautious stance might be helpful.
Actually can we reading this article that they preferred the note to the iPhone so I have no idea what you’re talking about