Should you upgrade to the iPhone 11 if you own an iPhone XR?

Posted:
in iPhone
The just-launched iPhone 11 is similar to the iPhone XR in many respects, but still has its fair share of upgrades from the earlier model. AppleInsider weighs up whether it's a good idea for iPhone XR owners to move over to the newest model in Apple's iPhone lineup.

The iPhone 11's range of colors
The iPhone 11's range of colors


As revealed on September 10, Apple continued to provide two distinct tiers of iPhone model in its latest generation, with the iPhone 11 effectively replacing the iPhone XR, considered the value proposition of 2018's iPhone roster. As usual, Apple has made a few changes that could prompt upgrades by owners of older models to opt for the latest version.

The question, however, is whether it is enough to tempt current owners of the iPhone XR to upgrade. It's a difficult question, not least because of the similarities between the two generations.

The Outside and Screen

Just as with the iPhone XR, the iPhone 11 sports an identical 6.1-inch LCD IPS display with a 1792-by-828 pixel resolution, 1400:1 contrast ratio, True Tone support, and 625 nits of maximum brightness. Made from a glass and aluminum case and frame, the models also have the same physical size and weight.

The models are also offered in a wide array of colors, with both available in black, white, and Product(RED), but while the iPhone XR goes for a strong yellow along with a light blue and coral, the iPhone 11 opts for a light yellow, purple, and a pastel-like green.

Apple's iPhone XR, in yellow
Apple's iPhone XR, in yellow


To onlookers, without seeing the rear camera bump and only looking at the front and sides, it is quite easy to confuse the two models at face value, without a closer inspection.

The newer model does have a higher water and dust resistance of IP68 versus IP67, which means it can survive for up to 30 minutes at 2 meters instead of 30 minutes at half the depth.

Cameras

Arguably the main difference between the two models is the extra camera on the back of the iPhone 11. While the iPhone XR has an adequate 12-megapixel wide-angle camera, the iPhone 11 add a second camera, but rather than a telephoto lens as usually offered by dual-camera setups of previous iPhones, this one is a 12-megapixel ultra wide camera.

While not quite the same as wide and telephoto, this is a fairly similar concept to typical dual camera systems, except there's a 2x zoom out to get more of the environment instead of a zoom in to make a tighter frame.

The extra camera also means there's a different camera bump on the back, though instead of the oval style of other iPhones, the iPhone 11 uses a square bump like its stablemates, the iPhone 11 Pro and iPhone 11 Pro Max.

The two cameras on the back of the iPhone 11
The two cameras on the back of the iPhone 11


There have also been some improvements to video, with the iPhone 11 now capable of a 2x optical zoom out while both offer a digital zoom-in to 3x. The iPhone 11 also has "Audio Zoom" and "QuickTake video" for when recordings need to be taken in a short space of time.

Apple's automatic adjustments to photographs is also present here, as with the Pro models, while its Night Mode helps improve low-light photography.

The TrueDepth camera on the front has also been given a boost, upgraded from 7 megapixels to 12 megapixels, along with the capability to record 4K video at 60fps, up from 1080p.

A13 over A12

There are other smaller, but expected, changes under the iPhone 11's skin, such as the move to A13 Bionic instead of the A12 Bionic. Capable of over one trillion operations per second with a 20-percent faster CPU and GPU, the A13 is obviously the better chip, as well as being far more power-efficient than the previous version.

Apple certainly promoted the A13's performance and power efficiency, but it isn't a massive leap from the A12
Apple certainly promoted the A13's performance and power efficiency, but it isn't a massive leap from the A12


At this point, the A12 is still an extremely powerful chip in the smartphone market, so the shift to A13 will certainly cement Apple's position as a processor pioneer. However, while better for the most demanding tasks, such as gaming, it may not necessarily be felt as an improvement in everyday usage.

Sure, there's a massive performance gulf between the A13 and, say, the A11 or earlier versions, but between the A13 and A12, we're talking about apps loading maybe a fraction of a second quicker in the iPhone 11. Given it is unlikely that an iPhone's processing capability will be replied upon in a life-or-death situation, the performance is a nice-to-have but not easily noticeable boost to regular users.

Smaller Changes

The iPhone XR had excellent battery life at its launch, with Apple still marketing it as having up to 16 hours of video playback time. For the iPhone 11, the time has been extended by another hour, which is impressive, but seeing as though the iPhone XR is a device that can last for an entire day being used actively, an extra hour is a comfortable addition, but not as valuable as it once was.

There is also the addition of the U1 chip, which is using Ultra Wideband (UWB) technology. In theory the chip will help the iPhone pinpoint the location of iBeacons and other iOS devices that are also equipped with a U1 chip, and other location-detection applications using features of Bluetooth 5.1, but it is still fairly early in its lifecycle to determine whether it will be of any real use.

Upgrade from XR to 11?

If you were presented with a brand new $699 base model iPhone 11 and a $599 iPhone XR, and was asked which one you would buy, it is highly likely that most AppleInsider readers would opt for the iPhone 11. Sure, it's $100 more, but the extra camera, processing power, and more battery life would be worth it.

The question becomes harder when you already own an iPhone XR. The price difference grows to however much the shortfall is when you trade in your iPhone XR. Based on Apple's website and with a good-condition trade-in for an iPhone XR at $370, that $100 changes to $479 for the base model.

The iPhone XR, with one less camera and the previous A12 chip
The iPhone XR, with one less camera and the previous A12 chip


Seeing as though the processing improvement and the battery life are relatively small increments, the question fundamentally becomes: Is it worth paying $470 to be able to zoom out with a second camera, to take higher-resolution self-portraits, and to film 4K video with the TrueDepth camera?

Unless you are a social media star or a creative professional who highly values the images an iPhone takes, it doesn't really seem to be as much of a deal to pay that much out for zooming out and better night shots. Even so, said social media influencers and creative types would pay the extra again to go for the iPhone 11 Pro and Pro Max to get that third camera lens.

There is the extra option of going down the route of the iPhone Upgrade Program and perpetually upgrading your iPhone to the newest model each year, which may be one way to take the sting out of the effective-upgrade pricing.

Otherwise, it's probably better not to move from the iPhone XR to iPhone 11 after all. Hold on to the smartphone for another year, save the money, and put it towards the 2020 models. Releases that could include better upgrades, including the much-rumored 5G connectivity.

Where to buy

Wireless carriers and third-party Apple resellers are already offering deals on the new iPhone 11, iPhone 11 Pro and iPhone 11 Pro Max. A sampling of the discounts can be found below, while additional promotions can be found in our iPhone 11 deal roundup and iPhone 11 Price Guide. Each offer is subject to terms and conditions, so please consult the merchant's website for a full list of details.

iPhone 11 deals

  • AT&T Wireless: Buy an eligible iPhone and get the iPhone 11 for free when you buy both on a qualifying installment plan with an eligible AT&T unlimited plan. Plus, get a $300 reward card when you order online.
  • Verizon Wireless: Get a free iPhone 11 (64GB) via bill credits when you switch to Verizon with select trade-in and Unlimited plan.
  • Sprint: Starting at $0 per month with Sprint Flex lease and select trade-ins.
  • T-Mobile: Trade up to the new iPhone 11 and get up to 50% off.
  • Walmart: Save up to $100 on the iPhone 11. Offer valid only on purchase with installment plan.
  • Sam's Club: Get a $150 Sam's Club gift card when you buy and activate the iPhone 11 by Nov. 8.
  • Visible: Get up to a $200 Prepaid Mastercard Virtual Account when you buy an iPhone 11 and bring your phone number to Visible. Plus get 0% financing, no money down, no upgrade fees, and free overnight shipping for well-qualified customers.
iPhone XR deals

  • AT&T Wireless: Buy an eligible iPhone and get the iPhone XR for free when you buy both on a qualifying installment plan with an eligible AT&T unlimited plan. Plus, get a $300 reward card when you order online.
  • Verizon Wireless: Buy an iPhone XR on monthly payments, get a 64GB iPhone XR via bill credits. Plus, get a $200 Prepaid Mastercard when you switch to Verizon on Unlimited. After checkout, visit Verizon's Digital Rebate Center and enter promo code SEPTSWITCH200.
  • Sprint: Lease an iPhone XR, get an iPhone XR via bill credits. Requires two new lines or one new and one upgrade.

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 19
    cpsrocpsro Posts: 2,516member
    It's not just the price of the new device but the question of what to do with the "old" one. Trade-in value is poor. Selling on ebay can be much better but is a pain.
    albegarcyojimbo007
  • Reply 2 of 19
    wood1208wood1208 Posts: 2,026member
    Debate/argument of should you upgrade from iPhone XR to iPhone 11 has no clear winner. But, should you upgrade to iPhone 11 from any previous touchid based iPhone or android phone ? And the answer is clear. Absolutely 100% YES. Why ? Because iPhone 11 is fair price all-around, large screen,phone for everyone's need.
    edited September 18 albegarcyojimbo007guscat
  • Reply 3 of 19
    wood1208wood1208 Posts: 2,026member
    cpsro said:
    It's not just the price of the new device but the question of what to do with the "old" one. Trade-in value is poor. Selling on ebay can be much better but is a pain.
    Craiglist is one place you could fetch decent price.
    cornchip
  • Reply 4 of 19
    wood1208 said:
    Debate/argument of should you upgrade from iPhone XR to iPhone 11 has no clear winner. But, should you upgrade to iPhone 11 from any previous touchid based iPhone or android phone ? And the answer is clear. Absolutely 100% YES. Why ? Because iPhone 11 is fair price all-around, large screen,phone for everyone's need.
    But a lot of people prefer simplicity and speed of Touch ID.  Looking forward to in-screen version if they can do
  • Reply 5 of 19
    cpsro said:
    It's not just the price of the new device but the question of what to do with the "old" one. Trade-in value is poor. Selling on ebay can be much better but is a pain.
    I have used craigslist in the past and now Letgo the last two years with no problems.  Some silly lowball offers, but nothing too annoying.. and straight cash no fees like Ebay.
  • Reply 6 of 19
    M68000 said:
    wood1208 said:
    Debate/argument of should you upgrade from iPhone XR to iPhone 11 has no clear winner. But, should you upgrade to iPhone 11 from any previous touchid based iPhone or android phone ? And the answer is clear. Absolutely 100% YES. Why ? Because iPhone 11 is fair price all-around, large screen,phone for everyone's need.
    But a lot of people prefer simplicity and speed of Touch ID.  Looking forward to in-screen version if they can do
    What is slow or complicated about Face Id?  It's a smooth swipe up with no delay on my Xs Max.. raise to wake was made for Face Id.. all one motion.
    guscat
  • Reply 7 of 19
    MplsPMplsP Posts: 1,728member
    wood1208 said:
    Debate/argument of should you upgrade from iPhone XR to iPhone 11 has no clear winner. But, should you upgrade to iPhone 11 from any previous touchid based iPhone or android phone ? And the answer is clear. Absolutely 100% YES. Why ? Because iPhone 11 is fair price all-around, large screen,phone for everyone's need.
    That’s open to debate but regardless, it still doesn’t mean you should upgrade. My car is paid off. I can get a new Tesla model 3 for $38k. It’s a fair price and would fit my needs. Does that mean I should upgrade?

    No matter how you cut it, upgrading costs money. There’s also an environmental cost to device production and disposal. Every new iPhone Apple releases will be better than the previous model. The question is whether your current phone is meeting your needs, and if not, is the cost of upgrading worth the features you would get? If not, the answer is ‘No.’
    designrGeorgeBMac
  • Reply 8 of 19
    jcs2305 said:
    M68000 said:
    wood1208 said:
    Debate/argument of should you upgrade from iPhone XR to iPhone 11 has no clear winner. But, should you upgrade to iPhone 11 from any previous touchid based iPhone or android phone ? And the answer is clear. Absolutely 100% YES. Why ? Because iPhone 11 is fair price all-around, large screen,phone for everyone's need.
    But a lot of people prefer simplicity and speed of Touch ID.  Looking forward to in-screen version if they can do
    What is slow or complicated about Face Id?  It's a smooth swipe up with no delay on my Xs Max.. raise to wake was made for Face Id.. all one motion.
    One of the programmers where I work is hanging onto his 8. It does everything he needs, but he’s not upgrading mostly because he likes TouchID. Oh, he understands the simplicity and the added security and all that of FaceID. He just likes TouchID better. You can’t account for personal preference.
    guscatdesignrmuthuk_vanalingam
  • Reply 9 of 19
    cpsro said:
    It's not just the price of the new device but the question of what to do with the "old" one. Trade-in value is poor. Selling on ebay can be much better but is a pain.
    Trade-in value is actually not poor. I'm surprised at how much Apple is offering for trade-ins. $400 for my two-year old X? $370 for a XR? Sure beats $246 on gazelle and avg eBay of $337 (minus eBay and PayPal fees, putting it closer to ~<300) for my X.
  • Reply 10 of 19
    asdasdasdasd Posts: 5,330member
    I was going to move to an XR this year, from an 8. I rarely buy the latest, but the 11 is so fairly priced the it is worth it. So I will get that. Clever pricing by Apple.
    edited September 18 guscatmuthuk_vanalingamsellerington
  • Reply 11 of 19
    asdasdasdasd Posts: 5,330member
    DAalseth said:
    jcs2305 said:
    M68000 said:
    wood1208 said:
    Debate/argument of should you upgrade from iPhone XR to iPhone 11 has no clear winner. But, should you upgrade to iPhone 11 from any previous touchid based iPhone or android phone ? And the answer is clear. Absolutely 100% YES. Why ? Because iPhone 11 is fair price all-around, large screen,phone for everyone's need.
    But a lot of people prefer simplicity and speed of Touch ID.  Looking forward to in-screen version if they can do
    What is slow or complicated about Face Id?  It's a smooth swipe up with no delay on my Xs Max.. raise to wake was made for Face Id.. all one motion.
    One of the programmers where I work is hanging onto his 8. It does everything he needs, but he’s not upgrading mostly because he likes TouchID. Oh, he understands the simplicity and the added security and all that of FaceID. He just likes TouchID better. You can’t account for personal preference.
    I do too, actually. But it isn't in the 11 so what can you do.
  • Reply 12 of 19
    M68000 said:
    wood1208 said:
    Debate/argument of should you upgrade from iPhone XR to iPhone 11 has no clear winner. But, should you upgrade to iPhone 11 from any previous touchid based iPhone or android phone ? And the answer is clear. Absolutely 100% YES. Why ? Because iPhone 11 is fair price all-around, large screen,phone for everyone's need.
    But a lot of people prefer simplicity and speed of Touch ID.  Looking forward to in-screen version if they can do
    Face ID is at least as fast and far simpler to use than Touch ID. I know because I have both an XR and an iPad Air 3. Face ID reminds me of swipe to unlock. And it certainly seems a lot better than an inscreen Touch ID.
  • Reply 13 of 19
    I hope Apple really made an improvement on the signal reception with Intel modem. I had to get rid of XS as soon as S10 came out. The difference was night and day.
  • Reply 14 of 19
    cpsro said:
    It's not just the price of the new device but the question of what to do with the "old" one. Trade-in value is poor. Selling on ebay can be much better but is a pain.
    Trade-in value is actually not poor. I'm surprised at how much Apple is offering for trade-ins. $400 for my two-year old X? $370 for a XR? Sure beats $246 on gazelle and avg eBay of $337 (minus eBay and PayPal fees, putting it closer to ~<300) for my X.
    Have you heard of Swappa? Current asking price for a good condition 64GB X is $515 minus $20 fee. I've sold several mint condition smartphones via Swappa for minimum of $100 more than trade-in offers. The $500 trade-in deal by VZW is, of course, unbeatable.
  • Reply 15 of 19
    k2kwk2kw Posts: 1,823member
    DAalseth said:
    jcs2305 said:
    M68000 said:
    wood1208 said:
    Debate/argument of should you upgrade from iPhone XR to iPhone 11 has no clear winner. But, should you upgrade to iPhone 11 from any previous touchid based iPhone or android phone ? And the answer is clear. Absolutely 100% YES. Why ? Because iPhone 11 is fair price all-around, large screen,phone for everyone's need.
    But a lot of people prefer simplicity and speed of Touch ID.  Looking forward to in-screen version if they can do
    What is slow or complicated about Face Id?  It's a smooth swipe up with no delay on my Xs Max.. raise to wake was made for Face Id.. all one motion.
    One of the programmers where I work is hanging onto his 8. It does everything he needs, but he’s not upgrading mostly because he likes TouchID. Oh, he understands the simplicity and the added security and all that of FaceID. He just likes TouchID better. You can’t account for personal preference.
    Plus you won’t get skin cancer on your face in 30 years.   Show me studies that say blast IR radiation at your head is safe long term.
  • Reply 16 of 19
    Good, sensible piece. Saved me from making an upgrade I wanted but did not need.
    guscatalbegarc
  • Reply 17 of 19
    I am tempted to upgrade to the iPhone 11 from my iPhone XS. Much better battery life, improved photo processing plus night mode are very good reasons to upgrade. A larger phone with less sharp display plus poor trade in value on my year old phone make for a tough decision. I justified my XS purchase by convincing myself I’d keep it for 2 years but I’m seriously reconsidering now.
    blurpbleepbloopalbegarc
  • Reply 18 of 19
    MplsPMplsP Posts: 1,728member
    k2kw said:
    DAalseth said:
    jcs2305 said:
    M68000 said:
    wood1208 said:
    Debate/argument of should you upgrade from iPhone XR to iPhone 11 has no clear winner. But, should you upgrade to iPhone 11 from any previous touchid based iPhone or android phone ? And the answer is clear. Absolutely 100% YES. Why ? Because iPhone 11 is fair price all-around, large screen,phone for everyone's need.
    But a lot of people prefer simplicity and speed of Touch ID.  Looking forward to in-screen version if they can do
    What is slow or complicated about Face Id?  It's a smooth swipe up with no delay on my Xs Max.. raise to wake was made for Face Id.. all one motion.
    One of the programmers where I work is hanging onto his 8. It does everything he needs, but he’s not upgrading mostly because he likes TouchID. Oh, he understands the simplicity and the added security and all that of FaceID. He just likes TouchID better. You can’t account for personal preference.
    Plus you won’t get skin cancer on your face in 30 years.   Show me studies that say blast IR radiation at your head is safe long term.
    uh oh! Somebody's been spending their time reading conspiracy theories instead of medical and physics text books!
  • Reply 19 of 19
    cpsro said:
    It's not just the price of the new device but the question of what to do with the "old" one. Trade-in value is poor. Selling on ebay can be much better but is a pain.
    One gripe I have with Apple's trade-in program is that it doesn't account for extra storage on the old phone:   Like, when you bought the Xr, going to 128Gb cost (at least) an extra $100.   But, the trade in program completely ignores that premium.   So, if you bought an upgraded phone, you have even more incentive to hang onto it - or maybe sell it on EBay where you can at least get a little bit for that extra storage.
    avon b7
Sign In or Register to comment.