Design poll - help me make an ad choice
Hi all!
I am taking out a small ad in the chamber of commerce newsletter. They have 1200 copies going out and good grayscale-only printing. Anyway, I made 4 alternative ads and set up a poll. Please vote to let me know which ad you all think will be the most effective.
http://multimediabychris.com/poll.php
Thanks for your feedback! - cw
I am taking out a small ad in the chamber of commerce newsletter. They have 1200 copies going out and good grayscale-only printing. Anyway, I made 4 alternative ads and set up a poll. Please vote to let me know which ad you all think will be the most effective.
http://multimediabychris.com/poll.php
Thanks for your feedback! - cw
Comments
The 3rd slogan is appealing though.
However, I feel the background is too bland. I like the background on image number 2 without the crest in the middle. Would it be possible to put the background from number 2 into number 3 to see what it's like?
It certainly the strongest of the four. #1 I just don't get. # 2 looks like a religious event. # 4 just. looks. flat.
#2 was actually interesting to me, but I'm pretty certain that it will print a bit darker than you anticipate. Plus, the fake 3D text seems a bit out of correct perspective and the words you use in the "mathematic formula" don't have a satisfying "mouth feel"... I would think the result of the equation would be better described as giving you "damaged reputation".
#3 gets the product message out there again, on the main stage... and it's *definitely* aimed at a sports-minded crowd, but it sounds so cheesy and self-aggrandizing that I just couldn't do that with MY business.... but of course it might win in a town that lived, eat and pooped their local sports teams.
Of all of the ads, #4 at least puts something vaguely computer-like out for people to see and consider. The simple refinement of the banner area gives it some class. Ultimately, I don't think that the graphic is as effective as it could be.. possibly because I feel like there's a better word pairing to use for the slider.
I voted for #4, but it could stand some tweaks as well as any of the other options... but good luck with whichever you choose!