'Fortnite' not coming back to iOS or Mac any time soon
Apple will not restore Epic Games' App Store developer account that it used for "Fortnite," until all of the appeals for the trial have been exhausted -- which will take years.
Credit: Epic Games
Epic Games CEO Tim Sweeney said on Wednesday that Apple had decided to exercise its right to exclude the company from the App Store. Apple lawyer Mark Perry informed Epic's counsel Gary Bornstein of the decision "late" Tuesday, according to Sweeney.
Additionally, Perry's letter to Epic Games indicated that Apple would not consider any further reinstatement requests until "the district court's judgement becomes final and nonappealable." Sweeney says that process could be as long as five years.
The decision comes after Epic Games submitted a request to Apple to have its developer account reinstated. Apple said it would welcome Epic Games -- and "Fortnite" -- back to the App Store if it played by the same rules as everyone else.
In Apple's message back to Epic Games, the Cupertino tech giant said that the decision was based on the court ruling that Epic Games had intentionally breached its contract and other past "duplicitous conduct."
"Apple lied. Apple spent a year telling the world, the court, and the press they'd 'welcome Epic's return to the App Store if they agree to play by the same rules as everyone else,'" Sweeney wrote. "Epic agreed, and now Apple has reneged in another abuse of its monopoly power over a billion users."
The district court's ruling in the Epic Games v. Apple case came on Sept 10. It decided that Apple was not a monopoly, but that its guidelines prohibiting developers from advertising cheaper in-app purchase prices was anticompetitive. As such, the court gave Apple 90 days to do away with that policy and allow developers to add links or buttons to third-party payment platforms.
The court also decided that Epic Games had breached its contract by sneaking a direct payment platform -- in violation of Apple's guidelines -- in a "Fortnite." That breach of contract is why Apple can retain the ban on Epic's developer account. The court also ordered Epic Games to pay back about 30% of the money it made from the direct payment system.
Apple called the ruling a victory. Epic Games was less happy, and filed to appeal the decision on Sept. 12.
Read on AppleInsider
Credit: Epic Games
Epic Games CEO Tim Sweeney said on Wednesday that Apple had decided to exercise its right to exclude the company from the App Store. Apple lawyer Mark Perry informed Epic's counsel Gary Bornstein of the decision "late" Tuesday, according to Sweeney.
Additionally, Perry's letter to Epic Games indicated that Apple would not consider any further reinstatement requests until "the district court's judgement becomes final and nonappealable." Sweeney says that process could be as long as five years.
The decision comes after Epic Games submitted a request to Apple to have its developer account reinstated. Apple said it would welcome Epic Games -- and "Fortnite" -- back to the App Store if it played by the same rules as everyone else.
In Apple's message back to Epic Games, the Cupertino tech giant said that the decision was based on the court ruling that Epic Games had intentionally breached its contract and other past "duplicitous conduct."
"Apple lied. Apple spent a year telling the world, the court, and the press they'd 'welcome Epic's return to the App Store if they agree to play by the same rules as everyone else,'" Sweeney wrote. "Epic agreed, and now Apple has reneged in another abuse of its monopoly power over a billion users."
The district court's ruling in the Epic Games v. Apple case came on Sept 10. It decided that Apple was not a monopoly, but that its guidelines prohibiting developers from advertising cheaper in-app purchase prices was anticompetitive. As such, the court gave Apple 90 days to do away with that policy and allow developers to add links or buttons to third-party payment platforms.
The court also decided that Epic Games had breached its contract by sneaking a direct payment platform -- in violation of Apple's guidelines -- in a "Fortnite." That breach of contract is why Apple can retain the ban on Epic's developer account. The court also ordered Epic Games to pay back about 30% of the money it made from the direct payment system.
Apple called the ruling a victory. Epic Games was less happy, and filed to appeal the decision on Sept. 12.
Read on AppleInsider
Comments
Apple could play nice and accept Epic again in the App Store, assuming they don't repeat any shenanigans—and stop bitching in social media. Or Apple could nuke their ass by banning all Epic developer accounts (e.g. Unreal Engine) which is allowed to do now, if I've read the verdict correctly.
This "so so" approach only gives air to Epic's fiery comments about being mistreated, at the same time that it don't do enough to really hurt them.
Maybe if Epic retract all the bad things they have said, maybe if they publically state that they were wrong and Apple were right all along, maybe if Epic admit that what they did was childish and a breach of contract, maybe if they apologise to Apple in the newspapers, maybe if they state that they will abide by the same rules as others and not pursue any appeals or attempt to bring new court cases. Maybe then Apple should consider letting them back in. Maybe.
I wonder what Epic's board thinks of Sweeney's performance now, maybe a boot in the ass and hard shove out the door is warranted?
You made your bed, now sleep in it. Follow the rules.
yeah, not how the system works. but thanks for playing along...
The court explicitly told Apple it doesn’t have to do that, ever, so Epic should probably be pleased Apple says they will allow them to come back when the appeal is exhausted, which is better than, you know, never.
It’s also worth noting that Apple will be able to work out the details of how to implement the ruling without Epic’s meddling, at least not directly. Instead, Epic’s (i.e., Unreal Engine’s) customers will be the ones working with Apple to figure this out.
I have no love for Epic (because of the suit), but until they decided to sue Apple, they'd treated the Mac platform better than most cross-platform gaming developers...