Compared: Sony LinkBuds open-design vs. AirPods Pro transparency mode

Posted:
in General Discussion
Sony just released new wireless earbuds with a donut-like hole in the center. Here's how Sony's open approach compares to Apple's transparency mode found on AirPods Pro.

LinkBuds
Sony LinkBuds

Open earbuds aren't anything new

While Sony's take here with the LinkBuds may be new, the idea of headphones that provide situational awareness isn't.

There are two categories of earbuds you'll see most frequently.

There are "closed" earbuds that will seal in your ear. This is also called "passive" noise cancellation, as it achieves this noise-canceling by physically blocking off the outside world from your ears.





Then you have "open" earbuds that are just the opposite. They don't seal themselves in your ears. These can be more breathable, but the bass response can be lacking without a good seal.

Some open earbuds use bone conduction for a similar effect. They don't go in your ears at all but rather are placed behind your ears. Bone conduction headphones typically will have the lowest level audio quality of the lot.

There are many reasons why you want to hear your surroundings that are commonplace among users.

Some, who work in an office, want to make sure they can hear if someone says their name. While outside going down the street -- be it a casual walk or a workout -- you want to know if someone yells or honks at you. And some wearers don't like being cut off from the world around them.

LinkBuds, giving them a try

The LinkBuds themselves are tiny earbuds. They feel like the first "fresh" take on earbuds in a long time.

LinkBuds design
LinkBuds design


There are three sections of each earbud. There is a small wing that fits into the ridges of your ear, a bulbous part that houses the driver and battery, then the donut-shaped ring that covers your ear canal.

They are comfortable to wear, giving us no issue with extended wear. The wing is flat, which means it can easily move front to back but not side to side. This is what allows it to fit into your ear comfortably but not fall out.

Sony has exceptional pedigree in the audio space, and audio quality was above what we expected on these open buds. Prior to wear, we assumed audio would take a tremendous because of the open design. Fortunately, that wasn't the case.

You lose some bass because there is no seal, but otherwise, the earbuds sounded great. They were clear with crisp vocals and volume. The tradeoff is that even though the bass is lower, they present a larger soundstage which we tend to prefer.

Sony LinkBud in case
Sony LinkBuds in their case


The microphone quality was also spot-on. Sony managed to do a good job isolating our voice from background sounds while on calls.

Sony's biggest shortcoming is battery life. The LinkBuds have a 5.5-hour battery rating that goes up to 17 combined with the case, which is just average. On a phone call, that battery dropped lower, only yielding about three hours of use.

Open design versus transparency mode

We were most excited to test how the open style of the LinkBuds compared to the transparency mode found on AirPods Pro. Both allow external audio to reach your ears, but they do so in fundamentally different ways.

LinkBuds versus AirPods Pro


LinkBuds have a hole that allows sound to reach your eardrums. AirPods Pro uses external microphones to detect audio and play it back on the interior speakers.

After plenty of testing, we almost always preferred the LinkBuds approach. Simply put, LinkBuds let you listen to actually what's around you versus listening to a speaker. Real-life will always sound better than what comes through the speaker.

AirPods Pro also tended to amplify other noises beyond what they were. Scratches or high-pitched noises were uncomfortable to hear with AirPods Pro transparency mode.

That said, LinkBuds had issues too. For example, while waiting at Starbucks, we couldn't listen to our audio very well because the store's music was playing. We felt we were battling the in-store music by turning our volume up.

With AirPods Pro, we have the option to turn off transparency mode or even turn on noise-canceling to better block those external noises.

Everyone's a winner

The unique Sony LinkBuds design
The unique Sony LinkBuds design


In this scenario, both earbuds do an excellent job. They're just different jobs. You can't have an open-style earbud while also offering noise cancellation.

If ANC and audio quality are most important, you should look at AirPods Pro or the Sony XM4s, but if you want more awareness and won't use ANC, the LinkBuds are an incredible option.

They have great audio, a unique design, and are much better than any bone conduction headphones we've tried.

Check out our dedicated AirPods Pro price guide for any current deals on Apple's high-end earbuds and you can pick up the Sony LinkBuds on Amazon for $178.

Read on AppleInsider

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 6
    Tech Moan also reviewed these which surprised me since I am used to him covering vintage stuff.
  • Reply 2 of 6
    How much noise do these leak to the person sitting next to you? That’s my big concern and I haven’t seen any reviews address this. 
  • Reply 3 of 6
    Everyone's a winner? Not if you care about your hearing. The big problem with "open" earbuds like these that also lack noise-cancelling--and these don't even offer the small degree of passive isolation you get from non-NC AirPods--is that you're virtually forced to listen at louder volumes to hear music above the surrounding noise. Obviously not an issue in quiet environments (although sound leakage may be a problem there), but around town and on public transportation? Yeah, no. 
    mike1jcs2305
  • Reply 4 of 6
    Andrew_OSUAndrew_OSU Posts: 550member, editor
    charlesn said:
    Everyone's a winner? Not if you care about your hearing. The big problem with "open" earbuds like these that also lack noise-cancelling--and these don't even offer the small degree of passive isolation you get from non-NC AirPods--is that you're virtually forced to listen at louder volumes to hear music above the surrounding noise. Obviously not an issue in quiet environments (although sound leakage may be a problem there), but around town and on public transportation? Yeah, no. 
    Not true at all. These will not hurt your hearing or require you to listen to louder volumes that could damage your ears. You may have to raise it a little, but it is still a speaker in your ear. You don't need too much volume to be able to hear easily enough.

    Also, it isn't a problem with open earbuds that they lack noise cancelling -- that's the whole point. There's a whole ecosystem of open or bone conduction headphones that are designed to let in the world around you.  I had no issues in louder environments hearing with these safely. The volume doesn't go nearly loud enough to hurt your ears.
  • Reply 5 of 6
    Andrew_OSUAndrew_OSU Posts: 550member, editor
    How much noise do these leak to the person sitting next to you? That’s my big concern and I haven’t seen any reviews address this. 
    Very valid question and one of the first things I tested! It is very minimal. standing in my kitchen, I played some music and I couldn't even hear it when holding them two feet from my ears. Only after turning them to face me and turning the volume up could I hear the audio.
    d.j. adequateCloudTalkin
  • Reply 6 of 6
    I bought a pair the day they came out, and I loved them, except for the fact they were very painful to wear.  I wore them multiple hours a day for five days straight hoping my ears would get used to them, but they only got more painful.
Sign In or Register to comment.