US will not tolerate EU fine against Apple, says White House

1235

Comments

  • Reply 81 of 104
    shrave10 said:
    Appeal to what?  A kangaroo court that always fines US companies guilty and EU companies innocent?  
    Do you really believe that the US news bubble that you live in would report on the EU Commission fining EU companies?  Newsflash, they have done so many times, you are just ignorant of it.
    US does not have any organization that can fine companies 10% of global turnover before any court appeals are done.  If the EU is not a definition of a kangaroo court, I don't know what is
    anonymousered oakalgnormwilliamlondonwatto_cobra
     4Likes 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 82 of 104
    shrave10 said:
    shrave10 said:
    Appeal to what?  A kangaroo court that always fines US companies guilty and EU companies innocent?  
    Do you really believe that the US news bubble that you live in would report on the EU Commission fining EU companies?  Newsflash, they have done so many times, you are just ignorant of it.
    US does not have any organization that can fine companies 10% of global turnover before any court appeals are done.  If the EU is not a definition of a kangaroo court, I don't know what is
    If the only thing you're considering is the available fines then you've got a weird-ass definition of a kangaroo court.

    Incidentally, this fine is well short of 10% of global turnover.  It's barely 1% of revenue in the EU.
    edited April 26
    nubusmuthuk_vanalingamwilliamlondonwatto_cobra
     2Likes 1Dislike 1Informative
  • Reply 83 of 104
    avon b7avon b7 Posts: 8,281member
    shrave10 said:
    shrave10 said:
    Appeal to what?  A kangaroo court that always fines US companies guilty and EU companies innocent?  
    Do you really believe that the US news bubble that you live in would report on the EU Commission fining EU companies?  Newsflash, they have done so many times, you are just ignorant of it.
    US does not have any organization that can fine companies 10% of global turnover before any court appeals are done.  If the EU is not a definition of a kangaroo court, I don't know what is
    Who needs fines when you have tariffs? 

    No need for investigations, findings or rulings! Just an executive order and a giant size sharpie pen! 
    tiredskillsnubusmuthuk_vanalingamwatto_cobra
     3Likes 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 84 of 104
    anonymouseanonymouse Posts: 7,098member
    shrave10 said:
    shrave10 said:
    Appeal to what?  A kangaroo court that always fines US companies guilty and EU companies innocent?  
    Do you really believe that the US news bubble that you live in would report on the EU Commission fining EU companies?  Newsflash, they have done so many times, you are just ignorant of it.
    US does not have any organization that can fine companies 10% of global turnover before any court appeals are done.  If the EU is not a definition of a kangaroo court, I don't know what is
    If the only thing you're considering is the available fines then you've got a weird-ass definition of a kangaroo court.

    Incidentally, this fine is well short of 10% of global turnover.  It's barely 1% of revenue in the EU.
    Again, it's a moot point, but the Ireland case shows that the EU is running kangaroo courts.
    halukstiredskillsshrave10williamlondonwatto_cobra
     4Likes 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 85 of 104
    avon b7avon b7 Posts: 8,281member
    red oak said:
    krawall said:
    I think it's time for the gloves to come off. honestly... this is a disgrace. How long are you guys across the pond (westwards, to be clear) watching this disaster unfolding?

    Yes the US are very important for the whole world's economy, but there's limits to everything. We should stop this appeasing and just call out things what they are. The US government decided that diplomacy is no longer "in", so the rest of the world should not be trying to uphold principles towards the US that are not reciprocated. 
    “Time for the gloves to come off”.    LoL.  The EU has no technology.    Zero. Nothing.   That is why it spends all its time with bureaucracy  and trying to fine everyone 

    Go ahead and “take your gloves off”  LoL 
    Technology isn't everything.

    There is an EU document out there from the pandemic period analysing strategic dependencies between the EU and other countries/trading blocs.

    The US was dependent on the EU for over 260 products. 

    The EU was dependent on the US for 15.

    Areas where the EU was ahead included Advanced manufacturing, IoT, security, advanced materials, photonics and active ingredients for the pharmaceutical industry. 

    Most of that happens to involve 'technology'. 

    watto_cobra
     0Likes 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 86 of 104
    anonymouseanonymouse Posts: 7,098member
    avon b7 said:

    Technology isn't everything.

    [...]

    Most of that happens to involve 'technology'. 

    Well, make up your mind, which is it?
    tiredskillswilliamlondonwatto_cobra
     2Likes 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 87 of 104
    avon b7avon b7 Posts: 8,281member
    avon b7 said:

    Technology isn't everything.

    [...]

    Most of that happens to involve 'technology'. 

    Well, make up your mind, which is it?
    My mind is clear. Very clear. Let me repeat:

    Technology isn't everything.

    However, of the examples I mentioned, many just 'happened' to involve technology.

    That's why I used the verb 'happen'.

    In response to the claim that the EU had 'Zero. Nothing.' in technology.

    It clearly does, even though 'technology' isn't everything. 
    watto_cobra
     0Likes 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 88 of 104
    anonymouseanonymouse Posts: 7,098member
    avon b7 said:
    avon b7 said:

    Technology isn't everything.

    [...]

    Most of that happens to involve 'technology'. 

    Well, make up your mind, which is it?
    My mind is clear. Very clear. Let me repeat:

    Technology isn't everything.

    However, of the examples I mentioned, many just 'happened' to involve technology.

    That's why I used the verb 'happen'.

    In response to the claim that the EU had 'Zero. Nothing.' in technology.

    It clearly does, even though 'technology' isn't everything. 
    It isn't but it is. Ok, if you say so.
    tiredskillswilliamlondonwatto_cobra
     2Likes 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 89 of 104
    red oakred oak Posts: 1,117member
    avon b7 said:
    red oak said:
    krawall said:
    I think it's time for the gloves to come off. honestly... this is a disgrace. How long are you guys across the pond (westwards, to be clear) watching this disaster unfolding?

    Yes the US are very important for the whole world's economy, but there's limits to everything. We should stop this appeasing and just call out things what they are. The US government decided that diplomacy is no longer "in", so the rest of the world should not be trying to uphold principles towards the US that are not reciprocated. 
    “Time for the gloves to come off”.    LoL.  The EU has no technology.    Zero. Nothing.   That is why it spends all its time with bureaucracy  and trying to fine everyone 

    Go ahead and “take your gloves off”  LoL 
    Technology isn't everything.

    There is an EU document out there from the pandemic period analysing strategic dependencies between the EU and other countries/trading blocs.

    The US was dependent on the EU for over 260 products. 

    The EU was dependent on the US for 15.

    Areas where the EU was ahead included Advanced manufacturing, IoT, security, advanced materials, photonics and active ingredients for the pharmaceutical industry. 

    Most of that happens to involve 'technology'. 

    “An EU document out there”.   LoL 

    The EU is a leader in NONE of those examples you give.   NONE.    You really think the EU leads the US in advanced materials?    What are you smoking.   I’m surprised you did not list Spotify as your leading tech company 
    edited April 26
    tiredskillswilliamlondonwatto_cobra
     2Likes 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 90 of 104
    anonymouseanonymouse Posts: 7,098member
    red oak said:
    avon b7 said:
    red oak said:
    krawall said:
    I think it's time for the gloves to come off. honestly... this is a disgrace. How long are you guys across the pond (westwards, to be clear) watching this disaster unfolding?

    Yes the US are very important for the whole world's economy, but there's limits to everything. We should stop this appeasing and just call out things what they are. The US government decided that diplomacy is no longer "in", so the rest of the world should not be trying to uphold principles towards the US that are not reciprocated. 
    “Time for the gloves to come off”.    LoL.  The EU has no technology.    Zero. Nothing.   That is why it spends all its time with bureaucracy  and trying to fine everyone 

    Go ahead and “take your gloves off”  LoL 
    Technology isn't everything.

    There is an EU document out there from the pandemic period analysing strategic dependencies between the EU and other countries/trading blocs.

    The US was dependent on the EU for over 260 products. 

    The EU was dependent on the US for 15.

    Areas where the EU was ahead included Advanced manufacturing, IoT, security, advanced materials, photonics and active ingredients for the pharmaceutical industry. 

    Most of that happens to involve 'technology'. 

    “An EU document out there”.   LoL 

    The EU is a leader in NONE of those examples you give.   NONE.    You really think the EU leads the US in advanced materials?    What are you smoking.   I’m surprised you did not list Spotify as your leading tech company 
    Well, being ahead isn't everything.  :D
    watto_cobra
     1Like 0Dislikes 0Informatives
  • Reply 91 of 104
    avon b7avon b7 Posts: 8,281member
    red oak said:
    avon b7 said:
    red oak said:
    krawall said:
    I think it's time for the gloves to come off. honestly... this is a disgrace. How long are you guys across the pond (westwards, to be clear) watching this disaster unfolding?

    Yes the US are very important for the whole world's economy, but there's limits to everything. We should stop this appeasing and just call out things what they are. The US government decided that diplomacy is no longer "in", so the rest of the world should not be trying to uphold principles towards the US that are not reciprocated. 
    “Time for the gloves to come off”.    LoL.  The EU has no technology.    Zero. Nothing.   That is why it spends all its time with bureaucracy  and trying to fine everyone 

    Go ahead and “take your gloves off”  LoL 
    Technology isn't everything.

    There is an EU document out there from the pandemic period analysing strategic dependencies between the EU and other countries/trading blocs.

    The US was dependent on the EU for over 260 products. 

    The EU was dependent on the US for 15.

    Areas where the EU was ahead included Advanced manufacturing, IoT, security, advanced materials, photonics and active ingredients for the pharmaceutical industry. 

    Most of that happens to involve 'technology'. 

    “An EU document out there”.   LoL 

    The EU is a leader in NONE of those examples you give.   NONE.    You really think the EU leads the US in advanced materials?    What are you smoking.   I’m surprised you did not list Spotify as your leading tech company 
    Well, I'm not going to go out of my way to locate it. I have better things to do. I read it during the pandemic. I've posted some of the things I remember from the document, which was an official EU document.

    And I didn't even mention 'leader'. The document was on strategic dependencies. 

    As for 'believing', forgive me for siding with the EU when it comes to official documents.

    I just did a very quick Google on photonics where it appears the EU is second only to China.

    This explains why the EU sees photonics as a cornerstone technology;

    https://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/policy/communities-and-networks/s3-community-of-practice/partnership_industrial_mod_photonic_en#:~:text=These sectors are critical for,leader in research and innovation.
    edited April 26
    watto_cobra
     0Likes 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 92 of 104
    IreneWirenew Posts: 313member
    red oak said:
    avon b7 said:
    red oak said:
    krawall said:
    I think it's time for the gloves to come off. honestly... this is a disgrace. How long are you guys across the pond (westwards, to be clear) watching this disaster unfolding?

    Yes the US are very important for the whole world's economy, but there's limits to everything. We should stop this appeasing and just call out things what they are. The US government decided that diplomacy is no longer "in", so the rest of the world should not be trying to uphold principles towards the US that are not reciprocated. 
    “Time for the gloves to come off”.    LoL.  The EU has no technology.    Zero. Nothing.   That is why it spends all its time with bureaucracy  and trying to fine everyone 

    Go ahead and “take your gloves off”  LoL 
    Technology isn't everything.

    There is an EU document out there from the pandemic period analysing strategic dependencies between the EU and other countries/trading blocs.

    The US was dependent on the EU for over 260 products. 

    The EU was dependent on the US for 15.

    Areas where the EU was ahead included Advanced manufacturing, IoT, security, advanced materials, photonics and active ingredients for the pharmaceutical industry. 

    Most of that happens to involve 'technology'. 

    “An EU document out there”.   LoL 

    The EU is a leader in NONE of those examples you give.   NONE.    You really think the EU leads the US in advanced materials?    What are you smoking.   I’m surprised you did not list Spotify as your leading tech company 
    Well, being ahead isn't everything.  :D
    Well, whoever is the "leader" right now (and I will gladly admit the US has an overwhelming share of Nobel Prize winners), that will change once The Orange One is done dismantling the universities.

    Sad.
    watto_cobra
     1Like 0Dislikes 0Informatives
  • Reply 93 of 104
    oxonrich said:
    oxonrich said:

    The DMA isn't an extortion racket.
    Sorry, but if it weren't an extortion racket they would publish actual regulations that tell companies like Apple precisely what compliance consists of. Do they do that? No, they don't, they just "find" that whatever these companies, with no concrete guidance at all on what is expected, did do "wasn't sufficient". Classic racket.
    The regulations are clear. Others manage to comply. 
    Others? Oh good one, thought you were being serious for a moment. I know, the whole "gatekeeper" pretense makes this so ridiculous.

    Your ignorance is showing. 

    If you're really not a fan of kangaroo courts, perhaps it is time to speak up about the disgrace that is your SC. 
    williamlondonwatto_cobra
     0Likes 2Dislikes 0Informatives
  • Reply 94 of 104
    red oak said:
    avon b7 said:
    red oak said:
    krawall said:
    I think it's time for the gloves to come off. honestly... this is a disgrace. How long are you guys across the pond (westwards, to be clear) watching this disaster unfolding?

    Yes the US are very important for the whole world's economy, but there's limits to everything. We should stop this appeasing and just call out things what they are. The US government decided that diplomacy is no longer "in", so the rest of the world should not be trying to uphold principles towards the US that are not reciprocated. 
    “Time for the gloves to come off”.    LoL.  The EU has no technology.    Zero. Nothing.   That is why it spends all its time with bureaucracy  and trying to fine everyone 

    Go ahead and “take your gloves off”  LoL 
    Technology isn't everything.

    There is an EU document out there from the pandemic period analysing strategic dependencies between the EU and other countries/trading blocs.

    The US was dependent on the EU for over 260 products. 

    The EU was dependent on the US for 15.

    Areas where the EU was ahead included Advanced manufacturing, IoT, security, advanced materials, photonics and active ingredients for the pharmaceutical industry. 

    Most of that happens to involve 'technology'. 

    “An EU document out there”.   LoL 

    The EU is a leader in NONE of those examples you give.   NONE.    You really think the EU leads the US in advanced materials?    What are you smoking.   I’m surprised you did not list Spotify as your leading tech company 
    Which US company is ahead of ASML?
    williamlondonwatto_cobra
     1Like 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 95 of 104
    anonymouseanonymouse Posts: 7,098member
    oxonrich said:
    oxonrich said:
    oxonrich said:

    The DMA isn't an extortion racket.
    Sorry, but if it weren't an extortion racket they would publish actual regulations that tell companies like Apple precisely what compliance consists of. Do they do that? No, they don't, they just "find" that whatever these companies, with no concrete guidance at all on what is expected, did do "wasn't sufficient". Classic racket.
    The regulations are clear. Others manage to comply. 
    Others? Oh good one, thought you were being serious for a moment. I know, the whole "gatekeeper" pretense makes this so ridiculous.

    Your ignorance is showing. 

    If you're really not a fan of kangaroo courts, perhaps it is time to speak up about the disgrace that is your SC. 
    You're right, SCOTUS is a disgrace right now, but what does that have to do with the topic we are discussing? Why nothing at all it turns out. Nice try with the whataboutism.
    williamlondon
     1Like 0Dislikes 0Informatives
  • Reply 96 of 104
    gatorguygatorguy Posts: 24,740member
    avon b7 said:
    red oak said:
    avon b7 said:
    red oak said:
    krawall said:
    I think it's time for the gloves to come off. honestly... this is a disgrace. How long are you guys across the pond (westwards, to be clear) watching this disaster unfolding?

    Yes the US are very important for the whole world's economy, but there's limits to everything. We should stop this appeasing and just call out things what they are. The US government decided that diplomacy is no longer "in", so the rest of the world should not be trying to uphold principles towards the US that are not reciprocated. 
    “Time for the gloves to come off”.    LoL.  The EU has no technology.    Zero. Nothing.   That is why it spends all its time with bureaucracy  and trying to fine everyone 

    Go ahead and “take your gloves off”  LoL 
    Technology isn't everything.

    There is an EU document out there from the pandemic period analysing strategic dependencies between the EU and other countries/trading blocs.

    The US was dependent on the EU for over 260 products. 

    The EU was dependent on the US for 15.

    Areas where the EU was ahead included Advanced manufacturing, IoT, security, advanced materials, photonics and active ingredients for the pharmaceutical industry. 

    Most of that happens to involve 'technology'. 

    “An EU document out there”.   LoL 

    The EU is a leader in NONE of those examples you give.   NONE.    You really think the EU leads the US in advanced materials?    What are you smoking.   I’m surprised you did not list Spotify as your leading tech company 
    Well, I'm not going to go out of my way to locate it. I have better things to do. I read it during the pandemic. I've posted some of the things I remember from the document, which was an official EU document.
    https://commission.europa.eu/system/files/2021-05/swd-strategic-dependencies-capacities_en.pdf
    muthuk_vanalingam
     1Like 0Dislikes 0Informatives
  • Reply 97 of 104
    krawall said:
    I think it's time for the gloves to come off. honestly... this is a disgrace. How long are you guys across the pond (westwards, to be clear) watching this disaster unfolding?

    Yes the US are very important for the whole world's economy, but there's limits to everything. We should stop this appeasing and just call out things what they are. The US government decided that diplomacy is no longer "in", so the rest of the world should not be trying to uphold principles towards the US that are not reciprocated. 
    No - The gloves have come off, because the US is constantly ripped off and walked over by other countries. The EU imposes a 10% tariff on all incoming vehicles on the US, while the US only has a 2.5% tariff on EU made autos.  A reciprocal tariff here is completely fair game. The EU plays this "we need competition" game, when they are the ones being anti-competitive. The EU claims to be anti-monopoly...unless is European.

    shrave10williamlondonwatto_cobra
     2Likes 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 98 of 104
    oxonrich said:
    oxonrich said:
    oxonrich said:

    The DMA isn't an extortion racket.
    Sorry, but if it weren't an extortion racket they would publish actual regulations that tell companies like Apple precisely what compliance consists of. Do they do that? No, they don't, they just "find" that whatever these companies, with no concrete guidance at all on what is expected, did do "wasn't sufficient". Classic racket.
    The regulations are clear. Others manage to comply. 
    Others? Oh good one, thought you were being serious for a moment. I know, the whole "gatekeeper" pretense makes this so ridiculous.

    Your ignorance is showing. 

    If you're really not a fan of kangaroo courts, perhaps it is time to speak up about the disgrace that is your SC. 
    You're right, SCOTUS is a disgrace right now, but what does that have to do with the topic we are discussing? Why nothing at all it turns out. Nice try with the whataboutism.
    Call it what you want.   The simple truth, demonstrated by all of your posts, is that you don't understand something so you are making out that it's wrong/bad.   That puts you in the same bracket as your dumb as a fence post Commander in Chief.   

    The collapse of your economy can't come soon enough.


    williamlondonwatto_cobra
     0Likes 2Dislikes 0Informatives
  • Reply 99 of 104

    macguy85 said:
    krawall said:
    I think it's time for the gloves to come off. honestly... this is a disgrace. How long are you guys across the pond (westwards, to be clear) watching this disaster unfolding?

    Yes the US are very important for the whole world's economy, but there's limits to everything. We should stop this appeasing and just call out things what they are. The US government decided that diplomacy is no longer "in", so the rest of the world should not be trying to uphold principles towards the US that are not reciprocated. 
    No - The gloves have come off, because the US is constantly ripped off and walked over by other countries. The EU imposes a 10% tariff on all incoming vehicles on the US, while the US only has a 2.5% tariff on EU made autos.  A reciprocal tariff here is completely fair game. The EU plays this "we need competition" game, when they are the ones being anti-competitive. The EU claims to be anti-monopoly...unless is European.

    You think the Tariff is why Europeans don't buy your cars.   hahahahahaha
    nubuswilliamlondon
     1Like 1Dislike 0Informatives
  • Reply 100 of 104
    shrave10 said:
    shrave10 said:
    Appeal to what?  A kangaroo court that always fines US companies guilty and EU companies innocent?  
    Do you really believe that the US news bubble that you live in would report on the EU Commission fining EU companies?  Newsflash, they have done so many times, you are just ignorant of it.
    US does not have any organization that can fine companies 10% of global turnover before any court appeals are done.  If the EU is not a definition of a kangaroo court, I don't know what is
    If the only thing you're considering is the available fines then you've got a weird-ass definition of a kangaroo court.

    Incidentally, this fine is well short of 10% of global turnover.  It's barely 1% of revenue in the EU.
    As per the article  above this comments section, the EU may have lowered their fines so as not to draw too much attention from the White House.  But it failed.  They noticed. 

    Reuters is reporting that Whitehouse officials will begin unveiling trade deals within the next 2-3 weeks.  You can bet that when they are negotiating with the EU, the kangaroo court system otherwise known as the DMA will be  rewritten.   

    US has no organization that can start fining companies 10% of global annual revenue within 60 days without any due court proceedings.  Currently the EU offers no ability for US companies to contest their viewpoints in an EU court of law before incurring massive fines that include up to 10% of global annual revenue of the company with 60 days warning.  They can also levy up to 5% of average daily worldwide turnover without any court proceedings. 

    It’s like they are the judge, jury, and executioner without needing to follow any existing laws.  And they use the act to zero in on U.S. companies while leaving EU and Chinese companies relatively unscathed. 

    I suspect the DMA framework will be rewritten during any trade negotiations.  

    If the EU does not flex on this, then I would not be surprised if the White House even threatens to put in place a similar entity in US solely for scrutinizing foreign companies doing business in U.S.  and allow them to implement similar penalties on foriegn companies based on 10% of their global revenues within 60 days and without any formal court proceedings to see if any laws are violated. 

    Maybe the EU will see the unfairness in their DMA system then?

    williamlondonwatto_cobra
     1Like 1Dislike 0Informatives
Sign In or Register to comment.