Final Cut Studio... MB, or MBP?
I am planning on buy a MB or a MBP and getting Final Cut Studio from an educational accomodation but im not sure which i should get, keep in mind that im a student on a budget but i was thinking a MBP with the following...
-1.8 Ghz Proccessor
-15" Screen (glossy or not?)
-80 GB HD
-2 Gigs Ram (Ill add it myself)
But that would run me basically 2k.
or MB
-2.0 Ghz
-13.3 Screen
-60 GB HD
-2 Gigs of Ram (ill add it myself)
I really need screen size for video editing and ill get a external drive regardless. So would 1.8 be enough to video edit and also CS3?
-1.8 Ghz Proccessor
-15" Screen (glossy or not?)
-80 GB HD
-2 Gigs Ram (Ill add it myself)
But that would run me basically 2k.
or MB
-2.0 Ghz
-13.3 Screen
-60 GB HD
-2 Gigs of Ram (ill add it myself)
I really need screen size for video editing and ill get a external drive regardless. So would 1.8 be enough to video edit and also CS3?
Comments
Originally posted by skatman
MacBook will be sufficient.
I'm sorry I have to disagree. The Macbook will run FCS but Apple doesn't not support that configuration. You will want to be able to use Motion 2 for many tasks and it simply doesn't run very well at all on integrated graphics. With the MBP you get a dedicated 128MB or 256MB of RAM on discrete graphics. This will help you tremendously on FCS. I expect more GPU functionality coming in the next version of FCS.
You also have the expresscard slots which could be important for adding fast storage or other items. If you can afford it..go MBP is my advice. If money is tight and you just want to run the basics then as Skatman has said the MB will suffice.
Put a generous helping of RAM in whatever you buy and consider adding a Hitachi Travelstar 7200rpm drive. Hitachi's drives tend to run cooler than the comparable Seagate.
Thanks guys
I think we may see a 13 inch MacBook Pro offered once the hype about the Macbooks subside.
Since Apple never really changed the enclosure of the Macbook Pros from the G4 Powerbooks....I think such an update would come when Apple does a complete redesign maybe by next January. Perhaps releasing the 13 inch version first to spur sales.
But then again...I have no friggin clue. :-)
Yes, 13 inches isnt ideal for video editing, but if you are an editor or photo journalist who travels extensively, it is perfect. And then you could hook it up to a larger monitor when home. Because lets face it, even a 15 inch and dare I say it a 17 inch laptop isnt IDEAL for video editing either.
SO...if you are going to hook it up to a monitor ANYWAY when at home, making a 13 inch highly portable version for professionals(or those who travel alot) is a major niche that Apple has overlooked for too long.
The poor 12 inch power book ALWAYS got short changed. EVEN when there was a consumer ibook available for years...APPLE still crippled the 12 powerbook. Never giving it any of the bells and whistles its bigger pro laptops enjoyed. It was very frustrating for us power users who wanted a pro laptop to take on the road with us.
Just my two cents.
Everyday I come to work and dock my HP laptop I think to myself that this is how it's supposed to be. However what Apple could do is innovate the dock a bit more than what many people are doing. Add a drive to the dock that supports SMB/CIFS or the ability to run triple head and USB Firewire hub.
Man the Powerbook Duo series was sooooo cool back in the days but it just wasn't powerful enough. Today we need something like that where our laptop becomes a beast at home.
Let's hope Apple is listening.