ruddy
About
- Username
- ruddy
- Joined
- Visits
- 0
- Last Active
- -
- Roles
- member
- Badges
- 0
- Posts
- 94
Reactions
Comments
-
Quote: Originally Posted by d4NjvRzf I haven't heard anyone up in arms about the existence of Mono, the clean-room implementation of the .NET APIs which has been around for many years. Microsoft hasn't made any noise. Why would they? Microsof…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by ItsTheInternet I did not listen to the oral arguments and I am not a lawyer nor a US citizen so I am particularly removed from this case. I am speaking only in terms of what is reasonable to a developer. What yo…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy Curious... Are you an attorney, and if so specializing in patent law? Nope, this discussion is about Copyright law. Quote: Are you claiming there's no question that Google will be found guilty of co…
-
Alsup's first epic fail is in elevating interoperability, an argument which has occasionally been used for a fair use defense of infringement, to be an excuse to deny copyrightability. He simply made this up. There is no precedent for it, and it's a…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by ItsTheInternet I know that no serious developer I have ever met has held that APIs are copyrightable, Even if this were true (which it obviously isn't) since when are software developers arbiters of copyright law…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by ItsTheInternet It seems pretty unlikely they will prevail. Obviously you didn't listen to the hearing in front of the Appeals Court. The judge's questions and comments give pretty solid indication they will reverse …
-
Quote: Originally Posted by gwmac I think the biggest threat to Android was the Oracle lawsuit over Java against Google but that was dismissed. You are going to be in for a surprise on the Java copyright case.
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy Was it really all that hard to admit the absolute position you originally took, and that I pointed out was never stated by any court, or President or any other EU or US official, was a bit overstated? Nop…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy I'm not aware of anyone here in denial about which way the wind is blowing. There's absolutely a push for clarity and direction and everyone understands that. You're shifting to a false argument if that's …
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy http://www.fosspatents.com/2014/02/us-and-eu-antitrust-enforcers-take.html Antitrust regulators have a habit of making a lot of noise and then backing off when it comes to actual remedies and punishments. …
-
Quote: @ruddy: Sure, but neither left or right cases you cited support your claim. In the former, Judge Posner states: To begin with Motorola's injunctive claim, I don't see how, given FRAND, I would be justified in enjoining Apple from infrin…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy What did all that have to do with an SEP holder giving up patent enforcement rights that they did not agree to? The limited trading away of specific rights was addressed within the voluntary agreements betw…
-
I am aware the ITC has upcoming decisions to make about injunctions for SEPs. I believe they will recall the President's policy this time, and recall what happens when they make decisions contrary to the President's clearly stated policy, and I beli…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by tooltalk 4) Contrary to ruddy's misleading comment, no court ruled anything out on SEP cases. Yet another AI poster who makes up his own information to suit his bias and blow a lot of hot air around. US courts are d…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Gatorguy So then "no injunctions for SEP's... PERIOD", which is what you originally said isn't true (and by your own admission) just as I posted. Just as I posted. Puffery won't change that. Perhaps you should try "h…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by leavingthebigG With this DOJ decision in effect does it mean the SEPs in the March trial have to be discarded if they are being used for injunctions? Nope. A real court trial (unlike an ITC judgment) can decide dama…
-
Injunctions for SEPs in the US is history now, like has already been decided in much of Europe (except Germany).
-
Quote: It is a falsehood, you made up the specifics of what I said, what I actually said was that I believed they had abandoned most arguments from their opening statement. You Couldn't provide their opening statement Couldn't provide anyth…
-
What part of Quote: exclusionary relief should be available based only on the relevant factors described in the Policy Statement don't you understand? English does not appear to be your first language. I suggest you actually read the bottom 2¶…
-
Quote: So prove it. You made the claim Apple abandoned its defense of claiming the pro-competitive effects of the agency model. It's up to you to prove that isn't a falsehood. Quote: Cote appears to cite precedent: She cites 2 cases, Toys R…