Samsung asks judge to dismiss Apple's appeal of Japanese court ruling

in General Discussion edited January 2014
Samsung on Monday asked a Japanese court judge to conclude a patent infringement suit with Apple for which the Korean company won a favorable ruling in August, seeking to end the case without hearing an appeal from the Cupertino tech giant's lawyers.

Galaxy Tab 7
Samsung's Galaxy Tab 7.

The request to conclude proceedings was tendered to Judge Shuhei Shiotsuki of the Intellectual Property High Court in Tokyo as both parties presented their first oral arguments, reports Bloomberg. The IPHC is a specialized branch of the Tokyo High Court established in 2005 to deal with Japanese court appeals regarding certain patent litigation.

Apple is appealing a ruling handed down in August 2012 by Tokyo District Court Judge Tamotsu Shoji, who found Samsung's Galaxy devices to not infringe on Apple's JP Patent No. 4,204,977. Judge Shoji said he found it "hard to believe the products belong to the range of technologies of the claimant," referring to Apple's patent for synchronizing music and video in devices to off-site servers.

The original suit, first filed in 2011, sought to ban Japanese sales of Samsung's Galaxy S and Galaxy S II smartphones and the Galaxy Tab 7. Apple was also asking for 100 million yen, or roughly $1.3 million at the time, in damages.

Counsel for both parties are scheduled to meet for the next round of talks on March 21, said Judge Shiotsuki.

Both leaders in the booming smartphone market, Apple and Samsung are locked in numerous patent battles around the world. As part of the ongoing court struggle, Apple was awarded over $1 billion by a U.S. jury in the landmark Apple v. Samsung trial that found the Samsung in violation of six utility and design patents. That case is currently in post-trial proceedings.


  • Reply 1 of 5
    metrixmetrix Posts: 256member
    3. Worst Company in the World goes to none other than Samsung
  • Reply 2 of 5

    How unsurprising. Why is that even news?


  • Reply 3 of 5
    krawallkrawall Posts: 163member
    I guess it doesn't surprise anyone but it's still news, ie, happening, so it's reported here.

    I really wonder what is happening next on the legal front. Last time I checked the computer shop in our mall and most smaller notebooks looked like Macbook Airs.
  • Reply 4 of 5
    ok... i overlooked the grammatically incorrect headline, but i just couldn't get by "ardfguments".
  • Reply 5 of 5
    Samroid knows that when you are stealing IP a good legal move is always handy
Sign In or Register to comment.