One month later: iPhone XS against the iPhone X in the real world

AppleInsider

At the launch of the iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max, most reviewers including ourselves agreed that those who purchased an iPhone X should skip the iPhone XS model and wait another year. After a month with the iPhone XS Max, the answer isn't so clear cut.

The iPhone XS feels as premium as ever with its stainless steel and glass construction, but being a fan of gold, I really like Apple's new color option. I spent a year with a space gray iPhone X and I noticed small scratches on the band after only a few days, but the new gold band is holding up incredibly well.

The big picture

Like many people upgrading from the iPhone X, I went with the iPhone XS Max, mainly because of the larger display. Since the launch of Apple's iPhone 6 Plus, I always went with Plus-sized iPhones, and moving to the smaller iPhone X was a noticeable change.

It's true that the 5.8-inch display is technically larger if you measure it diagonally, but the 5.5-inch display on the iPhone 8 Plus actually has more screen real estate. Jumping up to the 6.5-inch display has been really nice, especially for watching videos and using the phone in landscape orientation.

The XS Max is definitely challenging to use compared to the iPhone XS or even the iPhone 8 Plus, even for those with larger hands. The display is so huge, reaching the top-right corner to pull down the control center is very difficult to do with one hand.

The display seems effectively identical to the iPhone X, so you may not notice a difference with the iPhone XS. Apple did make significant improvements to the display technology in its newest releases, leading DisplayMate to give the iPhone XS Max their "Best SmartPhone display award" because it matched or broke records in 8 different categories.

In real world usage, you probably won't notice the difference, since the iPhone X already has a great display.

When watching YouTube, even though the XS Max has 2,688 x 1242 resolution, the 1440P option was removed from the app. Even so, the upscaled 1080P still looks quite good.

Scratches and signal

Apple did mention it had used stronger glass, which considering the number of drop tests performed online is quite believable, but unfortunately it still scratches just as easily as before. After only a few days, a couple of inch-long scratches were easy to spot. Pretty disappointing.

Apple touted cellular connectivity improvements but there's little visible difference in speed, though this could easily be influenced by the carrier's networks.. There are a few places in town where coverage is less than idea, but again there isn't any real difference in these areas, which is a bummer.

This will of course vary based on your city and carrier and there are some speed tests out there showing some huge improvements, but it seems that Android flagships still perform better.

Performance

Apple newest models include the beastly A12 Bionic processor, built on TSMC's latest 7-nanometer process, meaning more power and lower power consumption. The A11 Bionic was already a super fast processor, even beating the recently-released Note 9 even though it's a year old already. Since the iPhone X was already so quick, there wasn't any expectation of major performance improvements, but I was wrong.

Everything is definitely faster and smoother, from Face ID to apps being launched faster, along with keeping background apps open for longer. Lag is practically nonexistent.

When compared to the Note 9 in terms of gaming, the results from the iPhone XS were very impressive, with perfectly smooth playback where the iPhone X would slow down at times. Both phones were compared in Geekbench 4's graphics test, revealing a huge improvement in scores, so no wonder it performs so well. It's basically the ultimate mobile gaming experience with the larger display, which makes the gaming UI feel a lot less cramped compared to the iPhone X.

High Fidelity

The speakers have also received an upgrade, making them seem more balanced and with improvements to the high frequencies, but not much louder than before. It's definitely noticeable if you watch a lot of videos or are playing games like Fortnite where the upgrades over the iPhone X are more apparent.

Unfortunately, the earpiece speaker stopped working after about a week of usage, but thankfully before I had a chance to swap it at Apple, the firmware update that fixed the charging issues also fixed my speaker. Treat this as a lesson to make sure you're using the latest version of iOS.

Camera and video

Another area that wasn't expected to receive a huge upgrade is the camera. Yes, there's a larger sensor and better software, but the iPhone X was already fantastic. Smart HDR works incredibly well, and photos and video coming out of this thing are so good. Shutter lag is basically nonexistent, with the images more detailed and an impressive dynamic range on show.

There is a little bit of detail loss for selfies in low light, but that shouldn't bug most users. The reason for this has previously been thoroughly explained.

The video stabilization is definitely improved and, as long as you're shooting at 30FPS or below, Smart HDR is also improving the dynamic range. Video is practically even more detailed than before.

If your iPhone is your main camera and you take a lot of photos and video, this feature alone makes it worth selling the iPhone X, which has a very good resale value, and upgrading to the XS Max.

Battery life

The last thing to cover is is battery life, and boy is it impressive. Many phones vendors claim their products have an all-day battery life but this is honestly the first phone that did it for me. In my case, I use the phone constantly, requiring me to plug it in or place it on a wireless charger during the day, or else it will die in the evening.

Moving from the iPhone 8 Plus to the iPhone X, there was a slight drop in battery life, but the XS is rated to last for 30 minutes longer than the iPhone X, with the XS Max rated for 1.5 hours longer. Consumer Reports said the difference was even greater in their testing and my own heavy use backs this up.

The battery differences are really noticeable and that's a big deal if your life or business revolves around your phone.

In summary

After a month of use, I am more impressed with the XS Max then when I first received it. Certainly, the larger screen is nice, but even if you get the smaller XS model, the camera upgrades and battery life improvements are something that you will notice day to day.

With the resale value of the iPhone X being so good, if you can afford the difference, it is highly recommended to upgrade to the iPhone XS or XS Max.

Deals on the iPhone X, XS and XS Max

If you haven't already ordered Apple's iPhone XS or XS Max, wireless carriers are incentivizing the purchase with buy one, get one $700 off promotions and more. Want to get your hands on a new iPhone asap? eBay sellers are also shipping units now.

Carrier deals:

• AT&T Wireless: Buy one iPhone XS or iPhone XS Max, get a second $700 off when you add a line.
  
• Verizon Wireless: Buy an iPhone XS and get a 64GB iPhone XR for free.
  
• Sprint: Get the 64GB iPhone XS for half off with eligible trade-in and Sprint Flex lease.
  
• T-Mobile: Save up to $390 on the iPhone XS with an eligible iPhone trade.

Those interested in saving $100 off the iPhone X's original MSRP can also do so at Verizon Wireless, AT&T Wireless, T-Mobile and Sprint.

appleismymiddlename

Great video! Completely agree on all accounts.

lkrupp

To the author. You can be as ‘disappointed’ as you want to be about scratches but don't try to put it on Apple. Glass is glass is glass. it’s hard, it scratches. So does stainless steel by the way, easily. Meanwhile many of us can regularly go about our business without scratching our iPhone screens and without screen protectors. 

sirlance99

lkrupp said:

To the author. You can be as ‘disappointed’ as you want to be about scratches but don't try to put it on Apple. Glass is glass is glass. it’s hard, it scratches. So does stainless steel by the way, easily. Meanwhile many of us can regularly go about our business without scratching our iPhone screens and without screen protectors. 

And just as many wil have scratches 

seanismorris

lkrupp said:

To the author. You can be as ‘disappointed’ as you want to be about scratches but don't try to put it on Apple. Glass is glass is glass. it’s hard, it scratches. So does stainless steel by the way, easily. Meanwhile many of us can regularly go about our business without scratching our iPhone screens and without screen protectors. 

My main complaint is the glass exists at all.  It’s fragile and expensive to replace.  Wireless charging adds little value to the phone while increasing costs.

I’d buy the model without it, if offered...

Now, if Apple could tell me phones with the glass got better reception, that would be worth something.

chasm

I have to say that if you had scratches after a couple of days, you’re doing something abusive. I’ve had my iPhone 6s in my front pocket every day for the past four years, no screen protector, and no scratch on the glass (and yes, I looked carefully with the screen off to be sure there weren’t just tiny hard-to-see scratches). Don’t keep your phone in your pocket with your keys, or get a screen protector if you have no other option.

MplsP

lkrupp said:

To the author. You can be as ‘disappointed’ as you want to be about scratches but don't try to put it on Apple. Glass is glass is glass. it’s hard, it scratches. So does stainless steel by the way, easily. Meanwhile many of us can regularly go about our business without scratching our iPhone screens and without screen protectors. 

chasm said:

I have to say that if you had scratches after a couple of days, you’re doing something abusive. I’ve had my iPhone 6s in my front pocket every day for the past four years, no screen protector, and no scratch on the glass (and yes, I looked carefully with the screen off to be sure there weren’t just tiny hard-to-see scratches). Don’t keep your phone in your pocket with your keys, or get a screen protector if you have no other option.

Exactly. My experience with my 6s is exactly the same. 3+ years, no screen protector and no scratches. Regardless, people want something that is hard and won't scratch and also won't break, meaning it's not hard and brittle. Two fundamentally competing goals.

 Ultimately, the front glass is what I care about. I don't spend my tme looking at the back of my phone, and I don't carry it as a fashion accessory status symbol, so if it has a few scratches I don't care. If someone else cares, then good for them.

 Re: connectivity speeds - it's impossible to know because of the variables involved but how much of this is simply due to the intel modem having slower speeds than the Qualcomm modems?

WreckSpocka

I always love your videos, there's just one piece of mis-information on this one. I blame Apple for not making this feature more clear:

You do *not* have to reach the top of the phone with your thumb. Enable "Reachability" in Settings/General/Accessibility. It defaults to "Off" for some reason. Once it's on, you swipe down at the bottom of the phone, which lowers the display. Everyone knows this allows you to reach navigation arrows, etc, but what Apple hasn't communicated is that you can swipe down from the top for Notifications, and from the top-right for the control screen. I figured this out on my own, haven't seen anyone comment on it.

The hardest 'reach' for the XS-Max is the lower lefthand corner of the screen.

aegean

One year passed really quickly and I still feel like that I just bought my iPhone X (upgraded from 5). Time flies. And here we have 3 new versions of iPhone X. But I will not be upgrading my phone in the next 5 years, at least as it needs to justify the cost and life of C$2K as a freaking phone. I spend majority of my time on Mac, whether it's MacBook Air or Mac Pro or anything in between. On iPhone, like today, my screen time says I spent 11 min with the phone, last week total was 3h 21m.

JFC_PA

For me the cost difference beywern my previous iPhone X and my current iPhone XS Max? $5 per month. 

And as as I expected the larger screen is totally worth it. 

chiefhowell

To continue, I got a great deal at Best Buy, got $440.00 for my 8+ which made the 256GB Xs very affordable. My experience with the Xs is that it is everything Apple claimed and a keeper. I’m not sure what more Apple can do that will be a measurable improvement over the latest phones. While the A13 may be “faster”, I doubt anyone will notice. Better cameras or more lens? Possible but I doubt the difference will be THAT much better. 5G? Maybe but it will be years before it is widespread to make a difference. In short, it looks like we have hit ‘Nirvana’ with the Xs/Xs Max/Xr.

chiefhowell

Oops looks like my first post didn’t make it. I’ve had the Xs for almost a month and couldn’t be happier. I traded in my 8+ at Best Buy for $440 which made the high price more palatable. The 256GB is the ‘sweet spot’. Took it on a trip to DC for a week and took a boatload of pics! Great camera!!! Battery life was very good but not as good as the 8+. However, going to Low Battery mode made a difference. You can see my other post for further thoughts. The Xs is a keeper!

bestkeptsecret

I know I'm clumsy, which is why every phone I buy has a tempered glass screen and a clear case. It has saved my phone on many occasions.

I've already dropped my XS Max twice due to my butter fingers, but thankfully nothing happened to the phone.

I gave my iPhone X away to a relative after I got the XS Max so I cannot compare them, but I really love the design that they have settled on. Almost all-screen!

madan

Pushing X owners to upgrade to an XS is asinine. If a person spent 1200 dollars on a top of the line X, it makes no sense to push them to sell that phone at barely 50% peanuts the next year, just for the privilege of renting it for one year. Especially when the XS has a: 10% better battery. 10% better screen. 15-20% better camera. Same storage speeds. 15% better CPU. And the vaunted 50% improved CPU will only give you approximately 5-10% more frames on Mobility Fortnite, et al. Telling X owners to eat 400-600 dollars to upgrade to an XS or a Max is just crazy when this phone is obviously targeting 6 owners, and the like. If you've used both for any significant period of time (I have.), you'd be honest to state that 95% of the time, you're never going to notice a difference. Literally, 19/20 times, the phones feel identical. I don't think most people stop and think "Gee, I think upgrading my phone for 600+ dollars on a minute upgrade is so worth it!". It's just silly.

Madtiger

For me, i upgraded to Xs from X due solely to the camera.  I love Smart HDR...killer feature IMHO.  And i did upgrade my storage too (256 to 512)...and that is nice because i now have all my videos of kids etc on my phone.  I prefer local storage (with iTunes/iCloud backup) over Cloud...so, i just have 50 GB iCloud storage for device backups.

And of course, Verizon made it easy for me to upgrade...gave me $700 for my X.