Apple reportedly removes podcast app in China at request of government
Apple on Wednesday removed popular podcasting app Pocket Casts from the Chinese App Store, with developers of the platform claiming the takedown was initiated by the government's cyber watchdog agency.
Pocket Casts, which enjoys a healthy following as a cross-platform podcast discovery and playback platform, announced its removal from the China App Store in a tweet today.
"Pocket Casts has been removed from the Chinese App store by Apple, at the request of the Cyberspace Administration of China," the tweet reads.
In a separate tweet, the company said Apple relayed a message from the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC) earlier this week. Details of the notice were left unreported. The CAC has in the past issued warnings to app makers regarding in-app content it found to be in violation of local and national cyber laws.
Pocket Casts is characterizing the App Store removal as censorship, an oft-repeated refrain from other firms that reached a similar fate.
"We believe podcasting is and should remain an open medium, free of government censorship. As such we won't be censoring podcast content at their request," the company said.
Why Pocket Casts was singled out among the dozens of podcast players available on iOS is unknown.
Apple has not released a statement on the matter.
The tech giant's obsequious relationship with the CAC is often the target of criticism from free speech advocates and human rights groups. While it touts itself as a staunch champion of human rights causes, Apple routinely cows to the Chinese government, a body that controls the keys to a huge, and significantly untapped, consumer market.
In late 2016, Apple removed the official New York Times app from China's App Store after authorities claimed it was in violation of unspecified local laws. About six months later, Apple pulled multiple virtual private network (VPN) apps that threatened to break through China's "Great Firewall."
More recently, Apple yanked Quartz and a police monitoring app from the China App Store during protests in Hong Kong protests late last year. The HKmap.live app was later restored only to again be removed a day later.
Apple CEO Tim Cook addressed the HKmap.live kerfuffle in a letter to employees, saying at the time that the app was in violation of Hong Kong law because it was reportedly being used to maliciously target police officers and victimize individuals in areas where no police were present.
For its part, Apple maintains the app removals are a necessity as the company operates in line with local laws.
Pocket Casts, which enjoys a healthy following as a cross-platform podcast discovery and playback platform, announced its removal from the China App Store in a tweet today.
"Pocket Casts has been removed from the Chinese App store by Apple, at the request of the Cyberspace Administration of China," the tweet reads.
In a separate tweet, the company said Apple relayed a message from the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC) earlier this week. Details of the notice were left unreported. The CAC has in the past issued warnings to app makers regarding in-app content it found to be in violation of local and national cyber laws.
Pocket Casts is characterizing the App Store removal as censorship, an oft-repeated refrain from other firms that reached a similar fate.
"We believe podcasting is and should remain an open medium, free of government censorship. As such we won't be censoring podcast content at their request," the company said.
Why Pocket Casts was singled out among the dozens of podcast players available on iOS is unknown.
Apple has not released a statement on the matter.
The tech giant's obsequious relationship with the CAC is often the target of criticism from free speech advocates and human rights groups. While it touts itself as a staunch champion of human rights causes, Apple routinely cows to the Chinese government, a body that controls the keys to a huge, and significantly untapped, consumer market.
In late 2016, Apple removed the official New York Times app from China's App Store after authorities claimed it was in violation of unspecified local laws. About six months later, Apple pulled multiple virtual private network (VPN) apps that threatened to break through China's "Great Firewall."
More recently, Apple yanked Quartz and a police monitoring app from the China App Store during protests in Hong Kong protests late last year. The HKmap.live app was later restored only to again be removed a day later.
Apple CEO Tim Cook addressed the HKmap.live kerfuffle in a letter to employees, saying at the time that the app was in violation of Hong Kong law because it was reportedly being used to maliciously target police officers and victimize individuals in areas where no police were present.
For its part, Apple maintains the app removals are a necessity as the company operates in line with local laws.
Comments
it's simply a censorship....
Tim Cook has repeatedly made the compelling argument that it’s better to stay engaged and work with entities and people that have differing views than to withdraw in protest and end up with no influence. Sound logic.
However, influence works both ways. One is left to wonder about the power and influence those entities/people have on Apple’s internal decision making process, conscious or otherwise.
Apple is clearly not the company Steve Jobs built anymore. I’m not saying that’s good or bad - just acknowledging an emerging reality. If Apple is to continue with its more outspoken stance on social and political issues in the United States, they should expect to be held accountable and called out when taking a very different approach with authoritarian regimes.
As such, it would be wise for Apple to accelerate its diversification out of China.