Why your Mac might say its battery is 'Not Charging' on macOS Catalina

Posted:
in General Discussion edited August 2020
Apple, in a new support document, explains how a new "Not Charging" battery status is a feature of its macOS Catalina battery management tools.

Credit: Andrew O'Hara, AppleInsider
Credit: Andrew O'Hara, AppleInsider


The new Battery Health Management feature, introduced in macOS 10.15.5, is aimed at prolonging the lifespan of MacBook batteries by monitoring battery temperature and charging patterns.

In a recently published support document, Apple says that the new "Not Charging" battery status indicator is a part of the management suite.

"Depending on its settings, your Mac might temporarily pause charging to help calibrate battery health management, a feature designed to improve the lifespan of your battery," Apple writes.

The company adds that the indicator is normal and part of how the battery health management feature optimizes charging. Though the battery percentage may drop when a Mac has paused charging, it will soon resume powering up to 100% based on a user's charging patterns.

On the other hand, a Mac may sometimes show the "Not Charging" indicator if it is plugged in to a power source that isn't delivering enough power, or if it is plugged in using an incorrect cable or adapter.

The support document, which was first spotted by MacRumors, also refers users to another troubleshooting page if a Mac still won't charge with the proper power source and equipment.

Apple introduced a similar Optimized Battery Charging feature to iPhones and iPads in iOS 13, and to AirPods in iOS 14.

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 14
    rraburrabu Posts: 264member
    They should say “charging paused” instead. “Not charging” sounds more like a problem that needs to be fixed.
    elijahgrazorpittwokatmewroundaboutnowmuthuk_vanalingamPetrolDavedoozydozenseanjflyingdppscooter63
  • Reply 2 of 14
    elijahgelijahg Posts: 2,838member
    rrabu said:
    They should say “charging paused” instead. “Not charging” sounds more like a problem that needs to be fixed.
    Yes especially since it might say "not charging" when there is a problem too. "Calibrating battery" would make sense since "charging paused" may cause users to think it needs to be resumed somehow. 
    Ofermwhiterazorpittwokatmewroundaboutnowdoozydozenflyingdpwatto_cobra
  • Reply 3 of 14
    OferOfer Posts: 266unconfirmed, member
    elijahg said:
    rrabu said:
    They should say “charging paused” instead. “Not charging” sounds more like a problem that needs to be fixed.
    Yes especially since it might say "not charging" when there is a problem too. "Calibrating battery" would make sense since "charging paused" may cause users to think it needs to be resumed somehow. 
    Yup. This is not a good UX design and will cause needless confusion for end-users.
    razorpitelijahgtwokatmewPetrolDavedoozydozenseanj
  • Reply 4 of 14
    razorpitrazorpit Posts: 1,796member
    How about “Battery Maintenance”.  :)
    elijahgtwokatmew
  • Reply 5 of 14
    dewmedewme Posts: 5,702member
    "Battery Health Management" is a bit of a misnomer. The real term for this, and for every Apple product that has a non-user-replaceable battery, and especially those products with lithium-ion batteries, should be "Battery Death Management." There is nothing that you can do to prevent the eventual death of your battery-powered Apple device. It's not a question of whether it will die, but only a question of when it will die, and where you are in the warranty and/or product support lifespan for the product.

    If you're lucky and the battery in your Apple device happens to die while under Apple Care, possibly by bloating up and destroying the device in the process, you are golden. Apple will take care of you. If your Apple device battery dies while the product is still being supported, you may be able to get the device repaired or replaced for the standard battery replacement charge. You're not golden, but maybe bronze. Once your Apple product gets assigned to the end-of-life list you are on your own and Apple will gladly recycle the dead, bloated hulk of your formerly treasured Apple device - at no charge. Woo hoo.

    Not picking on Apple, okay maybe a little, but you really cannot think of any Apple device that has a non-user-replaceable battery as a durable product that you actually own and can pass down to your kids or donate to charity. You are basically renting these products for an indeterminate, but very finite, period of time after which time it will die in one way or another. For the slimmest and glued together recent products the most common cause of Apple Product Death for me has been battery bloat. Products like the last 3 generations of iPod Touches, iPads, and Apple Watch are particularly susceptible to Death By Battery Bloat (DBBB or DB^3). Other products, like Apple AirPods die silently and quietly on a time scale reminiscent of a Mayfly compared to their non battery operated cousins.

    Apple is not alone in perpetuating this very expensive masquerading of quickly decaying products as semi durable goods. They can choke us on new features and dazzle us with design wizardry but they cannot escape the reality that every battery product they sell us is doomed from the day it is born to die in the most inglorious manner long before we are willing to give up on it. Putting some more intelligence in the charging circuitry and software controls is fine, but let's see the a similar level of investment that Apple is putting into "Apple Silicon" into "Apple Portable Energy" to move their products beyond the scourge that is inherent in every battery powered product that Apple currently sells. It really is that big of a deal, and Apple is doing very little, or nothing, to lead us away from a problem that grows exponentially with every new battery powered product they release.

    If Apple has an achilles heel, this is it. They own the products and can no longer pass along blame to the battery manufacturers. Own it Tim.


    edited August 2020 Ofermuthuk_vanalingammike54flyingdppscooter63
  • Reply 6 of 14
    dewme said:
    "Battery Health Management" is a bit of a misnomer. The real term for this, and for every Apple product that has a non-user-replaceable battery, and especially those products with lithium-ion batteries, should be "Battery Death Management." There is nothing that you can do to prevent the eventual death of your battery-powered Apple device. It's not a question of whether it will die, but only a question of when it will die, and where you are in the warranty and/or product support lifespan for the product.

    If you're lucky and the battery in your Apple device happens to die while under Apple Care, possibly by bloating up and destroying the device in the process, you are golden. Apple will take care of you. If your Apple device battery dies while the product is still being supported, you may be able to get the device repaired or replaced for the standard battery replacement charge. You're not golden, but maybe bronze. Once your Apple product gets assigned to the end-of-life list you are on your own and Apple will gladly recycle the dead, bloated hulk of your formerly treasured Apple device - at no charge. Woo hoo.

    Not picking on Apple, okay maybe a little, but you really cannot think of any Apple device that has a non-user-replaceable battery as a durable product that you actually own and can pass down to your kids or donate to charity. You are basically renting these products for an indeterminate, but very finite, period of time after which time it will die in one way or another. For the slimmest and glued together recent products the most common cause of Apple Product Death for me has been battery bloat. Products like the last 3 generations of iPod Touches, iPads, and Apple Watch are particularly susceptible to Death By Battery Bloat (DBBB or DB^3). Other products, like Apple AirPods die silently and quietly on a time scale reminiscent of a Mayfly compared to their non battery operated cousins.

    Apple is not alone in perpetuating this very expensive masquerading of quickly decaying products as semi durable goods. They can choke us on new features and dazzle us with design wizardry but they cannot escape the reality that every battery product they sell us is doomed from the day it is born to die in the most inglorious manner long before we are willing to give up on it. Putting some more intelligence in the charging circuitry and software controls is fine, but let's see the a similar level of investment that Apple is putting into "Apple Silicon" into "Apple Portable Energy" to move their products beyond the scourge that is inherent in every battery powered product that Apple currently sells. It really is that big of a deal, and Apple is doing very little, or nothing, to lead us away from a problem that grows exponentially with every new battery powered product they release.

    If Apple has an achilles heel, this is it. They own the products and can no longer pass along blame to the battery manufacturers. Own it Tim.


    Yeah let's rename every "Health" related products, committee, board, hospitals to "Death" related because they can't prevent the death of humans
    You can change the way the battery is used and the charging habits to extend the battery life...just like use medications/ surgery to extend human life
    No matter what you do you can only extend battery life, just like human life. You can't have them forever...they're not immortal
    roundaboutnowwonkothesaneseanjwatto_cobra
  • Reply 7 of 14

    dewme said:
    You are basically renting these products for an indeterminate, but very finite, period of time after which time it will die in one way or another. 


    Its true for everything that makes a product. Not just battery. You think you can buy something have it last forever??? 
    Technology is growing quicker than ever. Even if you want to own an iPhone for 10yrs, you'll be prompted to upgrade after at least 5yrs because of not just battery, everything inside it will age, begins to show its mortal nature. For the same price you can get much better products with better specs after that many years
    "Nothing is built to last forever"

    edited August 2020 watto_cobra
  • Reply 8 of 14
    I guess the only truly way out in this is a very strict recycle program. With quickly detoriating products (EarPods) and for those that last longer, MacBooks, or even longer lasting stuff without batteries like refrigerators and cars. 
  • Reply 9 of 14
    Rayz2016Rayz2016 Posts: 6,957member
    rrabu said:
    They should say “charging paused” instead. “Not charging” sounds more like a problem that needs to be fixed.
    Yup. 

    The fact that they needed to note it in a support document means they really need to change it. Most Apple users don’t read support documents. 
    PetrolDavewatto_cobra
  • Reply 10 of 14
    wonkothesanewonkothesane Posts: 1,741member
    I wonder if you can override this in case you urgently need to charge NOW, even it might go against the battery health. Same with iOS.
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 11 of 14
    seanjseanj Posts: 322member
    The only battery bloat I’ve seen was with the two phones issued to me by my company for software development purposes. The battery on the Samsung bloated and smashed the casing, while the battery on the Apple had no issues.
    As for the supposed limited lifespan of Apple batteries... the battery on my 2005 Black MacBook is still fine and doing well.
    pscooter63watto_cobra
  • Reply 12 of 14
    seanjseanj Posts: 322member
    The only battery bloat I’ve seen was with the two phones issued to me by my company for software development purposes. The battery on the Samsung bloated and smashed the casing, while the battery on the Apple had no issues.
    As for the supposed limited lifespan of Apple batteries... the battery on my 2006 Black MacBook is still fine and doing well.
  • Reply 13 of 14
    gatorguygatorguy Posts: 24,622member
    seanj said:
    The only battery bloat I’ve seen was with the two phones issued to me by my company for software development purposes. The battery on the Samsung bloated and smashed the casing, while the battery on the Apple had no issues.
    As for the supposed limited lifespan of Apple batteries... the battery on my 2006 Black MacBook is still fine and doing well.
    Whether you've seen it on your own devices or not Apple themselves have acknowledged swollen batteries as a significant enough issue to warrant special warranty consideration on both the first gen Apple Watch and 2016/17 Macbook Pros. There's spotty reports on other Apple devices as well. It can happen despite the best of preventative measures, and sometimes as mentioned above with a whole series of devices.

    Eventually we'll move past fixed rechargeable Li-ion batteries in our electronics but not for a while. This is actually a very good idea by Apple, but not the best user-facing notification of what's happening. I suspect they'll modify the wording. 
  • Reply 14 of 14
    mike1mike1 Posts: 3,433member
    I wonder if you can override this in case you urgently need to charge NOW, even it might go against the battery health. Same with iOS.

    On the iPhone you can. When the phone is charged to 80% and tells you it will resume at some future time, just unplug and plug in the Lightning cable again. It will immediately begin topping off the charge.
    watto_cobrawonkothesane
Sign In or Register to comment.