Foxconn's bid for tax subsidies rejected by Wisconsin officials

Posted:
in General Discussion
Wisconsin state officials have reportedly rejected Foxconn's application for tax subsidies because the company's plans for a factory in the state were smaller than initially proposed.

Credit: Foxconn
Credit: Foxconn


Foxconn, known as one of Apple's key iPhone assembly partners, touted the Wisconsin plant project as one that would eventually employ as many as 13,000 people in the local economy. Since its announcement, the project has been troubled by slow progress and discrepancies in its plans.

On Monday, The Verge reported that the Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation had rejected Foxconn's application for tax subsidies, citing the fact that its plans are "smaller in scale and economic impact" than it originally planned.

Similarly, documents obtained by The Verge also show that the contract electronics maker failed to reach the minimum employment quota necessary to even receive tax subsidies.

The Taiwanese company needed to employ at least 520 people by the end of 2019. Although it said it hired about 550, the WEDC estimates that only about 281 would actually qualify toward the necessary number.

In other words, Foxconn isn't building the 20-million-square-foot LCD "Gen 10.5" factory that it had promised. That the plant wouldn't live up to expectations, in fact, became clear even as President Donald Trump broke ground on the project in June 2018.

Foxconn said in July 2019 that it would open the plant in May 2020 with just 1,500 jobs, about 300 short of the number necessary to secure subsidies. That timeline has since been pushed back to sometime in 2020, though an exact date isn't clear.

In a letter on Monday, WEDC CEO Melissa Hughes suggested that the door was still open for a new deal, stating that she was still committed to "help negotiate fair terms to support Foxconn's new and substantially changed vision for the project."

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 12
    Raise your virtual hand if you thought this deal was anything more than the dog and pony show that it has reveal itself to be.
    [no hands raise]

    Anyone with a modicum intelligence knew this was BS from the moment it was announced.  No one can be surprised we are where we are with this.
    ronnMplsPfred1muthuk_vanalingamtmayricmacgatorguy
  • Reply 2 of 12
    DAalsethDAalseth Posts: 2,783member
    Raise your virtual hand if you thought this deal was anything more than the dog and pony show that it has reveal itself to be.
    [no hands raise]

    Anyone with a modicum intelligence knew this was BS from the moment it was announced.  No one can be surprised we are where we are with this.
    I agree completely. People forgot the old adage “if it seems too good to be true, it probably is.” 
    ronn
  • Reply 3 of 12
    JFC_PAJFC_PA Posts: 932member
    This has happened before. Get the photo op then economic reality  quietly intrudes. 
    jeffharris
  • Reply 4 of 12
    ronnronn Posts: 654member
    It is what it is!  :D
  • Reply 5 of 12
    Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.

    Trouble is, this time Foxconn may be serious, what with Apple wanting to move production out of China, the trade war, and China's pandemic potential - as well as China's growing hostility towards foreigners and their burgeoning military adventurism.

    Right now, China is a good place to move out of.

    Too bad Foxconn poisoned the pond with that last con job meant to keep Apple and the feds placated.

    Foxconn ought to man up and give Wisconsin what they originally promised them - a working manufacturing center employing a bunch of Wisconsin workers.

    It would go a long way towards repairing their reputation.
    edited October 2020
  • Reply 6 of 12
    dewmedewme Posts: 5,372member
    I hope all is not lost. Perhaps WEDC can attract someone like Tesla, GM, Ford, or Apple to set up electric vehicle manufacturing operations in the soon to be abandoned space. Imho this would be a much better fit for WI compared to LCD panels. That part of the Midwest has a lot of component suppliers that serve automotive, machinery, and especially, industrial automation related and dependent industries. Much better fit. 
    edited October 2020
  • Reply 7 of 12
    Is this how we Make America Great Again?

    -__- 
    edited October 2020 fred1AlgerDAalsethricmacronn
  • Reply 8 of 12
    I will point out that when this was first announced a number of people complained that Wisconsin was "paying" Foxconn (in the form of tax relieve) for something that may never come to fruition.  Instead, what happened is what many of expected:  Foxconn didn't hit its targets and Wisconsin didn't give them the conditional tax relief.  In the spirit of the glass being half full, Wisconsin wasn't suckered into paying for nothing.  Sure it's a low bar, but it's better than lots of other failed boondoggle projects.
  • Reply 9 of 12
    Another fail in the swampiest age ever.
  • Reply 10 of 12
    morkymorky Posts: 200member
    I will point out that when this was first announced a number of people complained that Wisconsin was "paying" Foxconn (in the form of tax relieve) for something that may never come to fruition.  Instead, what happened is what many of expected:  Foxconn didn't hit its targets and Wisconsin didn't give them the conditional tax relief.  In the spirit of the glass being half full, Wisconsin wasn't suckered into paying for nothing.  Sure it's a low bar, but it's better than lots of other failed boondoggle projects.
    I think the issue was that even if they provided the 13,000 jobs, $3B was a crazy amount to credit them considering the cost of public infrastructure to support the facility.
    ronn
  • Reply 11 of 12
    xbitxbit Posts: 390member
    Good. Corporate socialism is a race to the bottom that states should avoid.
  • Reply 12 of 12
    gatorguygatorguy Posts: 24,213member
    I will point out that when this was first announced a number of people complained that Wisconsin was "paying" Foxconn (in the form of tax relieve) for something that may never come to fruition.  Instead, what happened is what many of expected:  Foxconn didn't hit its targets and Wisconsin didn't give them the conditional tax relief.  In the spirit of the glass being half full, Wisconsin wasn't suckered into paying for nothing.  Sure it's a low bar, but it's better than lots of other failed boondoggle projects.
    Have you done any reading on what Wisconsin had to do to make the failed project even possible? Wisconsin government was suckered, citizens were suckered, cities were suckered. A lot of money was spent, and labor and equipment resources taken away from other community and public projects around the states and concentrated on this one. You're right, the future tax subsidies won't materialize but it doesn't mean no economic harm was done.
    ronnCloudTalkin
Sign In or Register to comment.