Hands on with Apple's MagSafe charger and silicone cases

Posted:
in iPhone edited October 2020
Apple's MagSafe accessories have started to show up at customers' doorsteps. We take a look at a few first-party cases, as well as Apple's MagSafe charger, to see how they work.


Apple MagSafe accessories


A few readers had questions after AppleInsider posted its in-depth look on MagSafe last week. Here, we have an opportunity to answer those queries with a hands-on of Apple's own accessories.

Apple's MagSafe charger
Apple's MagSafe charger


As Apple just introduced the standard, the iPhone maker is one of the only manufacturers to currently have MagSafe products on the market. OtterBox has released a few cases, but it won't be long before countless others flood the market.





Ahead of the full launch of iPhone 12 -- including November's iPhone 12 mini and iPhone 12 Pro Max debuts -- we got our hands on Apple's MagSafe charger and several MagSafe-compatible silicone cases. Apple is still readying a leather sleeve, leather cases, and wallets. The wallets, big enough to house credit cards, are on sale now though they don't ship until November or December.

MagSafe charger

MagSafe for iPhone is what one would expect from a magnetic wireless charger. At first blush it looks like a scaled up version of the Apple Watch charging puck, at least the stainless steel version that comes with the higher-end models. The back of the charger sports a nice matte finish that resists fingerprints. Instead of hard plastic, the white center portion -- the part that touches your phone -- is soft and feels very similar to Apple's silicone cases.

Apple MagSafe charger
Apple MagSafe charger


A roughly three-foot USB-C cable is permanently affixed to the charging puck and should anything go bad with the cable the whole thing is bound for a landfill. If you didn't assume by the slim packaging, no power adapter is included.

Apple MagSafe Charger versus Apple Watch charging puck
Apple MagSafe Charger versus Apple Watch charging puck


Apple says you need at least a 20W USB-C power brick for its MagSafe charger if you want the maximum 15W of wireless power. Apple does offer its own, but we prefer a few third-party choices like the Anker PowerPort Nano III.

Charging iPhone 11 Pro with MagSafe charger
Charging iPhone 11 Pro with MagSafe charger


MagSafe is compatible with the Qi standard, which means that the iPhone 12 be juiced up by Qi chargers, while the MagSafe puck can charge Qi-enabled devices. We tested this ourselves with our AirPods Pro and our iPhone 11 Pro Max -- both of which worked without issue. It even charged our Samsung devices we had in the studio.

Charging AirPods Pro with MagSafe charger
Charging AirPods Pro with MagSafe charger


When connected to a Qi phone like our iPhone 11 Pro Max, there is a slight magnetic attraction which does a decent job of keeping the puck in place. It helps align our phone better than normal Qi wireless chargers. We can even sit and use our iPhone while it charges and the puck doesn't come free. That said, it isn't a very strong attraction and easily falls off with quick motions. It wasn't designed to be useful for these phones, but rather the iPhone 12. This is just a nice benefit.

Unfortunately, it does not charge our Apple Watch. Apple Watch still uses a proprietary charging method that is based around Qi, but is not compatible.

Apple silicone MagSafe-enabled cases

The second MagSafe accessory Apple released is an upgraded version of its silicone cases. They have the same feel as before, and the same physical makeup, just a new shape. Unlike OtterBox, which simply glued a MagSafe-compatible insert into their cases and called it a day, Apple sandwiches the magnets in between the case's back panel and microfiber lining.

To designate the MagSafe location, the inside of the case has a plastic indicator that looks like a sticker. Do not try to peel it off...

Inside of Apple's silicone cases
The inside of Apple's silicone cases


Aside from the ring in the center, there is an additional magnet array at in the six o'clock position which is used for alignment. The MagSafe charger doesn't utilize this piece, but it is necessary for accessories like wallets that need to be correctly orientated on the handset to function.

Since we don't have our iPhone 12 yet, we can't test charging the phone. We can, however, test connecting the MagSafe puck to our case. One of the most-asked questions was regarding the strength of MagSafe's magnets. At least to the case, the attraction is substantial but not overpowering.

When you lift your phone off the table, the charger will for sure be taken along. This can be good if you want to charge while holding your phone, but bad if you always want to disconnect as it requires two hands. Of course, there will soon be a slew of MagSafe chargers like stands, docks and other stationary designs.

We put a dummy iPhone 12 into the case and were able to let it dangle without either the phone or case coming free. A vigorous shake did break the bond. Based on early looks, it seems that there will be a slightly stronger connection when a real iPhone 12 is present.

Plum, Pink Citrus, Kumquat, and Product(RED) cases
Apple's Plum, Pink Citrus, Kumquat, and Product(RED) silicone cases


Another question we heard was whether or not the puck had to be facing any certain way. The puck can, in fact, rotate but not too easily. It doesn't have a fixed orientation, but the silicone-on-silicone creates enough grip to prevent free rotation. This is great because you can have the cable positioned at any angle.

These accessories are a great first start and we will continue to test them and some other early third-party accessories in the coming days, especially when we get our hands on the new iPhone 12.

There's been some discussion as to whether or not MagSafe will be iPhone 12's killer feature, and regardless of where you stand on the matter, chances are you will eventually have some form of MagSafe accessory. From our first look, that's not a bad thing.

Where to buy MagSafe accessories

A variety of MagSafe accessories can be ordered now from popular retailers like B&H and Amazon.

OtterBox is also shipping its own line of MagSafe cases, with promo code OTTER10 knocking 10% off the new accessories.

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 13
    JapheyJaphey Posts: 1,772member
    As you said, it’s a great first start. Personally, I was hoping the side of the MagSafe would have a bit of a ridge or lip in order to more securely hold it in place when removing the iPhone from a dock or stand that third party manufactures will inevitably flood the market with. Also, that Plum case looks way better in the video than it does on Apple’s website and makes my decision about which color to get a little harder. 
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 2 of 13
    technotechno Posts: 737member
    My question is how long will the cord connection to the charger last? You could see in the video that he was pulling on the cord to manipulate it. With a magnetic connection, it will require you to pull on that cord ever time. Eventually the wires inside will fray. 

    My first modification on mine is going to be: Find a permanent location and glue or stick it down on a surface so that all I have to do is lift the phone. Perhaps I will buy a couple to place around the house. I can't wait for the 3rd party car holder options to come. 
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 3 of 13
    GeorgeBMacGeorgeBMac Posts: 11,421member
    techno said:
    My question is how long will the cord connection to the charger last? You could see in the video that he was pulling on the cord to manipulate it. With a magnetic connection, it will require you to pull on that cord ever time. Eventually the wires inside will fray. 

    My first modification on mine is going to be: Find a permanent location and glue or stick it down on a surface so that all I have to do is lift the phone. Perhaps I will buy a couple to place around the house. I can't wait for the 3rd party car holder options to come. 

    I'm wondering if you might be more happy with one of the Belkin cases that work as stands and might be heavier?
    That said, I don't find it burdonsome on my Apple Watch.   But that may not be comparable.
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 4 of 13
    GeorgeBMacGeorgeBMac Posts: 11,421member
    Thanks Andrew!   As usual, that was an outstanding, clear and complete video review.   Apple's silicon cases have always been great.   My only qualm has been how well they protect.   But that was answered last week when my grandson dropped his mom's iPhone 7 from a counter to a ceramic floor and the phone came out of it just fine!

    Hopefully though you can do another on the Apple Wallet.   I am mostly wondering how well it sticks (I saw one review (I think from Todd Hazelton, but I forget) that said it didn't stick well when the phone was in a pocket.   And too, how securely does it hold a credit card?  And finally, can you use it to hold a card plus some paper cash or other stuff.   And, finally, finally, how well does it work along with a Magsafe case?

    Neither I nor more my grandson carry wallets,   Instead we carry all of our stuff in a wallet case for the iPhone -- specifically this no-name one from EBay because its one of the few that don't cover the screen.   Obviously it can hold far more that the little Apple Wallet, but it does add more bulk.

  • Reply 5 of 13
    JapheyJaphey Posts: 1,772member
    techno said:
    My question is how long will the cord connection to the charger last? You could see in the video that he was pulling on the cord to manipulate it. With a magnetic connection, it will require you to pull on that cord ever time. Eventually the wires inside will fray. 

    My first modification on mine is going to be: Find a permanent location and glue or stick it down on a surface so that all I have to do is lift the phone. Perhaps I will buy a couple to place around the house. I can't wait for the 3rd party car holder options to come. 
    Yes, that’s exactly what I mean. Though you probably explained it better than I did. I want something to anchor the charger either horizontally or upright so that I can grab the phone one-handed and go. 
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 6 of 13
    StrangeDaysStrangeDays Posts: 13,058member
    Unfortunately, it does not charge our Apple Watch. Apple Watch still uses a proprietary charging method that is based around Qi, but is not compatible.
    This is a shame. On puck to rule them all would be way better. Future versions I guess.
  • Reply 7 of 13
    “And should anything go bad with the cable the whole thing is bound for a landfill.”

    Apple requires you to buy a USB-C 20w charger to make it work.

    How is Apple saving the environment?

    So let’s see here.  Apple’s idea of wireless charging is a magnetic device stuck to the phone, even when you pick it up, cord and all.  3 feet is pretty darn short to reach an outlet, because it requires the 20w adapter.  If you have to buy the adapter and the magnet puck is stuck to the phone, just buy a USB-C cable and plug it into the 20w adapter that Apple requires you to buy so you can save money and charge at 20w, even with older phones using the correct cable.  This MagSafe device just proves that Apple is not saving the environment by making people buy them and throw away MagSafe chargers when the cables go bad.  As people will pull the puck from the cable. 

    Oh, watch reviews on the leather wallet.  It is so weak it falls off just by putting it in a pocket.  The one thing you never want to lose, your wallet, and Apple’s MagSafe wallet will do just that.  People watched YouTube reviews and saw how bad it was and immediately canceled their orders.  
    GeorgeBMac
  • Reply 8 of 13
    “And should anything go bad with the cable the whole thing is bound for a landfill.”

    Apple requires you to buy a USB-C 20w charger to make it work.

    How is Apple saving the environment?

    So let’s see here.  Apple’s idea of wireless charging is a magnetic device stuck to the phone, even when you pick it up, cord and all.  3 feet is pretty darn short to reach an outlet, because it requires the 20w adapter.  If you have to buy the adapter and the magnet puck is stuck to the phone, just buy a USB-C cable and plug it into the 20w adapter that Apple requires you to buy so you can save money and charge at 20w, even with older phones using the correct cable.  This MagSafe device just proves that Apple is not saving the environment by making people buy them and throw away MagSafe chargers when the cables go bad.  As people will pull the puck from the cable. 

    Oh, watch reviews on the leather wallet.  It is so weak it falls off just by putting it in a pocket.  The one thing you never want to lose, your wallet, and Apple’s MagSafe wallet will do just that.  People watched YouTube reviews and saw how bad it was and immediately canceled their orders.  
    I missed the part were Apple required people to get the USB C 20W adapter or the MagSafe charger. 

    You can get ANY usb c adapter of your liking or any brand or use a port on your computer etc...

    if you dislike the MagSafe charger don’t buy it then. You can still use the lighting cable. 

    BTW I do have my phone and charger already. if you grab your phone with one hand and slide the charger it will come off WHY people assume that you have to pull the cable or it will be a 2-hand task is beyond nonsense. That’s the reason is not super strong so you don’t have to fight to remove it.

    Super strong MagSafe will make sense in a car mount but horrible for a charging cable. Just wait for what 3rd parties comes up with stronger mounting options. 

    Regarding the wallet and YouTubers: remember “Apple is doomed get them more views”  ANY magnetic wallet or device will separate if one of the sides get purposely stuck on the pocket. The wallet isn’t for everyone. People will want to squeeze 10 cards in there and then complain it failed because they couldn’t get the 10 cards in.
  • Reply 9 of 13
    GeorgeBMacGeorgeBMac Posts: 11,421member
    Apple_Bar said:
    “And should anything go bad with the cable the whole thing is bound for a landfill.”

    Apple requires you to buy a USB-C 20w charger to make it work.

    How is Apple saving the environment?

    So let’s see here.  Apple’s idea of wireless charging is a magnetic device stuck to the phone, even when you pick it up, cord and all.  3 feet is pretty darn short to reach an outlet, because it requires the 20w adapter.  If you have to buy the adapter and the magnet puck is stuck to the phone, just buy a USB-C cable and plug it into the 20w adapter that Apple requires you to buy so you can save money and charge at 20w, even with older phones using the correct cable.  This MagSafe device just proves that Apple is not saving the environment by making people buy them and throw away MagSafe chargers when the cables go bad.  As people will pull the puck from the cable. 

    Oh, watch reviews on the leather wallet.  It is so weak it falls off just by putting it in a pocket.  The one thing you never want to lose, your wallet, and Apple’s MagSafe wallet will do just that.  People watched YouTube reviews and saw how bad it was and immediately canceled their orders.  
    I missed the part were Apple required people to get the USB C 20W adapter or the MagSafe charger. 

    You can get ANY usb c adapter of your liking or any brand or use a port on your computer etc...

    if you dislike the MagSafe charger don’t buy it then. You can still use the lighting cable. 

    BTW I do have my phone and charger already. if you grab your phone with one hand and slide the charger it will come off WHY people assume that you have to pull the cable or it will be a 2-hand task is beyond nonsense. That’s the reason is not super strong so you don’t have to fight to remove it.

    Super strong MagSafe will make sense in a car mount but horrible for a charging cable. Just wait for what 3rd parties comes up with stronger mounting options. 

    Regarding the wallet and YouTubers: remember “Apple is doomed get them more views”  ANY magnetic wallet or device will separate if one of the sides get purposely stuck on the pocket. The wallet isn’t for everyone. People will want to squeeze 10 cards in there and then complain it failed because they couldn’t get the 10 cards in.

    Force?  No, they just pushed them into it.

    If you buy a 5W charger then you also have to buy a USB-A cord to go with it because Apple supplied a USB-C cord.   So, to use the cord you just bought with you new phone, you have to buy the 20Watt charger.

    In truth, Apple should have been shipping a 20Watt charger and USB-C for several years now.  

    For the wallet, if people start losing credit cards and $50 wallets because it doesn't stick properly, excuses and gaslighting won't make them feel better.
  • Reply 10 of 13


    Apple_Bar said:
    “And should anything go bad with the cable the whole thing is bound for a landfill.”

    Apple requires you to buy a USB-C 20w charger to make it work.

    How is Apple saving the environment?

    So let’s see here.  Apple’s idea of wireless charging is a magnetic device stuck to the phone, even when you pick it up, cord and all.  3 feet is pretty darn short to reach an outlet, because it requires the 20w adapter.  If you have to buy the adapter and the magnet puck is stuck to the phone, just buy a USB-C cable and plug it into the 20w adapter that Apple requires you to buy so you can save money and charge at 20w, even with older phones using the correct cable.  This MagSafe device just proves that Apple is not saving the environment by making people buy them and throw away MagSafe chargers when the cables go bad.  As people will pull the puck from the cable. 

    Oh, watch reviews on the leather wallet.  It is so weak it falls off just by putting it in a pocket.  The one thing you never want to lose, your wallet, and Apple’s MagSafe wallet will do just that.  People watched YouTube reviews and saw how bad it was and immediately canceled their orders.  
    I missed the part were Apple required people to get the USB C 20W adapter or the MagSafe charger. 

    You can get ANY usb c adapter of your liking or any brand or use a port on your computer etc...

    if you dislike the MagSafe charger don’t buy it then. You can still use the lighting cable. 

    BTW I do have my phone and charger already. if you grab your phone with one hand and slide the charger it will come off WHY people assume that you have to pull the cable or it will be a 2-hand task is beyond nonsense. That’s the reason is not super strong so you don’t have to fight to remove it.

    Super strong MagSafe will make sense in a car mount but horrible for a charging cable. Just wait for what 3rd parties comes up with stronger mounting options. 

    Regarding the wallet and YouTubers: remember “Apple is doomed get them more views”  ANY magnetic wallet or device will separate if one of the sides get purposely stuck on the pocket. The wallet isn’t for everyone. People will want to squeeze 10 cards in there and then complain it failed because they couldn’t get the 10 cards in.

    Force?  No, they just pushed them into it.

    If you buy a 5W charger then you also have to buy a USB-A cord to go with it because Apple supplied a USB-C cord.   So, to use the cord you just bought with you new phone, you have to buy the 20Watt charger.

    In truth, Apple should have been shipping a 20Watt charger and USB-C for several years now.  

    For the wallet, if people start losing credit cards and $50 wallets because it doesn't stick properly, excuses and gaslighting won't make them feel better.
    Then, why buy a 5W adapter USB A? there’s a plethora of usb c chargers that aren’t the Apple branded 20W. 

    They come in 18W 20W or even the new Anker Atom 30W.

    The people losing the wallets will be the same ones that use the AirPods for intense workouts and then complain “my AirPods fell to the ground”.

    Supplying the USB A cable would have avoid the winning and bad press but USB C is where everything is going. Apple always takes this controversial decisions and take the heat but then everybody follows. 

    If Apple didn’t have their environmental stance. They could have easily include everything inside the box raise the price of each iPhone 100 more and blame it on 5G components and no one would have said anything (or at least just the usual crying about Apple greedy greedy). 


  • Reply 11 of 13
    Oh, watch reviews on the leather wallet.  It is so weak it falls off just by putting it in a pocket.  The one thing you never want to lose, your wallet, and Apple’s MagSafe wallet will do just that.  People watched YouTube reviews and saw how bad it was and immediately canceled their orders.  
    Really?  You know these people and they told you so?

    The phone is released/delivered today (Friday).  How were the videos made with undelivered iPhones? 
  • Reply 12 of 13
    gatorguygatorguy Posts: 24,605member

    Apple's new MagSafe Charger is SLOWER than you Expect..


    Warrants further testing IMO


  • Reply 13 of 13
    eriamjheriamjh Posts: 1,733member
    iPhone 11 cases with magnets would allow MagSafe pucks to work with the 11s just like the 12s.
Sign In or Register to comment.