Vocal App Store critic discontinuing iPhone keyboard app, citing rejections

AppleInsiderAppleInsider
Posted:
in iOS
Apple Watch keyboard app FlickType is discontinuing its iPhone keyboard feature, citing years of facing "obstacle after obstacle" from Apple's App Store review process.

Credit: Apple
Credit: Apple


FlickType founder Kosta Eleftheriou, who has been a vocal critic of scam apps on the App Store, wrote on Monday that the app's team can no longer "endure [Apple's] abuse." As such, FlickType is abandoning the iPhone portion of their app, which is specifically made for blind and low-vision users.

Eleftheriou said that the team submitted a small bug fix and under-the-hood improvement update earlier in August. Apple subsequently rejected the update, citing the fact that the keyboard app needed full access to work properly.

The FlickType team said that this characterization is false. Eleftheriou, for example, noted that FlickType was previously rejected for the same reason, but was eventually allowed onto the App Store after a successful appeal. This time is different, Eleftheriou said.

We tried reaching out to Apple a total of 9 times last week, with no success. At this point they seem to be ignoring our attempts to contact them directly, despite previously explicitly telling us to "feel free" to contact them if we need "further clarification".

-- FlickType Watch Keyboard (@FlickType)


The FlickType founder says that the app's rejection history spans more than 40 pages of "repeated, unwarranted, & unreasonable rejections." Eleftheriou also said that dealing with app review rejections is both time-consuming and emotionally draining. He also alleges that Apple's keyboard APIs and developer tools are buggy and inconsistent.

Eleftheriou said the team feels a "sense of duty to the accessibility community," and tried to keep the iPhone keyboard extension as a TestFlight beta. Apple also rejected that, he said.

He added that he hopes the team can bring FlickType back to the iPhone as an actual keyboard app "hopefully outside of the App Store." Eleftheriou seems to be hoping for change, should pending legislation that could bar Apple from prohibiting third-party app stores on iOS be enacted into law.

Eleftheriou has been a vocal critic of the Apple App Store for some time, saying that the marketplace enables scam and copycat apps. The developer sued Apple in March for fraud, abuse of monopoly power, and the scam app problem.


Read on AppleInsider

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 9
    jeff fieldsjeff fields Posts: 161member
    So he's suing Apple for fraud, trying to actively undermine the App Store and Apple's business model and security model, yet he's expecting white-glove support? Got it. Seems legit. ;)
    jahbladewatto_cobra
  • Reply 2 of 9
    mark fearingmark fearing Posts: 437member
    And it’s awesome he has plenty of other platforms to make this for. That’s his right. He’s a private company, basically, and controls his business decisions. But he wants the Govt to control Apples…got it.
    jahbladebaconstangJapheywatto_cobra
  • Reply 3 of 9
    ArchStantonArchStanton Posts: 200member
     I'd listen if he is saying they are getting the rules applied to them differently than others. Unfortunately he didn't say that, he just said he didn't like the,. Worse, he then goes into the "hopefully outside the App Store" and that the App Store is full of copyright infringement and "scams". What a disingenuous POS who is just looking for the free Apple clickbait ride.  A loathsome POS. The App Store is factually (quantifiable) the least scam and copyright infringement. Nothing will be perfect but the App Store is closer than others. And an App Store Copy outside of Apple's requirements are all but certain to be far more scam laden and copyright infringement laden. But hey, you can do what you want there so lets get users into increased scam and infringement.  Just a total used car salesman POS unworthy of even getting media time (which too often means he will get it). 
    jahbladewatto_cobra
  • Reply 4 of 9
    mcdavemcdave Posts: 1,927member
    This guy was losing it anyway, lashing out at everything.
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 5 of 9
    applguyapplguy Posts: 235member
    I can’t imagine how many knock-off apps will appear almost overnight in a side load App Store including this keyboard. Be careful what you wish for. 
    igorskywatto_cobra
  • Reply 6 of 9
    crowleycrowley Posts: 10,453member
    ArchStanton said:
     I'd listen if ...
    You're not the audience.  Other developers are the audience.  And a growing number of them are saying the same thing, that Apple has significant problems here.  If they're going to argue the virtues of the App Store model to fend off any regulation then they need to sort these problems out.
    ArianneFeldry
  • Reply 7 of 9
    foregoneconclusionforegoneconclusion Posts: 2,813member
    And it’s awesome he has plenty of other platforms to make this for. That’s his right. He’s a private company, basically, and controls his business decisions. But he wants the Govt to control Apples…got it.
    Legislators appear to be the Plan B after courts reject the monopoly claims. BlueMail had no success claiming monopoly control in court. Epic doesn't have a better court case than BlueMail. And neither does this developer.
    edited August 2021 igorskywatto_cobra
  • Reply 8 of 9
    igorskyigorsky Posts: 774member
    crowley said:
     I'd listen if ...
    You're not the audience.  Other developers are the audience.  And a growing number of them are saying the same thing, that Apple has significant problems here.  If they're going to argue the virtues of the App Store model to fend off any regulation then they need to sort these problems out.
    I'm not really sure what "a growing number" of complaining developers really means.  It's like the AppleInsider article that stated a growing number of Apple employees were complaining about their work from home policy and signed a letter... and the number turned out to be 10.  Let's get some much-needed perspective on this.
    edited August 2021 watto_cobra
  • Reply 9 of 9
    crowleycrowley Posts: 10,453member
    igorsky said:
    crowley said:
     I'd listen if ...
    You're not the audience.  Other developers are the audience.  And a growing number of them are saying the same thing, that Apple has significant problems here.  If they're going to argue the virtues of the App Store model to fend off any regulation then they need to sort these problems out.
    I'm not really sure what "a growing number" of complaining developers really means.  It's like the AppleInsider article that stated a growing number of Apple employees were complaining about their work from home policy and signed a letter... and the number turned out to be 10.  Let's get some much-needed perspective on this.
    It almost doesn't matter how many there are, providing they're vocal and visible enough to weird influence and get the attention of regulators.  The App Fairness Coalition has 56 members (I think a couple aren't developers, but cba to count), but with big names and bigger mouths, and they're getting traction.

    Even developers who are long standing Apple cheerleaders are being outspoken about the App Store processes and how problematic they can be.


Sign In or Register to comment.