Compared: Pixel Buds Pro versus AirPods 3 & AirPods Pro

Posted:
in General Discussion edited May 16
Google is now gunning for the AirPods Pro by adding active noise cancelation to the Pixel Buds Pro. Here's how the search company's audio accessories fare compared to Apple's current-gen AirPods lineup.

Google's Pixel Buds Pro flanked by the AirPods and AirPods Pro
Google's Pixel Buds Pro flanked by the AirPods and AirPods Pro


During its Google I/O developer event, the search giant introduced an update in its Pixel Buds lineup. The Pixel Buds Pro are Google's attempt to take on Apple's AirPods Pro, complete with active noise cancelation, aimed at a primarily Android-based audience.

The latest release also boasts considerable battery life and several other tricks that could make them a compelling option for Android smartphone users.

Here's where they stand against Apple's third-gen AirPods and the AirPods Pro.

Specifications

 AirPods (Gen 3)AirPods ProGoogle Pixel Buds Pro
Price$179$249$199
Dimensions (inches)1.21 x 0.75 x 0.761.22 x 0.86 x 0.940.87 x 0.88 x 0.81
Weight (ounces)0.150.190.22
Case Dimensions (inches)1.83 x 2.14 x 0.841.78 x 2.39 x 0.852.49 x 1.97 x 0.98
Case Weight (ounces)1.341.612.2
Battery Life (earbuds)6 hours4.5 hours with ANC,
5 hours without ANC
7 hours with ANC,
11 hours without ANC
Battery Life (with case)Up to 30 hoursMore than 24 hoursUp to 31 hours
ConnectivityBluetooth 5.0Bluetooth 5.0Bluetooth 5.0
MicrophonesDual beamforming microphones,
Inward-facing microphone
Dual beamforming microphones,
Inward-facing microphone
Three microphones,
Voice accelerometer,
Wind-blocking mesh covers
SensorsSkin-detect sensor,
motion-detecting accelerometer,
speech-detecting accelerometer,
Force sensor
Dual optical sensors,
motion-detecting accelerometer,
speech-detecting accelerometer,
Force sensor
Capacitive touch,
IR proximity,
Motion-detecting accelerometer,
Gyroscope
Sweat and Water ResistanceIPX4IPX4IPX4
Active Noise CancellationNoYesYes
Spatial AudioYesYesComing soon in Android 13

Google Pixel Buds Pro vs AirPods 3 and AirPods Pro: Design and Dimensions

The AirPods and AirPods Pro have very well-known forms: a white earbud with dark venting and a long descender that drops down from the ear. The aesthetic is famous and unmistakable and is undoubtedly a wearable status symbol for some users.

While AirPods are designed to sit in the ear cavity, the AirPods Pro includes silicone tips in its design. The latter is helpful for not only keeping the AirPods Pro in place during workouts but also helps facilitate the ANC functionality.



Google's Pixel Buds Pro are not that much different from the Pixel Buds A-Series from 2021, which consists of a cylinder bearing the Google logo and a sticking-out element with a silicone tip to slide into the ear canal. There are no extra sticking out elements, with the entire unit jutting out from the folds of the ear itself.

The Google Pixel Buds Pro are cylindrical with only the earpiece sticking out from its core shape.
The Google Pixel Buds Pro are cylindrical with only the earpiece sticking out from its core shape.


Those ear tips are said to mold to the user's ear for a comfortable fit. To help reduce pressure, sensors can actively measure the levels in the ear canal, relieving it if necessary.

Apple's AirPods 3 measure 1.21 inches long by 0.76 inches by 0.75 inches. The AirPods Pro are a little bit bigger, at 1.22 inches by 0.86 inches by 0.94 inches.

The chunky design does mean Google's Pixel Buds Pro are a fair bit smaller than both of Apple's earphones. At 0.87 inches by 0.88 inches by 0.81, the round element takes up very little space overall.

Despite being smaller, the Pixel Buds Pro are heavier at 0.2 ounces against 0.19 ounces for the AirPods Pro and 0.15 ounces for the AirPods.

All three earbuds are said to include IPX4 sweat and water resistance, enabling them to easily handle the occasional workout routine or light rain.

Of the two product families, Google's is the most colorful. Apple offers the default white as its only option, while Google provides Coral, Fog, Charcoal, and Lemongrass highlights to otherwise black earbuds.

Google Pixel Buds Pro vs AirPods 3 and AirPods Pro: Features

Powered by Apple's H1 chip, the AirPods offer features such as Spatial Audio with dynamic head tracking, an adaptive EQ, automatic switching between devices, and the usual "Hello Siri."

The AirPods Pro go further, adding Active Noise Cancellation as a feature to help block out the environment. To go with this, the Transparency mode can let in some sounds to the user's ear, giving them some awareness of their surroundings or holding a conversation while still blocking out other audio.



The design of the AirPods Pro also includes a vent system to keep the pressure in the ear canal even, rather than adding pressure via the presence of a silicone tip.

Both are controlled via the descending tails, with a series of taps and holds able to instruct the AirPods or AirPods Pro to answer calls, manage music playback, activate Siri, or enable ANC or Transparency modes.

All the audio is provided via a custom high-excursion driver and high dynamic range amplifier, all designed by Apple. Skin detection sensors in the AirPods and optical sensors in the AirPods Pro enable music to play and pause when placed in the ear or removed.

Recordings are handled by dual beam-forming microphones, including an inward-facing microphone to help with summoning Siri.

Google uses custom speakers with 11mm drivers in its Pixel Buds Pro.
Google uses custom speakers with 11mm drivers in its Pixel Buds Pro.


New to the Pixel Buds Pro for 2022 is its own ANC feature, using "Silent Seal" to maximize the blocking out of external noise. Naturally, there's a Transparency mode for environmental awareness.

With Android 13, Google's also introducing its take on Spatial Audio, though that's not available until Android 13.

This is a system brought into play by a custom processor and custom algorithms and speakers, with the latter using 11mm speaker drivers. A full five-band EQ is available for high levels of customization, though there's also a Volume EQ to adjust the tuning as the user changes the required volume.

Each earbud includes a trio of microphones, along with a voice accelerometer that's analogous to Apple's speech-detecting accelerometer. The mics use beamforming and wind-blocking mesh covers to pick up the user's voice clearly, which can be used for calls and hands-free Google Assistant queries.

The buds can be tapped and swiped for calls, music, and assistant control, with there also an IR proximity sensor for ear detection. Accelerometers and a gyroscope are also built into each earbud.

Google Pixel Buds Pro vs AirPods 3 and AirPods Pro: Cases

All three include a charging case, which can recharge the earphones while storing them. The case can help top up the battery life of the accessories and extend their utility throughout the day.

Apple's cases are certainly more oblong than Google's version, which is more oval and egg-like. For all cases, flipping open the top reveals the earbuds and bud-specific holsters for recharging.

The AirPods have a case measuring 1.83 inches by 2.14 inches and 0.84 inches thick. The AirPods Pro use a case measuring 1.78 inches by 2.39 inches and a similar 0.85 inches thick.

Google's case is much larger in comparison, at 1.97 inches by 2.49 inches, and thicker at 0.98 inches.

The Google Pixel Buds Pro case isn't as boxy as those used by AirPods, but it is just as white.
The Google Pixel Buds Pro case isn't as boxy as those used by AirPods, but it is just as white.


Google also offers the heaviest case of the group, at 2.2 ounces versus 1.61 for the AirPods Pro and 1.34 ounces for the third-gen AirPods case.

All of the cases have wireless charging support, with Apple's using MagSafe while Google opts for Qi-compatible chargers. Apple's cases use a Lightning port for wired charging, whereas Google opts for USB-C.

Externally, all three cases are the same shiny white. Opening them up, Apple keeps the interior of the case white, while Google goes for a dark grey.

Google Pixel Buds Pro vs AirPods 3 and AirPods Pro: Battery

Battery life is an area Google has undoubtedly improved in its Pixel Buds Pro and does so at such a level that it could put Apple to shame.

Apple claims the third-gen AirPods can manage up to 6 hours of power from a single charge. The AirPods Pro can manage up to 5 hours with ANC turned off but a respectable 4.5 hours with ANC enabled.

The Google Pixel Buds Pro offers up to 7 hours of listening time with ANC enabled. Without ANC, that time rises to a massive 11 hours from a single charge.

With the recharging cases included, the AirPods can last for up to 30 hours of usage, while Apple says the AirPods Pro can go to "more than" 24 hours. Google claims its earphones can manage up to 31 hours of playback in optimal conditions.

Google Pixel Buds Pro vs AirPods 3 and AirPods Pro: Connectivity

As part of the update, Google's also introducing multi-point connectivity, so the Pixel Buds Pro can automatically switch between devices, including iOS and Android hardware. This is a feature Apple has offered for quite some time, so Android users are certainly catching up on this front.

There's sweat and water resistance to IPX4 across the board.
There's sweat and water resistance to IPX4 across the board.


In terms of actual connectivity, all three earbuds use Bluetooth 5.0 to connect to devices.

Google says the Pixel Buds Pro can connect to any device using Bluetooth 4.0 or later, including iOS devices, Android hardware, tablets, and notebooks.

Apple's compatibility lists cover a considerable history of hardware, so practically anything made since 2012 will almost certainly work with the AirPods and AirPods Pro, so long as users keep their devices up to date.

You can connect AirPods to other Bluetooth devices, including Android smartphones, but you won't necessarily get the same level of integration as you would do connecting it to an Android device. Similarly, you will anticipate deep integration with Android for the Pixel Buds Pro but more basic functionality when used on iOS.

Google Pixel Buds Pro vs AirPods 3 and AirPods Pro: Pricing

Apple sells the third-gen AirPods for $179 (check AirPods 3 prices). Engraving of the case is available at no extra charge.

The AirPods Pro are priced at $249 (shop lowest AirPods Pro prices). Likewise, the case can be engraved at the time of purchase.

In its four color options, the Google Pixel Buds Pro will cost $199 when it becomes available to preorder on July 21.

Pro, for Android

Google's advancements with its Pixel Buds line have brought it to an obvious result: competing with the AirPods Pro. Google's not hiding that fact at all, with the feature set and even the "Pro" suffix closely aligning with Apple's premium personal audio option.

You certainly can't fault Google for trying, as it's attempting to provide Android users something as similarly-featured and valuable as the AirPods Pro.

One thing that Google certainly offers users is a choice of color.
One thing that Google certainly offers users is a choice of color.


In many ways, Google meets Apple's rival version in features, and in the case of battery life, surpasses the incumbent top-of-the-range model.

Add in that the $199 price tag for the Pixel Buds Pro is closer to the cost of AirPods than the AirPods Pro, and it seems like Google is onto a winner here.

There are some downsides to the PixelBuds Pro, such as how they don't have the prestige of the AirPods Pro, the distinctive design, and how they don't have the same level of integration in iOS. Still, Google's earphones do have a place on the market, namely keeping Android users happy.

Are Google's Pixel Buds Pro primed to overtake the AirPods Pro in the marketplace? Probably not for iPhone users, but for the Android faithful, Google has seemingly accomplished its mission.

Where to buy

Google will open preorders of the Pixel Buds Pro from July 21 for $199 via its online store. A release date hasn't yet been confirmed at the time of publication.

AirPods are regularly on sale, with the cheapest prices at your fingertips in our AirPods Price Guide.

Read on AppleInsider

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 10
    JapheyJaphey Posts: 1,377member
    I guess we should commend Google for finally catching up to the AirPods Pro. And just in time for the AirPods Pro 2 to come out! About the only feature I feel any envy over is the choice of colors. Coral, ffs! C’mon son. With practically every earbud maker offering users color options, will Apple respond in kind? Or will they obstinately stick with only boring white?
  • Reply 2 of 10
    BeatsBeats Posts: 3,036member
    They’re ugly and they couldn’t even copy the AirPods case right. 
  • Reply 3 of 10
    No attempt at comparing sound quality = Pixel Buds Pro don't compare well. 
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 4 of 10
    gatorguygatorguy Posts: 23,380member
    No attempt at comparing sound quality = Pixel Buds Pro don't compare well. 
    Pixel Bud Pros haven't been released yet, so you could not have heard them to compare. Give it another month, give or take. 
    IreneWmuthuk_vanalingam
  • Reply 5 of 10
    avon b7avon b7 Posts: 6,227member
    "they don't have the prestige of the AirPods Pro, the distinctive design, and how they don't have the same level of integration in iOS. Still, Google's earphones do have a place on the market, namely keeping Android users happy." 

    "it's attempting to provide Android users something as similarly-featured and valuable as the AirPods Pro." 

    "This is a feature Apple has offered for quite some time, so Android users are certainly catching up on this front." 

    Perhaps these comments were tongue in cheek but Android users have had stellar options open to them for years that have stood out on almost every level mentioned (and then some). Often besting even the AirPods Pro on virtually every metric even if sound quality is often a very subjective aspect to play with. 

    I have these and they are amazing. 

    https://www.xda-developers.com/huawei-freebuds-pro-review/




    muthuk_vanalingam
  • Reply 6 of 10
    gatorguy said:
    No attempt at comparing sound quality = Pixel Buds Pro don't compare well. 
    Pixel Bud Pros haven't been released yet, so you could not have heard them to compare. Give it another month, give or take. 
    I didn't claim to have heard them. I was assuming the review was based on access to the product by the reviewer. I guess not...it's comparing actual products (AirPods 3, AirPods Pro) with a press release from Google. 
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 7 of 10
    avon b7 said: Often besting even the AirPods Pro on virtually every metric even if sound quality is often a very subjective aspect to play with. 
    FYI: AirPods 3 have the best sound in Apple's current ear bud lineup which means the AirPods Pro 2 release will need to raise the bar even higher. 
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 8 of 10
    avon b7avon b7 Posts: 6,227member
    avon b7 said: Often besting even the AirPods Pro on virtually every metric even if sound quality is often a very subjective aspect to play with. 
    FYI: AirPods 3 have the best sound in Apple's current ear bud lineup which means the AirPods Pro 2 release will need to raise the bar even higher. 
    A logical move as a step back in sound quality would be hard to justify even if the device were chock full of new features. The problem with sound quality though is it is so subjective once a quality threshold has been reached. Some may say I'm crazy but I do like to have tuning options to play around with the sound a bit. I personally hate cymbals, so an option to push them back into the mix would be nice. Basic equalization options etc. More or less Vass etc. 

    The next version of the Freebuds Pro is rumoured to launch this month. Possibly tomorrow.

    One feature I would like to see on all earbud cases is an internal Led to help insert them in darkness.

    Kirin A1 chips paired with modern Huawei devices probably already have the highest audio resolution as they can use Huawei's BT-UHD codec so I suppose even higher resolution/bandwidth could be on the cards. 
  • Reply 9 of 10
    tomottoetomottoe Posts: 6member
    avon b7 said:
    yes, but remember, those Huawei buds are listening to your thoughts . . . ;-)
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 10 of 10
    avon b7avon b7 Posts: 6,227member
    tomottoe said:
    avon b7 said:
    yes, but remember, those Huawei buds are listening to your thoughts . . . ;-)
    Ha! That must be what Mindspore and the bone conduct technology are for! :smile: 
Sign In or Register to comment.