Eve Motion 2 Review: New capabilities make up for a boring design
The second-generation Eve Motion is better in almost any conceivable way for HomeKit users, but its design is tired and doesn't mesh with the company's other products.
Second-generation Eve Motion now supports Thread
Eve has been on a roll as of late, updating much of its lineup with new designs, new features, and support for Thread connectivity. Up next is the Eve Motion which hasn't seen an update since its original release in 2016.
This new update builds upon the original by shrinking its footprint, adding Thread, including a light sensor, and tacking on water resistance for outdoor use. As always, we had to put it to the test.
Eve Motion 2 versus the original Eve Motion
Part of that smaller footprint was the move to AAA batteries rather than the pair of AA in the original. It isn't rechargeable, but it certainly is smaller.
The Eve Motion 2 though doesn't match much with the rest of the Eve lineup. Eve's other new products such as the Eve Aqua, Eve Room, Eve Degree, and Eve Button all have this clean, elegant appearance with anodized aluminum exteriors.
The all-plastic body of the Eve Motion 2 feels like it came from a different manufacturer than Eve. This comes even more apparent when you compare it against the Philips Hue motion sensor.
Philips Hue vs Eve motion sensors
Both look near identical to one another though Eve's is slightly larger and has its logo on the front.
That said, Eve had a goal when they set out to create the updated Eve Motion. The last-gen model was quite expensive and Eve reckoned that motion was too crucial to the smart home that they needed a much more cost-effective device.
Ditching the aluminum for a plastic body was one way to facilitate this.
Eve Motion in the rain
Opting to keep physical batteries was a cost decision too as it is cheaper to implement than an internal lithium-ion battery. It also aided the water resistance though. By ditching any exposed port, the Eve Motion 2 can safely stay outside in the rain thanks to its newfound IPX3 resistance.
There are very few dedicated outdoor motion sensors with the Philips Hue outdoor sensor being the beginning and end of the list. Now we can count the Eve Motion 2 as well.
Eve Motion setup in the Home app
The setup modal walks us through all of the basic steps including giving both sensors names, assigning them a room, and toggling on any of the suggested automations. It takes a few moments and the device is added to the Home app with our existing accessories.
Eve Motion settings in the Home app
In the Home app, you can view when motion is detected, see light lux in the room, and turn on notifications. It is also where you can create automations. Anything you want to happen when the light reaches a certain level or if motion is detected or stops.
Open blinds, turn on fans, enable lights, and much more. It's beneficial to combine the two sensors. You could create a conditional automation rule that will only turn on outdoor lights when the light sensor detects a designated threshold of light.
You could just set it to be triggered based on the sunset, but clouds and other interferences make this unreliable and inconsistent.
Here are some examples of HomeKit automations using a motion sensor:
HomeKit allows functionality that Apple chooses not to display within the Home app. Eve leverages this additional data and makes it available to users within its app for power users. Let's look at what benefits the Eve app offers.
Eve app with the motion sensor
For starters, the Eve app can graphically show you the history of both the lux light sensor and the motion sensor. You can view each actual data point in a list (that you could export if you chose to) or in a chart.
If the motion sensor is in your home and you were gone all day, you could quickly see via the graph where something -- or someone -- tripped that motion sensor.
The Eve app is where you can tweak the sensor's settings. You can adjust the sensitivity level of the motion sensor between high, medium, or low and can optionally tell it to run only when it's dark.
Other options are to trigger a subtle LED flash when motion is positively detected -- useful for troubleshooting -- and the duration of detected activity before the Eve Motion is triggered.
The Thread network in our home
Most people won't benefit from viewing their Thread network which is why it is buried in Eve's settings. But if you're curious, it is neat to check out.
Looking at our network, we can see the Eve Motion is connected via Thread, is located in the basement as an endpoint child node, and relayed through an Apple Border Router -- one of our HomePod minis or Apple TV 4K.
Eve Motion 2 uses HomePod mini as a Thread border router
In only a few days with the Eve Motion, we've noticed how rapid it is to respond. Despite a wide range of functionality, our Eve Motion has taken up residence on our basement steps, automatically turning the lights on the second we place a foot onto the stairs.
The Eve Motion is set to trigger several Thread-connected Nanoleaf lights and a few additional Philips Hue bulbs. Surprisingly, all of the Philips Hue light bulbs responded just as fast as the Thread-connected Nanoleaf bulbs.
We additionally wanted to see how fast Apple Home would identify the motion so we enabled notifications. Sure enough, seemingly less than a second after coming within the frame of the motion sensor an alert appeared on our iPhone.
A quick reminder as we talk about Thread, everything was not instant during the setup. It seemed that our Home Hubs and the Thread network needed at least a little time before they started reliably responding.
For the first hour or so after adding to the network, motion alerts were not showing up every time and lights were not turning on. It wasn't until we let the settings propagate across our home did everything start behaving properly.
Since HomeKit launched, there's been very little innovation for motion sensors. All existing models have been available for years and do roughly the same thing. The second-generation Eve Motion stands out by adding water resistance and Thread to its feature set.
Eve Motion outside
In our testing, the Eve Motion was fast and reliable for triggering automation routines and notifications. Thread support made a big difference compared to Bluetooth which often would have a few-second delay as it reestablished a connection with the nearest Home hub.
With the light sensor, it opened up even more possibilities outside our home. Since there was no delay, it gave us new motivation to start outfitting our home with additional motion sensors.
The box for the second-gen Eve Motion
As long as you're ok with the simple, white plastic design, the second-generation Eve Motion is easy to recommend.
Read on AppleInsider
Second-generation Eve Motion now supports Thread
Eve has been on a roll as of late, updating much of its lineup with new designs, new features, and support for Thread connectivity. Up next is the Eve Motion which hasn't seen an update since its original release in 2016.
This new update builds upon the original by shrinking its footprint, adding Thread, including a light sensor, and tacking on water resistance for outdoor use. As always, we had to put it to the test.
Design
When looking at the original Eve Motion, the new model is surely an upgrade. It is more compact with cleaner lines. Certainly more modern looking.Eve Motion 2 versus the original Eve Motion
Part of that smaller footprint was the move to AAA batteries rather than the pair of AA in the original. It isn't rechargeable, but it certainly is smaller.
The Eve Motion 2 though doesn't match much with the rest of the Eve lineup. Eve's other new products such as the Eve Aqua, Eve Room, Eve Degree, and Eve Button all have this clean, elegant appearance with anodized aluminum exteriors.
The all-plastic body of the Eve Motion 2 feels like it came from a different manufacturer than Eve. This comes even more apparent when you compare it against the Philips Hue motion sensor.
Philips Hue vs Eve motion sensors
Both look near identical to one another though Eve's is slightly larger and has its logo on the front.
That said, Eve had a goal when they set out to create the updated Eve Motion. The last-gen model was quite expensive and Eve reckoned that motion was too crucial to the smart home that they needed a much more cost-effective device.
Ditching the aluminum for a plastic body was one way to facilitate this.
Eve Motion in the rain
Opting to keep physical batteries was a cost decision too as it is cheaper to implement than an internal lithium-ion battery. It also aided the water resistance though. By ditching any exposed port, the Eve Motion 2 can safely stay outside in the rain thanks to its newfound IPX3 resistance.
There are very few dedicated outdoor motion sensors with the Philips Hue outdoor sensor being the beginning and end of the list. Now we can count the Eve Motion 2 as well.
HomeKit and automations
As usual, it is very easy to add Eve Motion to the Home app. We scanned the pairing code on the back of the device and we were on our way.Eve Motion setup in the Home app
The setup modal walks us through all of the basic steps including giving both sensors names, assigning them a room, and toggling on any of the suggested automations. It takes a few moments and the device is added to the Home app with our existing accessories.
Eve Motion settings in the Home app
In the Home app, you can view when motion is detected, see light lux in the room, and turn on notifications. It is also where you can create automations. Anything you want to happen when the light reaches a certain level or if motion is detected or stops.
Open blinds, turn on fans, enable lights, and much more. It's beneficial to combine the two sensors. You could create a conditional automation rule that will only turn on outdoor lights when the light sensor detects a designated threshold of light.
You could just set it to be triggered based on the sunset, but clouds and other interferences make this unreliable and inconsistent.
Here are some examples of HomeKit automations using a motion sensor:
- Trigger lights in a room to turn on when you enter and off when you leave
- Turn on your outdoor porch lights at night when visitors approach
- Turn on closet or pantry lights as you open the door which is more reliable than contact sensors
- Turn on patio filament bulbs only when it is dim enough for them to be seen
- Using conditionals, turn on under-cabinet lights to different brightness levels and colors based on the time of day
- Turn off a loud air purifier when you enter a room and turn it on when you leave
- Open your smart shades when motion in the living room is detected
- Turn on a ceiling fan when you enter the room
The Eve app
Before we talk about the Eve app, we need to reiterate Eve's commitment to HomeKit. Though there is technically added functionality within the Eve app, over Apple's Home app, everything still relies solely on exposed HomeKit properties.HomeKit allows functionality that Apple chooses not to display within the Home app. Eve leverages this additional data and makes it available to users within its app for power users. Let's look at what benefits the Eve app offers.
Eve app with the motion sensor
For starters, the Eve app can graphically show you the history of both the lux light sensor and the motion sensor. You can view each actual data point in a list (that you could export if you chose to) or in a chart.
If the motion sensor is in your home and you were gone all day, you could quickly see via the graph where something -- or someone -- tripped that motion sensor.
The Eve app is where you can tweak the sensor's settings. You can adjust the sensitivity level of the motion sensor between high, medium, or low and can optionally tell it to run only when it's dark.
Other options are to trigger a subtle LED flash when motion is positively detected -- useful for troubleshooting -- and the duration of detected activity before the Eve Motion is triggered.
Putting Thread to the test
The Eve app also lets you view your Thread network. The Eve Motion will communicate primarily over Thread but if you don't have a Thread Border Router, it will fall back to Bluetooth connectivity.The Thread network in our home
Most people won't benefit from viewing their Thread network which is why it is buried in Eve's settings. But if you're curious, it is neat to check out.
Looking at our network, we can see the Eve Motion is connected via Thread, is located in the basement as an endpoint child node, and relayed through an Apple Border Router -- one of our HomePod minis or Apple TV 4K.
Eve Motion 2 uses HomePod mini as a Thread border router
In only a few days with the Eve Motion, we've noticed how rapid it is to respond. Despite a wide range of functionality, our Eve Motion has taken up residence on our basement steps, automatically turning the lights on the second we place a foot onto the stairs.
The Eve Motion is set to trigger several Thread-connected Nanoleaf lights and a few additional Philips Hue bulbs. Surprisingly, all of the Philips Hue light bulbs responded just as fast as the Thread-connected Nanoleaf bulbs.
We additionally wanted to see how fast Apple Home would identify the motion so we enabled notifications. Sure enough, seemingly less than a second after coming within the frame of the motion sensor an alert appeared on our iPhone.
A quick reminder as we talk about Thread, everything was not instant during the setup. It seemed that our Home Hubs and the Thread network needed at least a little time before they started reliably responding.
For the first hour or so after adding to the network, motion alerts were not showing up every time and lights were not turning on. It wasn't until we let the settings propagate across our home did everything start behaving properly.
Should you buy the Eve Motion 2?
Motion is a critical component of the smart home. It isn't ideal for each situation, but there are certainly several examples of automation tasks that are enabled thanks to motion.Since HomeKit launched, there's been very little innovation for motion sensors. All existing models have been available for years and do roughly the same thing. The second-generation Eve Motion stands out by adding water resistance and Thread to its feature set.
Eve Motion outside
In our testing, the Eve Motion was fast and reliable for triggering automation routines and notifications. Thread support made a big difference compared to Bluetooth which often would have a few-second delay as it reestablished a connection with the nearest Home hub.
With the light sensor, it opened up even more possibilities outside our home. Since there was no delay, it gave us new motivation to start outfitting our home with additional motion sensors.
The box for the second-gen Eve Motion
As long as you're ok with the simple, white plastic design, the second-generation Eve Motion is easy to recommend.
Eve Motion 2 pros
- Smaller design
- New light level sensor
- Thread for ultra-fast connectivity
- IPX3 water resistance for use outdoors
- New lower price point
- Exclusively supports HomeKit and futureproofed
- Uses standardized AA batteries (that are also included)
Eve Motion 2 cons
- Plastic body feels cheap
- Design looks similar to Philips Hue motion sensor
Rating: 4.5 out of 5
Where to buy
You can pick up the all-new Eve Motion 2 on Amazon for $39.99.Read on AppleInsider
Comments
- Changing a battery is quick, takes a few seconds.
- Tricky to charge stuff outdoors, need to bring cable and (I guess) a computer or power bank to charge from.
- Batteries does eventually wear out. If they are built-in, you need to throw the whole device out. With batteries, you can just replace them.
- Batteries are also rechargeable. Instead of having every item in your household with built-in batteries, with separate charging cables for all of them, it's much better to use external batteries and a single charging station for regular batteries.
There are wireless keyboards, AirPods and their clones, and any number of devices where the customer can't change the battery and the manufacturer won't. Pay, use, enjoy, toss, pay...
Occasionally, maybe even rarely, a third-party battery can be found for a DIY replacement, but that's just not common.
i, personally, would take a smaller sensor without visible branding above this
but i am VERY particular about not having fugly devices in my home
what i would like is a philips hue sensor with some sort of pet detection filter