Seagate Expansion 8TB external hard drive review: No frills storage in need of USB-C

Posted:
in Current Mac Hardware
When speed isn't paramount, external USB hard drives are necessary tools for any Mac owner. The Seagate Expansion is a solid choice with 8TB of capacity for backups and file storage.

Seagate Expasion with the 24-inch iMac
Seagate Expasion with the 24-inch iMac


Seagate is well known in the storage space, building not only the internal drives but enclosures as well. Most drives in the Seagate lineup are mass-market consumer devices, while LaCie represents Seagate's professional line.

While they aren't necessarily as flashy as LaCie, Seagate devices are reliable and more widely available.

Design and connectivity

The Seagate Expansion is your typical desktop storage solution. It has a well-vented plastic body, just a hair larger than the 3.5-inch hard drive it hides within.

Rear ports on the Seagate Expansion
Rear ports on the Seagate Expansion


It connects to your Mac or PC using USB 3.1. On the rear of the drive is a common barrel connector used for the included power supply and USB Micro-B port.

We aren't huge fans of the slim Micro-B connector but they get used frequently with external hard drives. As the cable is a USB-A cable, you may need to use a hub or adapter with your Mac if solely has USB-C ports.

The included USB-A cable and our replacement USB-C
The included USB-A cable and our replacement USB-C


In our case, we just picked up one of the widely-available USB-C to Micro-B cables found on Amazon. We'd prefer a USB-C cable in the box, but plenty of people still rely on USB-A, and replacement cables are easy to come by in a pinch.

Using the Seagate Expansion with our MacBook Air
Using the Seagate Expansion with our MacBook Air


The enclosure has a striped appearance with angled lines along the plastic body. The top, rear, and bottom have hidden vents that allow airflow to the hard drive. They're in between the lines that make them near-invisible at a glance.

Because of the passive cooling, the drive feels a little hollow when we pick it up, but that's preferable to a loud spinning fan.

Finally, silicone feet are on the underside of the drive that keep it just off the surface of your desk and prevent it from sliding around.

Speed and performance

Speed isn't going to impress anyone on the Seagate Expansion drive. Not because it is bad, but because it is aiming to be affordable.

Spinning hard drive platters are going to be cheaper than solid state media, especially when you're looking for something as large as 8TB.

If you need a backup system or a place to store a wealth of files, then this is what you need.

We hooked the drive up to our Mac, and the drive was formatted in ExFat by default. As ExFat, it can work with both Mac or Windows PCs out of the box, but you can easily reformat it into the more Apple-specific APFS or leave it in ExFat for universal access.

Blackmagic Disk Speed test results
Blackmagic Disk Speed Test results


Using the Blackmagic Disk Speed test, we got 177MB/s for our write speed and 178MB/s for the read speed. This isn't fast but not terribly slow either.

In practical terms, we transferred a 1GB file to the Seagate Expansion in under 10 seconds. Again, for a backup drive, file repository, and everyday tasks, this will be just fine.

Using the Seagate Expansion with our MacBook Air
Using the Seagate Expansion with our MacBook Air


This won't be ideal for a video editing scratch drive, but it's great in 95 percent of other use cases. Not everyone is moving 124GB Final Cut libraries with any regularity.

Should you buy the Seagate Expansion external hard drive?

There's not always a need for the flashiest hardware. Seagate has a solid drive with an attractive appearance that provides you with 8TB of reliable storage at an affordable price.

Seagate Expansion in its box
Seagate Expansion in its box


You can get faster drives that have hard drives in a raid formation or that use SSD, but they'll cost you notably more. If you have no need for additional speed, the Seagate Expansion will get the job done without breaking the bank.

Seagate Expansion pros

  • Solid, reliable drive
  • Ample 8TB capacity
  • Sleek, modern exterior
  • Affordable
  • Preformatted in the universal ExFat file system

Seagate Expansion cons

  • No USB-C cable incldued
  • Uses full-size desktop drive that take up more space
  • HDD speeds

Rating: 3 out of 5

Where to buy

You can buy the Seagate Expansion 8TB external hard drive on Amazon for $164.99.

Read on AppleInsider

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 7
    crowleycrowley Posts: 10,453member
    Wait, this is a new drive enclosure being released with that janky extended micro-usb port?  And that's the only option? 

    I guess its otherwise a pretty reasonable price for 8TB, but wow
  • Reply 2 of 7
    JP234 said:
    Sure, 8TB is impressive. But do you know anyone who would commit 8TB of important data on a single drive? At this capacity, the only logical choice is a 5 bay, level 5 RAID with 2TB drives with hot swap redundant capability if one fails. Sure, it's going to cost 2-3 times as much, but what's 8 TB of your data worth, anyway?
    If your data is truly vitally important, consider also the need to have a geographically-diverse backup as well.  Unfortunately, for many, backing up online takes a significant amount of time due to asymmetric download/upload speeds with their internet connections, and limited monthly transfer quotas.

    But if you don’t add too much new data too fast, that’s sufficiently workable without shipping hard drives or media around.

    There are two main types of drive owners: those that have lost data due to some sort of failure, and those that will lose data, given long enough usage.  As I’ve not gotten into storing videos or creating them as a regular thing, I’ve not bothered getting a hard drive or SSD more than 1 TB in size since 2010 because I’ve not found a need for that much on a device.  Storage capacity has gone up faster than the combination of how much space most people will use before a drive tends to fail from age and use, so it’s a curious balance to be struck.
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 3 of 7
    Nothing wrong with using them as backup drives for home use. You can buy several for that price. When one fails, you have others. We went the hub route so we can run several drives and other stuff. 
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 4 of 7
    hagarhagar Posts: 132member
    Can we discuss the elephant in the room. If you connect this directly to your Mac, it’s going to slow down things considerably. I have a similar HDD for media files and Time Machine backups. Problem is that the drive spins down after a while and when I access Spotlight it will freeze until the drive spins up again. 

    This, combined with USB-A and Micro USB, and I don’t see how this is a good choice for Mac users in 2022. 
    edited August 2022 watto_cobra
  • Reply 5 of 7
    hagar said:
    Can we discuss the elephant in the room. If you connect this directly to your Mac, it’s going to slow down things considerably. I have a similar HDD for media files and Time Machine backups. Problem is that the drive spins down after a while and when I access Spotlight it will freeze until the drive spins up again. 

    This, combined with USB-A and Micro USB, and I don’t see how this is a good choice for Mac users in 2022. 
    Depending on your Mac port details, this is something that’d best be put on a “slow” USB port, where the infrequent devices are attached, such as printers.  Also, pretty sure you can tune things for performance, though I’ve not run most of the time with external drives.
  • Reply 6 of 7
    crowleycrowley Posts: 10,453member
    hagar said:
    Can we discuss the elephant in the room. If you connect this directly to your Mac, it’s going to slow down things considerably. I have a similar HDD for media files and Time Machine backups. Problem is that the drive spins down after a while and when I access Spotlight it will freeze until the drive spins up again. 

    This, combined with USB-A and Micro USB, and I don’t see how this is a good choice for Mac users in 2022. 
    https://osxdaily.com/2011/12/30/exclude-drives-or-folders-from-spotlight-index-mac-os-x/
    fastasleep
Sign In or Register to comment.