Brothers behind massive Apple counterfeiting scam are jailed

Posted:
in iPhone

Two brothers who conned Apple into replacing 10,000 counterfeits with real iPhones and iPads, have been sentenced to 41 months in federal prison.

San Francisco's Apple Fashion Valley store
San Francisco's Apple Fashion Valley store



The two brothers from San Diegoare Zhimin and Zhiting Liao, and a third brother named Zhiwei Liao who is to be sentenced later in October. According to the Times of San Diego, the men's wives have received three years probation.

At the same time, eight other co-conspirators have pleaded guilty and are awaiting sentencing. While not confirmed by the publication, the listing of a total of 14 group members suggests that three -- Xiamon Zhong, Charley Hsu and Hyo Weon Yang -- have been caught since the original arrest saw them escaping to become fugitives.

The arrests were made and subsequent charges were levelled in 2019. The group's operation had reportedly been running for eight years at this time, and in total had defrauded Apple of around $6.1 million.

With sources in China, the brothers leading the operation were able to source over 10,000 counterfeit iPhones from the country. They would then take the fakes to Apple Stores where they were replaced by genuine Apple devices.

Little of the detail of how this was done and exactly how the group got by Apple Store inspections of the devices. But it does appear that the devices had genuine serial numbers, all somehow copied from real iPhones.

The Times of San Diego says that between the group, Zhimin Liao personally visited 105 Apple Stores across 22 states. Zhiting Liao went to at least 200 stores across 18 states and Canada. Both attempted to exchange around 720 iPhones and iPads at the stores.

From 2019, it appears these three fugitives didn't get very far)/?
From 2019, it appears these three fugitives didn't get very far)



As well as 41 months in prison for the two brothers agreed to return over 200 iPhones to Apple, to forfeit their San Francisco residencies and return over a quarter of a million dollars.

The Liao brothers are naturalized US citizens, as were some of their co-conspirators. Their group included one Chinese national, plus various people born in Vietnam, Korea and Russia.

Reportedly the crime ring was discovered through the joint efforts of the FBI, Homeland Security, the San Diego Police department, US Customs and Border Protection, and more.

Read on AppleInsider

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 11
    I swear some thieves are so dumb, they always get caught in the end.
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 2 of 11
    jfabula1jfabula1 Posts: 162member
    Thats it?41 months only???
    ronnwatto_cobra
  • Reply 3 of 11
    65026502 Posts: 382member
    I swear some thieves are so dumb, they always get caught in the end.
    How do you know? We only hear about the ones that got caught not the thousands that didn't.
    FileMakerFellersphericwatto_cobra
  • Reply 4 of 11
    ronnronn Posts: 681member
    Kind of hard to argue that crime doesn't pay when the punishment is so limited. They made off with millions and have to forfeit a portion. And their spouses just received probation. Everyone involved should have gotten jail time.
    beowulfschmidtwatto_cobra
  • Reply 5 of 11
    9secondkox29secondkox2 Posts: 3,079member
    If the serial numbers were taken from customer phones, they should get additional time for ID theft. 

    These criminals are getting away with the proverbial “slap on the wrist.” 
    edited October 2023 ronnwatto_cobra
  • Reply 6 of 11
    chadbagchadbag Posts: 2,023member
    What is a counterfeit iPhone?    I mean, is it an actual iPhone made with real parts stolen from the supply chain?  It would have to actually run iOS to be able to get past the checks I would presume.  Even if they claimed they were bricked the fancy diagnostic cables attached should be able to read something I would expect.   Just wondering what exactly they were turning in to Apple to make this work (not because I want to try it). 
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 7 of 11
    danoxdanox Posts: 3,326member
    jfabula1 said:
    Thats it?41 months only???
    That’s how white collar (gentlemen) crime works.

    Edit: corrected by admin to remove unintentional racial remark (it's white collar, not white color)
    edited October 2023 watto_cobra
  • Reply 8 of 11
    danoxdanox Posts: 3,326member

    ronn said:
    Kind of hard to argue that crime doesn't pay when the punishment is so limited. They made off with millions and have to forfeit a portion. And their spouses just received probation. Everyone involved should have gotten jail time.
    A Gentlemen's crime, there are class distinctions at all levels of human life, and that includes crime. Don’t commit a crime, and have a poor Cockney accent, historically that’s how it works at least that’s how it was for the first modern police department in 1840s Britain good at enforcing blue-collar crime. Not so good if someone files a fake deed against your property (a gentlemen crime), then they are hopeless if you need help. :smiley: 
    watto_cobra
  • Reply 9 of 11
    AppleishAppleish Posts: 710member
    They should have stopped at 9,999. It was the round number that got them caught.
    FileMakerFellerwatto_cobra
  • Reply 10 of 11
    mknelsonmknelson Posts: 1,144member
    6502 said:
    I swear some thieves are so dumb, they always get caught in the end.
    How do you know? We only hear about the ones that got caught not the thousands that didn't.
    By your logic, why do you think it's thousands?  You've never heard of them! ;)
    FileMakerFellerwatto_cobra
  • Reply 11 of 11
    chasmchasm Posts: 3,543member
    ronn said:
    Kind of hard to argue that crime doesn't pay when the punishment is so limited. They made off with millions and have to forfeit a portion. And their spouses just received probation. Everyone involved should have gotten jail time.
    It appears that nearly all of the gang will indeed be getting jail time.

    The brothers’ two San Francisco residences, in the present market, might by themselves pay back every penny they stole from Apple.

    As for the “light” sentences, this was probably a concession in order to gain information about who at Foxconn was stealing genuine iPhone serial numbers. THAT is the person Apple and the Chinese authorities are probably MOST interested in, and I think you can rest assured that that person, if caught, will be regretting their life choices.
    edited October 2023 watto_cobra
Sign In or Register to comment.