Top AI tablets: iPad Pro with M4 versus Microsoft's new Surface Pro

Posted:
in iPad edited May 28

Microsoft updated its Surface Pro with more AI smarts as it tries to push forward in the machine learning industry. Here's how the Surfaace Pro compares versus Apple's new iPad Pro.

Apple's iPad Pro [left], Microsoft's Surface Pro [right]
Apple's iPad Pro [left], Microsoft's Surface Pro [right]



Microsoft's launch of its Copilot+ PC initiative included two offerings of its own. Alongside a refreshed Surface Laptop, Microsoft also updated its top-end Surface Pro.

As part of the update, the Surface Pro now benefits from improved ARM processing, with more of a leaning towards machine learning and similar AI-based tasks for apps. This is an area that Apple has extensive experience in, with the Neural Engine in its M-series and A-series chips performing such tasks for users over the last few years.

With Microsoft's latest hardware salvo, it's also a direct attack against Apple's long-running premium tablet, the iPad Pro.

This is how Microsoft's Surface Pro 11 looks compared to Apple's M4-based slate.

iPad Pro vs Surface Pro - Specifications



Specifications2024 iPad ProSurface Pro
Screen size (inches)11, 1313
Base price$999, $1,299
Best 11-inch iPad Pro M4 prices
Best 13-inch iPad Pro M4 prices
$999.99
Best Surface Pro 2024 prices
ProcessorM4
Snapdragon X Plus,
Snapdragon X Elite,
Qualcomm Hexagon NPU
Graphics10-core GPUQualcomm Adreno GPU
Memory8GB, 16GB16GB, 32GB
Dimensions (inches)9.83 x 6.99 x 0.21,
11.09 x 8.48 x 0.20
11.3 x 8.2 x 0.37
Weight (lbs)0.98, 1.281.97
Display typeUltra Retina XDR,
Tandem OLED,
ProMotion,
True Tone,
Wide color (P3),
Fully Laminated,
Nano-texture display glass option on 1TB, 2TB
LCD, OLED options,
PixelSense Flow,
3:2 Aspect Ratio,
120Hz Dynamic refresh rate,
Individually color-calibrated,
Adaptive color and contrast,
sRUB and Vivid color profiles
Resolution2,420 x 1,668,
2,752 x 2,064
2,880x1,920
Pixel Density (dpi)264, 264267
Stylus supportApple Pencil Pro,
Apple Pencil USB-C
Surface Slim Pen (Second Edition)
Supports Microsoft Pen Protocol
Capacities256GB, 512GB, 1TB, 2TB256GB, 512GB, 1TB
Rear camera (MP)12 wide, LiDAR10MP Ultra HD
Front camera (MP)12MP TrueDepthQuad HD Surfade Studio Camera,
Windows Hello
BiometricFace IDWindows Hello
Speakers42W stereo
NetworkingWi-Fi 6E,
Bluetooth 5.3,
Cellular options
Wi-Fi 7,
Bluetooth 5.4,
Cellular options
PortsThunderbolt 4 / USB 4,
Smart Connector
2 USB 4,
Surface Pro Keyboard port,
Surface Connect port

iPad Pro vs Surface Pro - Physical Dimensions



The iPad Pro's update brought with it a few changes, but mostly it was made to be thinner and lighter than ever before, for both 13-inch and 11-inch iterations.

The 11-inch measures 9.83 inches long and 6.99 inches wide, while the 13-inch is 11.09 inches by 8.48 inches.

The Surface Pro's 11th edition follows the same design trend, in effectively being a much chunkier iPad. This time around, it's made from aluminum alloy that uses at least 72% recycled material.

Available only in a 13-inch screen size, the Surface Pro is 11.3 inches long and 8.2 inches wide, making it longer and narrower than the 13-inch iPad Pro.

Side view of a blue tablet standing on a kickstand, showing its slim profile.
The Surface Pro is still quite thick, thanks in part to the kickstand.



When it comes to thickness, there's a definitive difference. The 11-inch iPad Pro is 0.21 inches thick, while the 13-inch is 0.20, but the Surface Pro is a lot chunkier at 0.37 inches.

This also translates into weight, as the Surface Pro is 1.97 pounds. By contrast, the 11-inch iPad Pro is 0.98 pounds and the 13-inch is 1.28 pounds.

The Surface Pro weighs as much as two 11-inch iPad Pros. That said, it does have the built-in kickstand, which the iPad doesn't have at all.

iPad Pro vs Surface Pro - Display



As part of its 2024 shake-up, Apple updated the iPad Pro to use a new Tandem OLED display. That means two OLED layers are used instead of one.

For Apple, this translates into a thinner display without backlighting, while maintaining brightness and dynamic range. That means they can go to 1,000 nits of full-screen brightness and 1,600 bits for peak brightness.

This also increased the contrast ratio to 2,000,000:1.

At 2,420 by 1,668, the 11-inch is the lowest resolution display of the two, with the 13-inch iPad Pro offering 2,752 by 2,064 pixels.

All of Apple's Ultra Retina XDR displays also have ProMotion support, True Tone, Wide Color (P3) coverage, and an optional Nano-texture display on the 1TB and 2TB models.

Tablet with a colorful abstract design on screen, standing on a blue kickstand against a plain white background.
Microsoft uses both LCD and OLED displays in its new Surface Pro



Microsoft offers two different types of display for its Surface Pro. The base version is LCD, but there's also an OLED version available.

Microsoft doesn't say what the brightnesses are, but it does offer up contrast ratios. The LCD version gets to 1,200:1, while the OLED manages 1,000,000:1.

The resolution of the displays are the same at 2,880 by 1,920. The pixel density of 267 pixels per inch just edges out Apple's tablet pair, with 264 ppi apiece.

Both displays are touch-sensitive, and work with styluses. The iPad Pro use the Apple Pencil Pro and the Apple Pencil USB-C.

Microsoft added support for the second-edition Surface Slim Pen.

iPad Pro vs Surface Pro - Performance



The M4 chip inside the new iPad Pro consists of a nine-core CPU with three performance cores, as well as six efficiency cores, in the 256GB and 512GB capacities. The 1TB and 2TB versions have an extra performance core, making it ten in total.

Apple also includes the Neural Engine in both, a 16-core chip for ML workloads, which can handle up to 38 trillion operations per second.

The key change Microsoft made in its Surface is to use new Qualcomm chipsets. It uses the Snapdragon X Plus with the LCD display model and the Snapdragon X Elite in the OLED version.

These consist of a ten-core Oryon CPU in the Plus, a 12-core version in the Elite, combined with an Adreno GPU. It also includes a Qualcomm Hexagon NPU for neural processing, basically acting as Microsoft's analog to the Neural Engine.

The Hexagon is capable of up to 45 trillion operations per second, a bit higher than the top-spec Neural Engine.

For memory, Apple has 8GB and 16GB capacities, depending on storage capacity, while Microsoft offers 16GB and 32GB of LPDDR5x RAM.

Single-core scores for the iPad Pro M4 and the X Elite chip
Single-core scores for the iPad Pro M4 and the X Elite chip



For benchmarking comparison, we have to look to other hardware running the Snapdragon X chipsets. According to Geekbench, there's a range of scores for the Elite version, with single core between 2,400 and 2,750 and the multi-core from 12,000 to 13,900.

In the case of the M4 in the 11-inch iPad Pro, Geekbench lists it as getting 3,694 for single-core performance, 13,405 for multi-core.

Multi-core score ranges for the iPad Pro M4 and the X Elite chip
Multi-core score ranges for the iPad Pro M4 and the X Elite chip



This is significant, as that means for single-core workloads, the iPad Pros will be faster. Since most tasks iPad users perform are going to be single-core in nature, this is very helpful.

iPad Pro vs Surface Pro - Camera and Audio



The iPad Pro has a rear 12-megapixel wide camera, complete with a LiDAR sensor. This is a small downgrade from the previous generation, which had two rear cameras, including a 10MP ultra-wide.

Around the front is Apple's TrueDepth camera array, featuring a 12-megapixel ultra-wide lens and a 2x digital zoom out. It's also made to handle Face ID for unlocking the iPad without a passcode.

Microsoft includes a 10-megapixel "Ultra HD" camera on the rear of the Surface Pro. It's joined by a Quad HD Surface Studio camera on the front.

Blue tablet with a kickstand extended, revealing a Windows logo on the back.
The rear camera is in the middle of an edge on the Surface Pro.



The front camera system also features Windows Hello support, Microsoft's facial recognition system for biometric security.

On audio, Apple includes four speakers, one in each corner, to provide stereo sound regardless of orientation. Four "studio quality" mics are used for audio capture.

Microsoft includes "Dual Studio Mics with voice focus" in the Surface Pro, along with 2W stereo speakers with Dolby Atmos support.

iPad Pro vs Surface Pro - Connectivity



On the wireless side, the iPad Pro have Wi-Fi 6E support along with Bluetooth 5.3, and configurable 5G support, albeit without mmWave.

The Surface Pro will have 5G options in the fall. In the meantime, it does have Wi-Fi 7 and Bluetooth 5.4 support.

For physical connections, the iPad Pro has a Thunderbolt 4 port that works with USB 4, as well as a rear Smart Connector.

The Surface Pro includes two USB 4 ports, a Surface Pro Keyboard port, and a Surface Connector port.

Speaking of keyboards, Microsoft singled out its Surface Pro Flex Keyboard during launch. It's a keyboard that can be used while attached to the Surface Pro, or detatched.

Obviously Bluetooth keyboards exist, so detached usage isn't entirely surprising, but Microsoft's solution seems to be a decent version for both connected and detached usage.

The battery capacity of the new Surface Pro is 58 watt hours, according to the company. This is enough to last for up to 14 hours of local video playback, and up to 10 hours of active web usage.

For the iPad Pro, Apple says both can manage up to 10 hours of web surfing or watching video, or up to nine hours when on cellular.

iPad Pro vs Surface Pro - Pricing and Storage



For 2024, the 11-inch iPad Pro starts at $999 with 256GB of storage. For 512GB it's $1,199, with 1TB at $1,599 and 2TB at $1,999.

The 13-inch version's base price is $1,299 with 256GB of capacity. The 512GB upgrade is $1,499, the 1TB is $1,899, and 2TB is $2,299.

Cellular costs consumers an extra $200 once again, putting the 11-inch 2024 model ranging from $1,199 to $2,199. The 13-inch goes from $1,499 to $2,499.

Nano-texture glass is available for 1TB and 2TB capacities, priced at $100 more.

Microsoft starts the Surface Pro with the X Plus and LCD display from $999.99, which includes 16GB of memory and a 256GB SSD, which is removable. There's a second capacity available of 512GB, which is $1,199,99.

The OLED version packs the X Elite, and starts at $1,499.99 with 16GB memory and 512GB of storage. Upgrades include 512GB of storage at $1,499.99, 1TB at $1,699, and 1TB with 32GB of memory for $2,099.

iPad Pro vs Surface Pro - A Microsoft iPad Pro



Microsoft's latest release is certainly pushing in the direction of AI. What it seems to have accomplished on paper is pretty decent, with higher AI performance than the iPad Pro and a marginally better OLED display, as well as removable storage.

In many areas, it can certainly be commended for how close it gets to what the iPad Pro offers, albeit using Windows.

Five laptops in blue, silver, grey, black, and bronze colors, arranged on a white surface with their kickstands open.
Multiple colors of Surface Pro



There are some elements where Apple still leads, including being half the thickness and considerably lighter. The most damning element is probably the single-core performance of the M4 chip it uses.

There's no getting past sheer speed for single-core tasks on a mobile device.

With Apple's long-time experience offering on-device ML-based processing to users, it still has a massive advantage over Microsoft in providing this utility to consumers.

Microsoft may be lagging far behind, but the updated Surface Pro is certainly a good step in the right direction for the company.

iPad Pro vs Surface Pro - Where to buy



Apple's M4 iPad Pro is discounted at popular retailers, with a rundown of the offers available in the AppleInsider 11-inch iPad Pro Price Tracker and 13-inch iPad Pro Price Tracker. Promo code APINSIDER knocks up to $100 off the 2024 models at Apple Authorized Reseller Adorama, while Amazon regularly discounts select configurations.

The Surface Pro Copilot + PC, meanwhile, can be ordered from Microsoft directly, as well as at Best Buy, Amazon and B&H Photo. The Surface Pro starts at $999 and tops out at $2,099.



Read on AppleInsider

Comments

  • Reply 1 of 6
    KITAKITA Posts: 409member
    For a lot of cases, these are still very different devices.

    The Surface Pro can run full Windows (with Prism for x86-64 emulation), or Linux, along with the vast ecosystem on both. You can upgrade the SSD, equip it with 32 GB of RAM and output to up to three 4K monitors.

    The iPad has very impressive hardware and a lighter and thinner package, but it can only run iPadOS and its very limited ecosystem and features for productivity or power users.
    tlinnwilliamlondon
  • Reply 2 of 6
    tlinntlinn Posts: 5member
    The Surface Pro is what so many in the Apple EcoSystem wish the iPad Pro to be. So much power wasted.
    williamlondonmuthuk_vanalingam
  • Reply 3 of 6
    tlinn said:
    The Surface Pro is what so many in the Apple EcoSystem wish the iPad Pro to be. So much power wasted.
    LOL...the Surface Pro is just another version of a Windows laptop with touch capability. The iPad Pro is fully customized for touch and is not intended as a slightly different version of an MBA or MBP.  
    thtwilliamlondon
  • Reply 4 of 6
    narwhalnarwhal Posts: 122member
    Windows devices being competitive means that Apple will lower prices, add features, and make faster chips. It's a win for Apple customers.

    For Microsoft though, it could mean an upheaval. There will suddenly be lots of manufacturers making several Windows on ARM machines, and to date there's been limited demand. Many of these new WOA devices will not sell well and will end up being discounted heavily. And that might tank demand for Intel machines. This would upset the status quo for big-name PC manufacturers.
    williamlondon
  • Reply 5 of 6
    thttht Posts: 5,530member
    This also translates into weight, as the Surface Pro is 1.97 pounds. By contrast, the 11-inch iPad Pro is 0.98 pounds and the 13-inch [iPad Pro] is 1.28 pounds.
    The weight is the one metric that determines the biggest difference between the two devices. 1.5 lb is borderline for being a mobile, handheld tablet device. I didn't choose the 2017 iPP12.9 because it was a touch too heavy at 1.49 lb, and perhaps a touch too big. A Surface Pro 13 is 2 lb. That really means it will spend most of its time on desk, table or in a backpack, and not as a tablet you carry around with your hands. I really didn't want that.

    So, I'd argue like others have too. The Surface Pro is a "detachable" laptop. It doesn't look like its stylus functionality is comparable to the Pencil Pro, but it is probably mostly comparable as a table top tablet, but I think the weight will have an impact there too.

    With the 2024 iPP13 model, Apple has made it more mobile with better handling qualities and better drawing qualities. I'm pretty happy about that and definitely the machine I'm getting just because of that.


    Microsoft starts the Surface Pro with the X Plus and LCD display from $999.99, which includes 16GB of memory and a 256GB SSD, which is removable. There's a second capacity available of 512GB, which is $1,199,99
    Hmm, sounds like the M2 iPad Air 13 is the proper competitor to the SP with the Snapdragon X Plus.
  • Reply 6 of 6
    danoxdanox Posts: 3,043member
    narwhal said:
    Windows devices being competitive means that Apple will lower prices, add features, and make faster chips. It's a win for Apple customers.

    For Microsoft though, it could mean an upheaval. There will suddenly be lots of manufacturers making several Windows on ARM machines, and to date there's been limited demand. Many of these new WOA devices will not sell well and will end up being discounted heavily. And that might tank demand for Intel machines. This would upset the status quo for big-name PC manufacturers.

    Window PC's are available all over the place Mac prices won't go down in fact Microsoft Ads, the Co-Pilot button, and the Recall feature will see to that or just reinforce Apples current position.
    edited May 30
Sign In or Register to comment.