iTunes Store Goes DRM Free

13

Comments

  • Reply 41 of 66
    ahmlcoahmlco Posts: 432member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by jdhayes117 View Post


    That's a 30% premium for the privilege of having legally purchased my music rather than pirating it like so many others have.



    So don't upgrade. Your old music works just fine, doesn't it?



    Besides, you're now also getting higher quality files from the other three labels, so it's not like you're not getting anything for your money.



    Think DVD to BluRay...
  • Reply 42 of 66
    hillstoneshillstones Posts: 1,490member
    After doing an "Upgrade My Library" make sure to have iTunes search for duplicates. After I did my upgrade, iTunes didn't quite delete all the duplicate items for the new ones downloaded. I had to manually delete a few of them.
  • Reply 43 of 66
    SpamSandwichSpamSandwich Posts: 30,837member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by PKGuy323 View Post


    Maybe Apple should consider its own in-house music label.



    That's been a point of discussion here before, but now that I've given it more thought I don't think it would be a smart move on their part. Musicians are a pain to deal with directly, and they need their management companies to handle negotiations. Apple would eventually get bogged down dealing with personalities rather than selling product.
  • Reply 44 of 66
    jeffdmjeffdm Posts: 12,946member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by walshbj View Post


    What happens if I upgrade to Plus now and then more songs are made available as Plus between now and the end of the quarter? How long will this offer be available?



    It's always been available where you can chose which qualifying tracks to upgrade, when you want to upgrade them. I don't think this was changed. I never had to upgrade them all.



    Quote:
    Originally Posted by hillstones View Post


    Good luck with that. You can only upgrade the entire library, not individual songs.



    This hasn't been true in my experience. You CAN upgrade the whole library, but you can also chose to upgrade individual albums or songs too.



    Quote:
    Originally Posted by jdhayes117 View Post


    I'm somewhat chapped that we have to pay extra for something that those who purchase now get for no additional cost. Over the last several years, I have legally purchased several hundred $s worth of music from iTunes. Now, to make my music DRM-free, I have to pay another $100+ for tracks that, if I bought them today, would cost me nothing additional. I get no new music, just slightly higher quality and no (always undesired...) copy protection. Although I have had the use of those tracks during that time, Apple has had the use of my funds so I think we should be considered even... If anything, I think those who previously purchased should be rewarded for supporting legal music acquisition. I'd be satisfied if that reward was the ability to remove my copy protection at no additional cost.



    Anyone else feel the same way?



    I understand, but it's always been worse. Say an album gets remastered. You have to buy the whole album all over again at the same price that a newcomer would. I don't remember anyone getting trade-ups. It's been the same with software too, you bought last year's version, you still had to pay a price to upgrade to the new version, even though say a person that walks into the Apple store today gets Leopard for the same price you paid for Tiger two years ago. The same applies to Windows software too.



    Besides, you got what you paid for, there is no social contract that I'm aware of that requires that later upgrades and remasters be free.



    Quote:
    Originally Posted by PXT View Post


    I think Apple were always right about the variable pricing and the music companies were always wrong. Having a single price always gave me the confidence to make casual purchases knowing I was paying a fixed price. Now, every time I see some music at the higher, premium price, I will feel a little cheated and this will create a little speed-bump before I hit the BUY button. I think the music industry are their own worst enemies and don't know their industry. That's why they gave it away to pirates in the first place and Steve Jobs saved their lazy asses by showing you can sell electronically and legally and people will still pay.



    But it is a needlessly rigid system, it treats a triple platinum album the same as a double rust one, and prices a new track the same as an old one. The desire to keep everything the exact same price despite difference in demand and desirability seems pretty quaint to me.



    Please tell me what other circumstances outside of what iTunes sells where several different releases were priced exactly the same. New release DVDs are not always priced the same as each other, and they dropped in price in time, but rarely at the same speed as each other. Nobody that's sane goes to a book store complaining that book XY is not priced the same as YZ even if they are about the same size. Even dollar stores aren't nearly so rigid as the pricing of music tracks.
  • Reply 45 of 66
    When upgrading tracks to DRM-free, is there a way to transfer the meta-data to the new tracks?



    I'd like to upgrade my library, but I don't want to lose my song Ratings, Genres, Play Counts, etc. Most of my playlists are based off this stuff.
  • Reply 46 of 66
    bgpubgpu Posts: 7member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by JeffDM View Post


    This hasn't been true in my experience. You CAN upgrade the whole library, but you can also chose to upgrade individual albums or songs too.



    How do you do that? It seems like it's all or nothing at this point.



    I have nothing against paying to upgrade tracks. The 30¢ charge seems a little excessive, but OK. It's the notion that you have to pay for everything at once that's aggravating people. It may cost you 50 bucks this week. Next week it may be 100 bucks.



    There should be some way of selectively upgrading what you've bought.
  • Reply 47 of 66
    jeffdmjeffdm Posts: 12,946member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by endurefun View Post


    When upgrading tracks to DRM-free, is there a way to transfer the meta-data to the new tracks?



    I'd like to upgrade my library, but I don't want to lose my song Ratings, Genres, Play Counts, etc. Most of my playlists are based off this stuff.



    I don't see an easy way to do this. I think iTunes gives you a new file without taking on the changes that happened to the old one. You can manually enter most of that except the play counts. Maybe there's an applescript hack somewhere that lets you migrate metadata from one song to another.
  • Reply 48 of 66
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by JeffDM View Post


    This hasn't been true in my experience. You CAN upgrade the whole library, but you can also chose to upgrade individual albums or songs too.



    How? I really want to know. Beside delete the tracks that I don't want upgraded from my library temporarily, obviously.



    No matter how Apple screw us over and over again. (In this case, more like the Music Industry's doing the screwing part) iTunes still wins. I just bought the Killers' new album in iTunes plus to complete the single "spaceman" Ahhhhhh I'm really a sucker
  • Reply 49 of 66
    jeffdmjeffdm Posts: 12,946member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by BGPu View Post


    How do you do that? It seems like it's all or nothing at this point.



    I have nothing against paying to upgrade tracks. The 30¢ charge seems a little excessive, but OK. It's the notion that you have to pay for everything at once that's aggravating people. It may cost you 50 bucks this week. Next week it may be 100 bucks.



    There should be some way of selectively upgrading what you've bought.



    Quote:
    Originally Posted by AllenKids View Post


    How? I really want to know. Beside delete the tracks that I don't want upgraded from my library temporarily, obviously.



    No matter how Apple screw us over and over again. iTunes still wins. I just bought the Killers' new album in iTunes plus to complete the single "spaceman" Ahhhhhh I'm really a sucker



    I could have sworn that I had upgraded only specific tracks in the past, but you two are right, right now, it's an all or nothing deal.



    I don't know if deleting certain tracks in your library would do it, because there are tracks listed that my sister bought using my account that never ended up in my library.
  • Reply 50 of 66
    ahmlcoahmlco Posts: 432member
    Remember if you upgrade you're going from 128kbps to 256kbps, and that as a result the file size will be effectively TWICE as large.



    Nano owners with limited space be warned.
  • Reply 51 of 66
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by JeffDM View Post


    I could have sworn that I had upgraded only specific tracks in the past, but you two are right, right now, it's an all or nothing deal.



    I don't know if deleting certain tracks in your library would do it, because there are tracks listed that my sister bought using my account that never ended up in my library.



    Actually, I just found this line in Apple's official FAQ section



    You cannot choose which songs, music videos or albums to upgrade individually.



    Oh, well
  • Reply 52 of 66
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by ahmlco View Post


    Remember if you upgrade you're going from 128kbps to 256kbps, and that as a result the file size will be effectively TWICE as large.



    Nano owners with limited space be warned.



    On that note, it sure makes 2GB shuffle much less hideous going through playlist randomly
  • Reply 53 of 66
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by endurefun View Post


    When upgrading tracks to DRM-free, is there a way to transfer the meta-data to the new tracks?



    I'd like to upgrade my library, but I don't want to lose my song Ratings, Genres, Play Counts, etc. Most of my playlists are based off this stuff.



    All of your metadata stays intact when you upgrade. It always has for me when I used it in the past. I see no reason for it not to work now, either.
  • Reply 54 of 66
    This upgrade scheme appears broken to me. I have songs showing up in the list that I imported myself and never purchased. Also there are songs listed separately that are also part of a greatest hits album it wants to upgrade, so in effect it wants to upgrade me twice for the single song.



    This all or nothing upgrade is a load of crap.
  • Reply 55 of 66
    idaveidave Posts: 1,283member
    I may be unusual but I don't mind Apple's DRM and I'm satisfied with the quality of the 128Kbps songs I've bought (lots of them). I'm concerned at some point I'll no longer be able to transfer these songs to a new computer after Apple decides to shut down their DRM servers. Maybe at that point Apple will just remove the authorization requirement from iTunes??? I'm certainly not going to pay hundreds of dollars to upgrade all of my music. I guess I better start burning audio CDs.
  • Reply 56 of 66
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by iDave View Post


    I may be unusual but I don't mind Apple's DRM and I'm satisfied with the quality of the 128Kbps songs I've bought (lots of them). I'm concerned at some point I'll no longer be able to transfer these songs to a new computer after Apple decides to shut down their DRM servers. Maybe at that point Apple will just remove the authorization requirement from iTunes??? I'm certainly not going to pay hundreds of dollars to upgrade all of my music. I guess I better start burning audio CDs.



    FairPlay is still in place for weekly free singles and TVs, movies, etc. I don't see these go away any time soon. So all in all your music library is pretty safe IMO. Besides, in case Apple ever wanna get rid of all these mechanism (which is a good thing for future costumers), I'm sure you will be compensated in some way. I mean Apple is evil but not quite that evil.
  • Reply 57 of 66
    dunksdunks Posts: 1,236member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Ireland View Post


    International.



    Woohoo!



    there is a God and his name is Steve!
  • Reply 58 of 66
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by hillstones View Post


    It is always available, that is how it has been done since the beginning of iTunes Plus. So you have to periodically check back once in awhile to see if new tracks in your library are available for upgrade.



    It is going to take awhile too. My first batch of songs to be upgraded only total 63 songs, a few albums, and some music video. So I might have to check back once in awhile to see if iTunes have checked my song purchases for more upgrades. But this is AWESOME NEWS!



    Just received the iTunes email and downloading my upgrade of 128 items. If you purchased an album, rather than individual song, it will count the album as 1 item, rather than each song. I will have to browse my library after the upgrade to see if more upgrades may be available in the near future.



    128? I had 1279!



    I am glad they are not all available today... even after the update of 1279, I have over 1700 songs that will need upgrading. I see the iTunes Music Store having a banner quarter...
  • Reply 59 of 66
    Abandoning DRM is great but what really interests me in the update is the switch to 256 kbps. The fact that you are forced to either upgrade in an all or nothing way is very annoying. I only want to upgrade my favorite songs not the ones that I don't listen to very often. But what really ticked me off is that yesterday i purchased an album after the announcement that was non-iTunes Plus. I just sucked it up because i thought that maybe it was part of the 2 million songs that wouldn't be updated until much later. But about 3 hours later I checked the iTunes store and it was available for upgrade. This really pisses me off. Of course you can't choose to upgrade individual songs so I'm screwed. I've read comments saying that Apple should upgrade the music you have already purchased for free but I think this is quite a stretch. But come on, atleast provide free upgrades to music purchased after the announcement. Especially because they are updating the songs in a trickle as oppose to one big update.
  • Reply 60 of 66
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by sbrett View Post


    Abandoning DRM is great but what really interests me in the update is the switch to 256 kbps. The fact that you are forced to either upgrade in an all or nothing way is very annoying. I only want to upgrade my favorite songs not the ones that I don't listen to very often. But what really ticked me off is that yesterday i purchased an album after the announcement that was non-iTunes Plus. I just sucked it up because i thought that maybe it was part of the 2 million songs that wouldn't be updated until much later. But about 3 hours later I checked the iTunes store and it was available for upgrade. This really pisses me off. Of course you can't choose to upgrade individual songs so I'm screwed. I've read comments saying that Apple should upgrade the music you have already purchased for free but I think this is quite a stretch. But come on, atleast provide free upgrades to music purchased after the announcement. Especially because they are updating the songs in a trickle as oppose to one big update.



    I think your best shot is to write a complaint letter to iTMS service. I always do that if I screw up a download or accidentally delete valuable tracks and many times they just put said items in my available downloading queue. Your problem is a stretch but hey it's worth a try.
Sign In or Register to comment.