ngrlvr
About
- Username
- ngrlvr
- Joined
- Visits
- 1
- Last Active
- Roles
- member
- Badges
- 0
- Posts
- 24
Reactions
Comments
-
Quote: Originally Posted by ascii No, I don't think I'm being particularly mystical or wishful, just talking about what people usually mean by an idea. Take F=ma, Newton's Second Law. Regardless of whether it's w…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by ascii I think I see where you're coming from now, you are working from the premise that nothing exists except the physical....But I would say ideas don't have a location. Well if you're saying that …
-
Quote: Originally Posted by ascii You seem to agree that people have property rights over their body, but [what about things inside our brains?] Yes, I clarified earlier that ideas in a person's brain are his property. Ne…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by ascii I disagree that the concept "property" only makes sense in a world of scarcity. Fair enough, but that's just a red herring... I wasn't arguing that "property only makes sense in a world of scarci…
-
Originally Posted by Tallest Skil Originally Posted by ngrlvr Again, if I steal your gold bar, and carve a figurine out of it, I've created a figurine. But that doesn't mean I have property right to…
-
Originally Posted by ngrlvr Again, if I steal your gold bar, and carve a figurine out of it, I've created a figurine. But that doesn't mean I have property right to it—it's your gold. The fact of property right doesn't stem from creation, o…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Tallest Skil Ah, so creation ? ownership, huh? Except every copyright law says otherwise. You're conflating positive law—manmade rules—with fact. If the government enacts a law that says 'giraffes ar…
-
tallest skil wrote: » ngrlvr wrote: » And what happened to your whole creation equals ownership argument? If you're going to abandon it, at least acknowledge that I demonstrated why it's untenable. Have any laws been passed in the last few hour…
-
tallest skil wrote: » What does any of this have to do with you being against punishment for stealing apps from developers? You speak in fallacies. Your original complaint was a non sequitor, followed up by red herrings and putting words in my mo…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Tallest Skil Originally Posted by ngrlvr "Having a grant of monopoly privilege does not make non-scarce information your "property"." They don't own their creations? Your respo…
-
Now you're just talking gibberish man... I said, "Having a grant of monopoly privilege does not make non-scarce information your "property"." You responded, "So no one should have the right to protect anything they create? They don't own t…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by gamingdiva Just imagine if it were different than this? How could any company ever justify putting money into R&D? How would we continue to evolve? Not sure if serious... Polio vaccine, anyone? …
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Tallest Skil Well, it's exactly what you said, so… No, you're either making things up or delusional... The whole interaction is right here written in stone, feel free to read it again...
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Tallest Skil Quote: Originally Posted by ngrlvr Having a grant of monopoly privilege does not make non-scarce information your "property". So no…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by abideworldwide It seems like people in Asia have no conscience about stealing someone else's property. Having a grant of monopoly privilege does not make non-scarce information your "property". Grow up…
-
Quote: Originally Posted by EricTheHalfBee And why is the ACLU getting involved? The market will take care of itself without them having to get involved. This. Markets organize automatically. People always buy the best experie…
-
The irony of an establishment outlet (WSJ) blasting another establishment outlet (CCTV) for putting out propaganda.
-
Schiller is scared and manipulative. Samsung "may" ship rainbow lollipops, but almost everyone accepts that won't be the case. Android 4.2.1 isn't nearly a year old, and there's an honest chance they'll ship with 4.2.2 which is quite new.
-
Quote: Originally Posted by Rogifan Why would you buy an iPhone in that case? Apple hardware, not-Apple software.