You do one. You can tell me mine's no good but I want to see a similar effort out of you. Let's see what you can come up with. I'm not done with mine yet, but at least this feedback is helping me to formulate a better final draft. Thanks for the needlessly harsh and also the constructive criticism, especially you HOM.8)
Oh, Messiahtosh/Macintosh, welcome back. Man, you've GOT to figure out a way to disguise yourself so you don't get this grief every time you come back.
This video: Well, the audio is pretty good. I think you could have summed it all up in less time, but it's okay. The problem I have with it is that the video doesn't usually follow what's being said. I can't connect many of the visuals with your words.
To the others: If you don't know why some people are getting a bit upset with Messiahtosh, I won't be the one to tell you why. I don't think it's appropriate that you base your opinion of someone by what others here might say.
For those of us who know Messiatosh/Macintosh and his history here, leave it alone! If you don't like his stuff, give constructive criticism but don't bash his loyalty to the Mac on a Mac forum! Now if he was a PC loyalist and posted that stuff here...fine.
Like Mom always said, "if you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all."
haha, well stated I guess. This is just something I whipped off in like 10 minutes, so I dont feel like its a big deal that people think its not high quality....it isnt. I just "let it all out" I guess and thought it might make a nice, quick .Mac video? Oh well, I tried.
Ok, some constructive ideas. Don't use video. Use still images and flash them by quickly only holding on ones that you want to emphasize. Make it a montage of stills not Apple's ads in fast forward.
Well most of the industry focuses on "profit and share price." Apple does this to some extent, but at the same time they want to change the world. Few other computer companies have the will and the drive to do this.
You could try a simple statement like above instead of video which inevitably gets bashed by other members.
Comments
Originally posted by Messiahtosh
Does this help???
no
Originally posted by HOM
no
You do one. You can tell me mine's no good but I want to see a similar effort out of you. Let's see what you can come up with. I'm not done with mine yet, but at least this feedback is helping me to formulate a better final draft. Thanks for the needlessly harsh and also the constructive criticism, especially you HOM.8)
serious, use slow moving pictures of apples
Originally posted by Messiahtosh
You do one. You can tell me mine's no good but I want to see a similar effort out of you. Let's see what you can come up with.
Strange game. The only way to win is not to play.
This video: Well, the audio is pretty good. I think you could have summed it all up in less time, but it's okay. The problem I have with it is that the video doesn't usually follow what's being said. I can't connect many of the visuals with your words.
To the others: If you don't know why some people are getting a bit upset with Messiahtosh, I won't be the one to tell you why. I don't think it's appropriate that you base your opinion of someone by what others here might say.
For those of us who know Messiatosh/Macintosh and his history here, leave it alone! If you don't like his stuff, give constructive criticism but don't bash his loyalty to the Mac on a Mac forum! Now if he was a PC loyalist and posted that stuff here...fine.
Like Mom always said, "if you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all."
You could try a simple statement like above instead of video which inevitably gets bashed by other members.