spheric

About

Username
spheric
Joined
Visits
290
Last Active
Roles
member
Points
4,418
Badges
1
Posts
2,805
  • EU has very serious issues with Apple, says competition chief

    avon b7 said:
    avon b7 said:
    nubus said:
    Vestager is ultra pro open markets. It seems not all here get that part. She is pushing for competition all the way by keeping competition fair. If you're like Apple doing tax evasion with a "Double Irish with Dutch Sandwich" model then you can expect to take some heat. And EU is by the way not keeping fines. Those fines are 1:1 deducted from what the countries pay and EU can't charge taxes on their own. EU is not like the US government.

    If Apple can't handle a person running things by the book, fighting for open markets, and being passionate about fair competition then the person replacing Vestager later this year will be a nightmare to Apple. The election earlier this month gave nationalistic parties more votes. Trade protectionism is high on their agenda. Tim Cook shouting at Vestager has all the way been very unprofessional. You don't see him like that when working with communist dictatorships.
    Apple has always been an open market player. 

    So your fluff piece is moot. 

    Apple operates a store. Apple gets its commission. Boom done. 

    This is how it’s been done in the history of stores to this day. 

    What stores dont do:

    A) host signs and banners telling you to go to one of your vendors house to get a shirt for cheaper. 

    B) use Billy bobs payment system since Billy Bob sells sandals in your store. 

    C) let vendors put up their own store inside of your store and not pay a commission on sold items
    and rent) 

    it’s flat out criminal what this corrupt organization has done. They’ve basically robbed Apple and then made them pay to operate other people’s marketing, hosting, and discovery. The heck out of here. 

    Try selling something through Walmart and pull these things: you’ll ba banned from selling through them and all affiliates and partners for life. And that’s what should have happened here. Penalize the contract-breakers, the thieves, and the hijackers, not the store operator. 

    Common sense does not exist in European government. 
    The store itself isn't really as much of a problem as the platform it is on. A platform that limits competitors. 

    It's not about a store in a store. It's about alternative stores on the platform. 

    As Apple has the keys to the gate it was deemed a gatekeeper. It got away with that unfair for years. 
    So, you're saying that Apple should be able to sell music through Spotify without paying them anything right? After all, with by far the largest share of the streaming market in Europe, the Spotify platform is a gatekeeper for music, and they don't currently allow anyone else to sell music on their platform, thus limiting competitors. I mean, it's all about alternative stores, right?
    What Spotify platform? Where are most Spotify users listening from? Its own platform? Is it limiting users to its own platform? 

    Are you implying Spotify has a captive audience? 


    So, you don't think its competitors deserve a fair shake inside the Spotify streaming ecosystem? Where's the consumer choice in that? I mean, surely Apple should be allowed to sell music/streaming inside Spotify? I don't get it, do you want to eliminate barriers to competition or not?  
    Strawman. Anybody is free to upload their music to Spotify. They do not artificially limit the market by excluding players from their platform. 

    If Apple had a label, that would be free to offer content via Spotify, as well. 
    gatorguy9secondkox2williamlondon
  • EU has very serious issues with Apple, says competition chief

    "Well, we have a number of Apple issues [and] I find them very serious," [Margrethe Vestager] said on CNBC.

    Chief of which is that Apple isn't paying enough graft to keep the EU off its back.
    I know the United States is devolving into some kind of corrupt banana republic where positions on courts and in government are handed out on a donation/friendship basis and Supreme Court Justices make millions in undisclosed "gifts" from "friends", but please don't assume that other places work the same way. 

    Thank you. 
    9secondkox2muthuk_vanalingamVictorMortimerroundaboutnowAlex1NScot1
  • EU has very serious issues with Apple, says competition chief

    gatorguy said:
    spheric said:

    rob53 said:
    I have very serious issues with the dictatorship called the EU. 
    The fact that a democratically elected government is "dictating" rules that all businesses — even foreign ones — need to follow (we call them "laws") does not make them a "dictatorship". 

    You'd just rather not have to follow the law. 
    Apple doesn't just follow the law, they follow the spirit of the law. 
    In this case, they're absolutely not following the spirit of the law. 

    They're complying with the letter, but adding extra levies to ensure that following the law makes effectively no difference. 

    That's the opposite of "following the spirit of the law", and it didn't fly with the EU commission. 
    9secondkox2williamlondonAlex1N
  • EU has very serious issues with Apple, says competition chief


    rob53 said:
    I have very serious issues with the dictatorship called the EU. 
    The fact that a democratically elected government is "dictating" rules that all businesses — even foreign ones — need to follow (we call them "laws") does not make them a "dictatorship". 

    You'd just rather not have to follow the law. 
    avon b7nubusRonnyDaddy9secondkox2muthuk_vanalingamVictorMortimerwilliamlondonAlex1NScot1
  • EU has very serious issues with Apple, says competition chief

    rhbellmor said:
    Whenever the EU needs money for budget overruns 
    Which "budget overruns" would that be that you're referring to? 

    The theory that whenever the EU overruns some budget, they just go out and fine someone is kinda cute.

    It's like a five-year-old trying to understand government budgeting. 
    avon b7gatorguyiOS_Guy80blastdoorMisterKitRonnyDaddy9secondkox2muthuk_vanalingamVictorMortimerwilliamlondon