Blu-ray vs. HD DVD (2007)

1198199201203204233

Comments

  • Reply 4001 of 4650
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by marzetta7 View Post


    That's pretty f'd up! You did make me look!



    Haha Finally!!!! I thought no one was going to click on it!!!



    Don't worry, it'll happen soon though.



    Cheers! haha
  • Reply 4002 of 4650
    shanmugamshanmugam Posts: 1,200member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Galley View Post


    Welcome to page 100, everyone!



    time to start 2008 thread!
  • Reply 4003 of 4650
    guarthoguartho Posts: 1,208member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by emig647 View Post


    For now 42" is plenty. I live in a duplex so it's not a huge living room. We are looking for a house. I figured the 42" would be a great tv for 2-3 years, then I can retire it to the bedroom and go with a bigger / better tv when HDTVs get ironed out a little more.



    I'm forming a similar plan, only I'm looking at 32" displays. I've finally concluded that I'll be waiting a lot longer if I go for anything bigger than that. Plus if I get much bigger than that I'll want 1080p which is another nice jump in price.
  • Reply 4004 of 4650
    bitemymacbitemymac Posts: 1,147member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Guartho View Post


    I'm forming a similar plan, only I'm looking at 32" displays. I've finally concluded that I'll be waiting a lot longer if I go for anything bigger than that. Plus if I get much bigger than that I'll want 1080p which is another nice jump in price.



    haha.... 37" is where 1080p starts (this is my bedroom TV/HTPC).... but for $100+ you can get 42"......... $200+....... this never ends.



    Since all HDM players can do 1080i/p from 1080p HDM source, you'll be happy with 1080p TV, even just for evaluation purposes.
  • Reply 4005 of 4650
    galleygalley Posts: 971member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by json View Post


    Both systems can store a lot of data (enough). Currently Blu-Ray can store 50GB to HD-DVD:s 30, but when three layer HD-DVD:s become available it will give HD-DVD the same (or actually even a bit more) storage, that is, both system will store enough for all movies.



    Blu-ray Disc can theoretically support 8 layers, for a total of 200GB.
  • Reply 4006 of 4650
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by emig647 View Post


    No I'm not sure if it was due to HOW the movie was shot. I just know that certain scenes in the movies are pretty dirty. I'm not sure why or how it's like that, I just know it's the movie.



    ahh film dirt isn't what you said earlier/how i took you to mean.



    thats different, thats down to the transfare, and BOTH formats have that issue on various films sadly
  • Reply 4007 of 4650
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Guartho View Post


    I'm forming a similar plan, only I'm looking at 32" displays. I've finally concluded that I'll be waiting a lot longer if I go for anything bigger than that. Plus if I get much bigger than that I'll want 1080p which is another nice jump in price.



    Whats your viewing distance going to be?
  • Reply 4008 of 4650
    jsonjson Posts: 54member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Galley View Post


    Blu-ray Disc can theoretically support 8 layers, for a total of 200GB.



    Yes you are of course correct! I should have been more clear. What I meant was that when 3 layer HD-DVD:s become the "norm" both systems have enough storage space for most, if not all, movies, that is, the storage space point is not of concern for the future.



    As far as I know, the only thing that cannot (easily) be improved is the maximum bit rate, and there Blu-Ray has the advantage, at least of these two systems.
  • Reply 4009 of 4650
    guarthoguartho Posts: 1,208member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Walter Slocombe View Post


    Whats your viewing distance going to be?



    We haven't decided how our living room is going to be laid out yet. It could be anything from 6 to 18 or so feet.
  • Reply 4010 of 4650
    marzetta7marzetta7 Posts: 1,323member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by json View Post


    Yes you are of course correct! I should have been more clear. What I meant was that when 3 layer HD-DVD:s become the "norm" both systems have enough storage space for most, if not all, movies, that is, the storage space point is not of concern for the future.



    As far as I know, the only thing that cannot (easily) be improved is the maximum bit rate, and there Blu-Ray has the advantage, at least of these two systems.



    The problem with HD DVD and their "norm" TL 51 disc is that it doesn't appear to be compatible with current HD DVD players. That's right, all current HD DVD owners would get the shaft if this were the case and movies began to be distributed on this new disc. "Further testing" was cited as to what needs to be done in order to confirm this--working on exiting equipment--or not. Regardless, HD DVD doesn't even have a working prototype yet and by the time they do and actually are capable of producing this disc in mass quantities, this war may be well over.



    On the other hand, TDK and Hitachi have created both 100 GB and 200 GB working Blu-ray prototypes and are well ahead in actually producing this type of disc in mass quantity. Also, these would be highly valuable for TV series to reduce clutter, and unlike their HD DVD counterparts, are said to work with a firmware upgrade to the Blu-ray players.
  • Reply 4011 of 4650
    marzetta7marzetta7 Posts: 1,323member
    Spider-Man 3 Sells 130K in Six Days on Blu-ray



    http://www.blu-ray.com/news/?id=655



    Quote:

    Sony Pictures Home Entertainment has revealed that the Blu-ray release of 'Spider-Man 3' sold 130,000 copies the first six days at retail, 15,000 more copies than the Transformers HD DVD was reported to have sold its first week on store shelves. Having shipped 400,000 copies to retailers, this represents a 30% sell-off for the title.

    David Bishop, President of Sony commented, "We are well-placed for the holidays. We got in before the key shopping season, and now you'll have more people getting into the market, as new players are launching from Sony, Sharp, Panasonic [among others]. It's our hope that they walk out with a player and Spider-Man 3."



    The 130,000 sold does not include copies given away as part of a Sony promotion to provide the title to those who purchase a 40GB PS3. Sony expects demand to increase throughout the holiday season, with 'Spider-Man 3' to remain a top seller.



    The sales numbers tomorrow ought to be interesting.
  • Reply 4012 of 4650
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by marzetta7 View Post


    Sony Pictures Home Entertainment has revealed that the Blu-ray release of 'Spider-Man 3' sold 130,000 copies the first six days at retail, 15,000 more copies than the Transformers HD DVD was reported to have sold its first week on store shelves.



    That of course depends on whose "report" one believes. Paramount is sticking to their guns on the 190,000 figure reported for Transformers' first week of HD DVD sales, saying they have double-checked the numbers.



    Regardless, everyone knows there are more Blu-Ray players/owners in the world than HD DVD players, and thusly Blu-Ray sells more movies each week. It's not rocket science, and there won't be a significant upswing in either side's sales figures until players become (and stay) at the $99 - $199 price range. Oh, and it wouldn't hurt if most people actually owned HDTVs, too
  • Reply 4013 of 4650
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Cory Bauer View Post


    That of course depends on whose "report" one believes. Paramount is sticking to their guns on the 190,000 figure reported for Transformers' first week of HD DVD sales, saying they have double-checked the numbers.



    Regardless, everyone knows there are more Blu-Ray players/owners in the world than HD DVD players, and thusly Blu-Ray sells more movies each week. It's not rocket science, and there won't be a significant upswing in either side's sales figures until players become (and stay) at the $99 - $199 price range. Oh, and it wouldn't hurt if most people actually owned HDTVs, too



    Seriously!! I'm a PS3 owner, a big decision in that purchase was BluRay obviously, but I still don't have an HDTV
  • Reply 4014 of 4650
    emig647emig647 Posts: 2,455member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by marzetta7 View Post


    The problem with HD DVD and their "norm" TL 51 disc is that it doesn't appear to be compatible with current HD DVD players. That's right, all current HD DVD owners would get the shaft if this were the case and movies began to be distributed on this new disc. "Further testing" was cited as to what needs to be done in order to confirm this--working on exiting equipment--or not. Regardless, HD DVD doesn't even have a working prototype yet and by the time they do and actually are capable of producing this disc in mass quantities, this war may be well over.



    First of all, they keep going back on forth on that...



    Second of all, they are saying IF the players aren't compatible a firmware update will fix...



    please keep fud to minimum
  • Reply 4015 of 4650
    marzetta7marzetta7 Posts: 1,323member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Cory Bauer View Post


    That of course depends on whose "report" one believes. Paramount is sticking to their guns on the 190,000 figure reported for Transformers' first week of HD DVD sales, saying they have double-checked the numbers.



    Regardless, everyone knows there are more Blu-Ray players/owners in the world than HD DVD players, and thusly Blu-Ray sells more movies each week. It's not rocket science, and there won't be a significant upswing in either side's sales figures until players become (and stay) at the $99 - $199 price range. Oh, and it wouldn't hurt if most people actually owned HDTVs, too



    The report Sony gave didn't have the ambiguity that tainted Paramount's claim. See here...(my emphasis added)



    Spidey 3 top Blu-ray seller for Sony



    http://www.videobusiness.com/article...?desc=topstory



    Quote:

    Sony Pictures Home Entertainment?s Spider-Man 3 swung to the top of the studio?s Blu-ray roster, selling 130,000 high-def units in its first six days on shelves, according to the studio.



    The studio shipped about 400,000 Spider-Man 3 Blu-ray units to retail for the title?s Oct. 30 bow, said Sony, making first-week sell-off about 30%. Sony said that does not include units bundled with the new $399 PlayStation 3.



    That street week sell-off bested the comparable kick-off frame for Casino Royale on Blu-ray by more than three times. Casino Royale, which sold 40,000 Blu-ray copies in week-one sales, had been Sony?s No. 1 performer in the format to this point.



    The top-opening Blu-ray title across studios is believed to be Warner Home Video?s 300, which the studio reportedly sold 250,000 units on the HD DVD and BD formats combined. It?s believed about two-third, or 165,000, of 300 units were Blu-ray.



    On the HD DVD side, Paramount Home Entertainment touted selling 190,000 HD DVD units of Transformers in the week after its Oct. 16 bow. Many industry sources wound up disputing that figure, however, believing it was actually tens of thousands lower.



    Sony executives said Spider-Man 3 Blu-ray is doing a bang-up job at retail.



    ?We are well-placed for the holidays,? said Sony?s worldwide president, David Bishop. ?We got in before the key shopping season, and now you?ll have more people getting into the market, as new players are launching from Sony, Sharp, Panasonic [among others]. It?s our hope that they walk out with a player and Spider-Man 3.?



    Bishop said the title sold millions of standard-definition copies during street week but declined further comment. Industry sources, however, estimated the standard-DVD version sold 4 million to 5 million copies overall in its first week.



    A number of retailers did note that Transformers sold at a brisker pace than Spider-Man 3 when comparing their first few days of sales across all formats. Paramount reported 8.3 million first-week units sold for Transformers.



    Despite Spider-Man 3?soutstanding $337 million U.S. box-office gross, Bishop said the studio was somewhat tempering its home entertainment expectations.



    ?We have a lot of historical data that says that when you get to third in a series, that correlation between box office and DVD is not going to be the same,? he said. ?We took that into consideration with our shipment numbers [in standard-def]. And the sell-off is as expected. It?s a very solid performer.?



    In contrast, Sony more liberally shipped Blu-ray units of Spider-Man 3 versus anticipated first week sell-off.



    ?We are in the phase of filling the [high-def] pipeline and have to anticipate demand,? said Bishop. ?We are getting in front of the demand of the players. On standard-definition, the demand is more set."



  • Reply 4016 of 4650
    marzetta7marzetta7 Posts: 1,323member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by emig647 View Post


    First of all, they keep going back on forth on that...



    Second of all, they are saying IF the players aren't compatible a firmware update will fix...



    please keep fud to minimum



    http://www.thedigitalbits.com/#mytwocents



    Quote:

    In other news for the HD-DVD camp, just two days after Sony DADC announced that they'd replicated their milestone 10 millionth 50GB Blu-ray Disc (click here for the Video Business story), the HD-DVD Promotions Group quickly countered with a little damage control, making sure everyone knew that the DVD Forum was close to approving the spec for a triple-layer 51GB HD-DVD disc (click here). However, industry sources are telling us that NONE of the existing Toshiba HD-DVD players and drives are currently capable of reading them. Indeed, the Video Business story indicates that once the spec is finalized, "compatibility with current HD DVD player and recorders can be investigated." According to reports from Bits readers who were on at CEATAC this weekend, Toshiba reps confirmed to attendees that the triple-layer disc configuration would require a hardware change, meaning that the existing drives are not firmware updatable.



    Simply sharing what I've read, no FUD necessary. I think the burden of proof to state otherwise is on Toshiba & Co. So, why don't they have a working prototype with TL51? Ya know if it is simply a matter of a firmware update? I think Toshiba's deafening silence on this one speaks volumes, otherwise, we would hear it trumpeted non-stop.
  • Reply 4017 of 4650
    emig647emig647 Posts: 2,455member
    We can all assume things because a company isn't up front on matters. If that was the case... then apple would never surprise us.



    I personally don't see the huge demand for the 50gb / 51gb discs from studios. Everyone is using 25gb blu-ray (for the most part), and 15-30gb hd-dvd. It is substantially more to use the 50gb discs. So if there isn't a huge demand for it, i would think that it would drop on the priority list. This is all speculation, because that is all we can do at this point.



    Personally, I feel this is for bragging rights until the pricing comes down. I definitely would like to see higher bit rate video come from the hd-dvd camp... which would require more room.



    BTW, There has been SOME news... I may have missed this in the thread because it's chaos sometimes...



    http://crave.cnet.com/8301-1_105-9776981-1.html



    So, I don't know who to believe until it happens or doesn't happen.
  • Reply 4018 of 4650
    marzetta7marzetta7 Posts: 1,323member
    John Lasseter Discusses Blu-ray and Ratatouille



    http://www.hollywoodinhidef.com/inside_detail.php?id=13



    Quote:

    JL: Let's talk about Blu-ray!



    PH: Yeah, because "Cars" is coming out on Blu-ray next Tuesday, a week from today.



    JL: I've been working with pure animation since 1981. And one of the things that we've always been pioneering at Pixar is high resolution, high-definition of everything that we've done because that's the way that you really want to see this stuff. And finally, as of Tuesday, Pixar Films are available to [consumers with the capability to] see the film on Blu-ray discs the way that we see them at Pixar for the very first time. I'm so excited. You cannot believe the amount of detail that we put into our films that you've never been able to see on DVD before.

    I had to turn my back to the monitor when "Cars" was showing since I kept getting sucked into the movie because it looks so good on the Blu-ray. I love Pixar. I love the films that we make.

    It's really fantastic. And you have the almighty pause button! So you can actually pause [the film] and you can go back to the beginning and ask, "Is that what I saw?" and actually see it. I'm so excited that we have "Ratatouille," "Cars" and the Pixar short films finally on a DVD and on Blu-ray all together on the same day.



    PH: Right. It?s something you didn?t have before.



    JL: In "Cars," it?s a world where there are no people in it. And we had to make this world believable. So we had to populate the movie "Cars" with all these [characters] in the background. We just kind of drive by them in the movie. So we created this game where you can sit and watch the movie and play the game while "Cars" is on. In this game you can select 217 different background [characters] in the movie "Cars" and learn about them - what their names are, what their background stories are and what kind of horsepower they have.



    PH: Wow. It's taking on a whole new dimension.



    JL: Yeah, it's really fun. And there?s a little more interactivity.



    PH: Now, you seem totally committed to the Blu-ray format, but we know there's a format for what's going on?



    JL: We all remember VHS and Beta and we thought it best not to do it that way. I think Blu-ray is far better technology, and when you see "Cars" and "Ratatouille" on Blu-ray you'll see what I mean. It's so beautiful and the amount of data that you can have on the disc [is great] to do your own special thing. And the other thing I loved about it is that there?s commentary. You can have these incredible commentaries in the midst of the film and they become documents for the rest of time.



    I hope this type of mindset spills over to Apple and they release a Mac with a drive already.
  • Reply 4019 of 4650
    marzetta7marzetta7 Posts: 1,323member
    HD DVD Standalone Player Sales Nearing 500,000 Milestone



    http://www.highdefdigest.com/news/sh...Milestone/1156



    Quote:

    Format backers say the total number of standalone HD DVD players sold is poised to hit the 500,000 mark by late November.



    That's according to a report published late Thursday by Home Media Magazine, which places the current total household penetration for HD DVD standalones at about 420,000 units.



    This news comes on the heels of reports earlier this week that roughly 90,000 HD DVD standalones were sold last weekend alone, following highly-publicized price drops for Toshiba's HD-A2 HD DVD player.



    While passing the 500,000 unit mark would certainly seem to cement the HD DVD camp's overall lead in standalone player sales, it still pales in comparison to the installed base of Sony's PlayStation 3 game console, which comes with a built-in Blu-ray player. (According to the website vgchartz.com, over 2.2 million PS3s have been sold in the US to date).



    Of course, as HD DVD backers will be quick to point out, the majority of PS3 owners are said to not use the console as a Blu-ray player.



    What effect all of this may (or may not) have on next-gen disc sales remains to seen. As we've previously reported, year-to-date figures from Home Media Research gave Blu-ray a 1.85:1 disc sales advantage for the first nine months of 2007.



    500,000 milestone? I thought the HD DVD group said they were going to sell 2 million players this year...pfffffffft! A far cry from that number, and further proof of HD DVDs craw-like momentum for all of 2007.
  • Reply 4020 of 4650
    bitemymacbitemymac Posts: 1,147member
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by marzetta7 View Post


    HD DVD Standalone Player Sales Nearing 500,000 Milestone



    http://www.highdefdigest.com/news/sh...Milestone/1156



    500,000 milestone? I thought the HD DVD group said they were going to sell 2 million players this year...pfffffffft! A far cry from that number, and further proof of HD DVDs craw-like momentum for all of 2007.



    Well.. HD-DVD players are comprised of:



    1) Standalone HD-DVD Players

    2) xbox360 HD-DVD AO

    3) Toshiba computers with HD-DVD drives.



    So, keep counting. There will be more standalone HD-DVD player promotions coming for the holidays. Well, the HD-DVD side already demonstrated the high demand for the format with walmart specials and I think there maybe more specials coming from HD-DVD marketing group real soon.
Sign In or Register to comment.