roundaboutnow

mike1 said:

What would be the 24" - 27" monitor of choice to pair this with these days? Anything out there remotely as good as an iMac display but less expensive than a Studio monitor?

blastdoor said:

mike1 said:

What would be the 24" - 27" monitor of choice to pair this with these days? Anything out there remotely as good as an iMac display but less expensive than a Studio monitor?

Back in the spring when I realized there would be no new Macs at WWDC, I bought a refurbished m2 pro Mac mini to replace my 27 inch iMac. 

I initially bought a Dell monitor to go with it, thinking it was a great deal relative to the Apple studio display. I was horrified by it. It looked so much worse than my iMac when I saw them side by side. I sent back the Dell and shelled out the money for the Apple. The web cam is as poor as reviews say, but the most important thing by far is the display quality. 

Maybe Apple will make a less expensive 24 inch display….

Cesar Battistini Maziero said:

I wish it was taller and smaller foot print.

Would be a life saver for table space, and mounting ass well.

discountopinion said:

Hi Dewme,

I see your points and my points were not articulated well.

Amazon seems to be abandoning Alexa and giving up on the ecosystem since it was an initial loss leader for a way to shop with Amazon that never appeared. Amazon will not continue to subsidize the Alexa ecosystem forever.

the current use cases for both Siri and Alexa merely scratches the surface of what voice based computing can offer. Children in particular love having conversations and learning. People with vision impairment benefit from HomePods a lot.

i didn’t mean for apple to aim for the price point of the cheap echo dots, I meant for apple to lean in on device local ai above and beyond what Alexa and current Siri are capable of.

As home automation becomes ever more intrusive in our lives then apples privacy ethos is a great selling point. Amazon is terrible.

the cost and price point will be determined by the capabilities of the next Apple Watch Ultra soc.

dewme said:

discountopinion said:

Ideally Apple will want to do a platform play and invest to also kick Alexa in the teeth. The Echo Dots of this world would then be painfully obsolete. If Apple can do a software only upgrade of AI capability through some magic then they will win the internet. There is a slight chance they can make it happen as current Siri models have a larger proportion of on device processing.

The Echo Dots are sub $50 USD devices that get heavily discounted during Amazon’s sales events. I don’t see Apple targeting anything in that price range and sales volume. They are ubiquitous, cheap, work well, have voice recognition that puts Siri to shame, and could probably be sold in the checkout line in grocery stores. I use mine for turning on/off smart lights and smart plugs, in-house intercom, getting weather updates, setting alarms and timers, monitoring interior temperature, and automation. None of these things require more horsepower than what’s already in them. Some of the other more advanced capabilities of the Echo Dot, including integration with alarm systems using sound recognition, serving as mesh points on certain brand WiFi systems, and in the larger models, halfway decent audio playback.

Even the cheapest and oldest Dots are more than enough for listening to radio quality music, sports broadcasts, talk shows, podcasts, etc., especially while working in the garage or shed. I wouldn’t dare put an HomePod in my garage due to living in a fairly challenging 4-season climate with snow, rain, cold, high humidity, and dust always present, regardless of the much higher price and lower functionality of Apple’s smart speakers.  Even older Echo Dot models have been updated to support Thread and Matter. How many older Apple devices are being backfitted with Thread and Matter support? 

There’s no doubt that a 20-ton excavator would kick in the teeth of a hand shovel. But what’s the point? The Echo Dot and pretty much every current Echo device is way too low of a bar for Apple to aim for. Apple also needs to figure out how to monetize AI on some of these devices. Unlike Amazon, Apple has far more options available to take advantage of, like its customer centric ecosystem. Apple has clearly set its targets appropriately and is executing on a plan that is at least a decade in process.