rcomeau

About

Username
rcomeau
Joined
Visits
37
Last Active
Roles
member
Points
215
Badges
0
Posts
85
  • Apple Watch sensor has racial bias, claims new lawsuit

    zimmie said:
    MacPro said:
    I can't see what Apple could do?  If they improved the sensitivity wouldn't that just make measurements better for light skins too, thus maintaining the differential?  It's physics not bias. 
    Not necessarily. All pulse oximeters use a measurement correction curve to convert from the amount of reflected light to an oxygenation percentage. That curve needs to change based on skin tone and possibly other characteristics we don’t even know about today (since only recently did a million people start carrying an oximeter around with them everywhere). Correcting the curve for darker skin would make readings for lighter skin less accurate, so it would need to be adjustable.
    There should be a calibration setting. 
    It may not be that simple. The amount of IR light that gets absorbed in the skin is dependant on different factors including the % of melanin in the skin. Melanin absorbs certain IR frequencies effectively so what ultimately happens is you have a lot less signal to work with. If you have insufficient signal, calibration curves won't help because you simply don't have enough photons to work with. It is unfortunate and in a way, the physics is racially biased (add us soulless gingers with a lot of freckles as well). I guess the choice is to not invent the device at all since it cannot benefit everyone?
    anonymouseiOS_Guy80radarthekat9secondkox2
  • Apple Watch sensor has racial bias, claims new lawsuit

    MacPro said:
    I can't see what Apple could do?  If they improved the sensitivity wouldn't that just make measurements better for light skins too, thus maintaining the differential?  It's physics not bias. 
    I don’t know what wavelength of light they use for these but there probably is a range in the non visible spectrum that could be used where skin tone would be irrelevant.
    Pulse oximetry depends on the differential absorbance of 2 (or more) different frequencies of IR light in the blood, specifically the oxygenated and deoxygenated haemoglobin. You can pick 2 IR wavelengths where the absorbance curves of oxi and de-oxi cross each other (typically pick one <700nm and one >800nm. Acquire relative intensity (changes in time) of both these wavelengths and you can fit them to a curve using something called the modified Beer-Lambert law to get an estimated change in blood oxygenation. You have to pick wavelengths that are on the right spots on the curve as well as what wavelengths of LED are actually available and affordable (only a new nm difference can mean a $1 LED or a $100LED due to the material in the LED that emits the light). This is not an easy problem to solve, other than blasting more light in, but you then run into concerns over heating the skin (absorbing IR light means conversion into heat) as well as power consumption and safety (too intense and you run the risk of eye damage if some fool stares into the back of the watch with the LEDs on. Not an easy fix.
    anonymouseradarthekatravnorodomh4y3sbeowulfschmidtMacocalypse
  • Apple Fellow Phil Schiller quits Twitter

    Maybe the future of social media is one social media engine used exclusively by conservatives, and a different one used exclusively by socialists. Companies with a political agenda will use only one of these two engines, and they won't even advertise on the engine that doesn't suit their own political agenda. Neutral companies may never be allowed to advertise on either platform because they will be banned by each platform if they advertise on the other platform.

    Basically, you have to pick your side before you can interact with anyone on the Internet. Ultimately, socialists will have their own nationwide VPN and conservatives will be forced to have their own too. This will finally bring peace to the Internet. At least nobody will argue about politics anymore because everyone will be on their own political VPN.
    So anyone who is not "conservative" is by your definition a socialist? Not the best way to encourage respectful and honest exchange of ideas. Have fun with the pillow guy.
    ilarynxdrdavidblastdoorAlex_Vdewmedavronnwilliamlondontdknoxdarkvader
  • VMware Fusion 13 adds Windows 11 virtualization for Apple Silicon Macs

    Still no macOS virtualization on Windows or Linux hosts regardless if old Intel or ARM. Go figure. So why would one want to run Windows on macOS? That must be very interesting reason if everything is there on Mac's and supposedly better.
    I assume you are simply trolling but no one says that macOS has everything you ever need and that it is all better than Windows. The fact that we have had virtualization for decades makes that pretty obvious.
    roundaboutnowdewmezigzaglensmuthuk_vanalingamwilliamlondon
  • Apple employee petition demands flexibility against return-to-office policy

    mac_dog said:
    Spoiled brats? I don’t know about this, as I don’t know the particular people involved. I’m glad some of you do. 

    I agree this should be handled with immediate managers. They would take the responsibility if their division fails to meet productivity requirements. 

    They should be required to prove their increased productivity from home vs office. Simple enough to do and it’s measurable. 

    Both sides should be open to the scrutiny that’s required to make this a fair arrangement. 
    Not everything is measurable and companies that reply too much on measuring usually don't do anything creative. A lot of the benefits of being in person in groups are the random conversations that spark the ideas that changes things. KPIs (key performance indicators) are overrated.
    prolinedocno42kurai_kagedewmeapplejakesFileMakerFeller